Nokia has beaten Motorola to the punch with a music smart phone that can pack 3,000 songs on a miniature hard disk drive.
But the Nokia N91 raises the same issues that US analysts have been pondering over the proposed Motorola iTunes phone ‘ namely which operators would want one.
Faultline has answered that question and thinks the answer remains the same. The conundrum is that operators want a walled garden, in which they say what can be delivered to a phone, using their own networks to deliver it. In the end some operators will use the facilitation of on-phone music as a means to attract more customers, so it may not drive their Average Revenue Per User, but it will drive revenues. And in the end larger operators will be forced to join in.
Nokia has opened the phone up for music copying from a PC or over the internet, using a USB or wi-fi connection, or even Bluetooth, and Nokia two months ago signed its first European music service client in O2 Germany. But of course the Nokia N91 can also buy its music over a cellular connection if that’s what the operator requires. This may not be true of the iTunes phone.
In the O2 service Nokia partnered with Loudeye, which brought with it 1 million tracks, which can reach the phone in any way that the operator decides, including from a PC. The music is protected from wider distribution using OMA’s DRM standard.
Given that this Nokia phone will not be available until towards the end of this year, Nokia is hedging its bets. The phone can actually be used to operate as the back end of any kind of music business model.
Some operators will go to Loudeye and Nokia, negotiate an own brand music service, where music can be purchased either over a cellular connection or over the internet and be transferred from a PC. In either case a music service branded by the operator can yield some revenue for that operator even if the music is delivered over a landline.
Other operators will insist on retaining their walled garden and will not open a gateway from the PC to the phone hard disk. Other operators still may decide to offer a subscription service to music, which is cut off the moment the phone subscription is ceased.
This, of course, is not the case with Apple. It has a music service that is already successful and it has quite strict rules that are already in place. PC to portable player copying is allowed and structured by Apple and uses a closed DRM system. So an iTunes phone may present more of anathema to the larger cellular operators than the new Nokia device.
The Nokia N91 comes with a 4 GB hard disk and headset jack, and Nokia has signed up with various peripherals makers, such as external speaker manufacturers. No doubt Nokia (or its operator partners) can copy much of the business modeling that Apple has shown works already in extending the iPod to a full featured home music device.
It comes with up to 12.5 hours of battery, supports MP3, M4A, AAC and WMA formats, and allows sharing of playlists and songs through Multimedia Messaging, email or Bluetooth, again depending upon the operator’s business model. It is not yet clear which of the miniature hard disk supplier is making the disk for Nokia, but since it has less storage than the standard Seagate device, and those proposed by Western Digital and Hitachi, and since Cornice hasn’t yet come up with a 4 GB product, it must be the 0.85-inch miniature hard drive from Toshiba aimed at cell phones which will be supplied in both 2 GB and 4 GB versions, which will be delivered just about when Nokia says the N91 is ready.
The phone has a 2 megapixel camera, email support, a full web browser and video sharing capabilities.