The Marlin Joint Development Association, not to be confused with the Coral Consortium, says it is setting up a developer community for DRM.
The problem is that the two organizations have all the same members in that they are spearheaded by Intertrust, which is turn is owned by Sony and Philips, and have attracted other consumer electronics partners Matsushita and Samsung.
In a nutshell, Coral is a method for letting DRM’s talk to each other, and Marlin is a ready made toolset for producing your own DRM system for a consumer electronics device. It is also supposed to be a one stop shop for patent royalties, and it will be Coral compliant from the ground up.
The Marlin DRM platform will work with mobile phones, set top boxes, computers and both portable and stationary CE devices says Intertrust.
The Marlin Developer Community (MDC) is supposed to be a standards-setting and promotions organization but really since this is all about Intertrust technology, it makes it tough to set standards with only one technical contributor. Which is perhaps why it is being opened up to any individual or party to access the specifications now, in the hope of getting more momentum into the process.
The MDC will be open for membership in the near future when the JDA completes its 1.0 version of the specifications. The Marlin JDA anticipates that the first Marlin-based devices and services will enter the market in 2006.
Although Marlin is supposed to be an Open DRM platform, it has yet to publish patent licensing terms, which makes it difficult for developers to take seriously. Intertrust and its partners in Marlin are largely the same companies, plus ContentGuard, that are haggling with the Cellular operators over licensing terms for the patents within the Open Mobile Alliance (OMA) cellular phone DRM.
Now it turns out that Marlin will target the cellphone space and is said to be OMA v2.0 compliant. Is it likely that its license terms are any different from those already rejected?
In April the MPEG LA offered license terms to cellphone operators of $0.65 per handset and 1% of all transaction charges, to a maximum of 25 cents per user per annum, after the GSM Association said it refused to pay previously suggested higher rates. The dispute is still not resolved.
Intertrust holds over 30 US patents and has more than 100 patent applications pending worldwide and in April 2004 successfully licensed its technology to Microsoft for $440 million, after a lengthy legal dispute.