Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

28 September 2005

Microsoft and Intel join the HD DVD party as the band stops playing

With one apparently strong hand, Microsoft and Intel gave to the HD DVD forum by coming out with a clear unambiguous statement of support for the technology. The impact was almost immediately ruined by the other hand that slipped on Toshiba’s statement this week that it will delay the launch of its HD DVD players in the US until February or March.

The cracks have been showing in the alliance that supports HD DVD, but it has always maintained that it would arrive first and be cheaper. Neither now appear to be true, although manufacturing of HD DVD disks might be 10 cents cheaper. Perhaps.

But the fact that the old Wintel team is backing HD DVD surely carries some weight? Well not really. Is Microsoft or Intel going to stop Hewlett-Packard or Dell from delivering Blu-ray drives in their products by refusing to support them? Well not if the drivers are being written by HP and Dell? And it would amount to anti-trust if they tried to. Microsoft and Intel certainly have little control over Panasonic, Samsung and Philips.

So apart from putting their highly respected names behind the Toshiba NEC led team, it may well have little bearing on the outcome and it smacks of desperation from the point of view of HD DVD. If these two giants really thought highly of the technology, they could have influenced the outcome of the fight for hearts and minds (which is now largely over) by lending their support earlier. Microsoft Japan made a statement a year ago, but it was not echoed by its parent and Intel had never made its position clear. It looks like they are bowing to pressure from a partner, but at the same time damning it with faint praise, offering too little too late.

Already the real decision makers, the film studios, are split down the middle, but those backing HD DVD in the form of Warner Brothers, Universal and Paramount, were thought to be wavering and wanting to put back production runs until things were clearer. In other words until they had more companies on their side.

It would be a savage blow to see playing devices out with no content to play on them, so it was inevitable that Toshiba would move the goalposts back.

The ostensible reason was that this was not a delay, but a market tactic so that higher volumes would be available immediately. HD DVD players will still be launched in Japan’s at the end of this year.

The truth is that Microsoft and Intel want to take revenue and market share away from many of the Japanese consumer electronics businesses, so are always likely to back the opposition. Sony and Philips have driven the alternative Blu-ray format, which is far more dense as storage medium and more of a radical technology introduction, and are backed by Apple, HP, Dell, Samsung, Panasonic and about 125 other companies, that amount to 90% of the world’s CE manufacturing capacity.