Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

9 November 2005

Cable Cos Sprint towards cable TV on a phone

When we first heard rumors of an MVNO for the cable operators in the US, we asked ourselves ‘What will that achieve?’

Faultline’s first thoughts went to the fact that a quadruple play needs to be all run across the same infrastructure in order to be economically effective. We could see TV signals, high speed internet lines and voice all going over the same lines, but an MVNO, although leveraging the customer ownership of the cable operators, would need an entirely new set of infrastructure and it would offer no cost savings by bundling it with the other three services.

In fact over a year ago, when an analyst first suggested it, Faultline said, ‘That won’t happen,’ and actually it hasn’t. Instead the deal announced last week was in simple terms about taking cable TV to a mobile phone.

Actually the plan is much bigger than that but all the other converged services which the announcement discussed, such as remotely programming home DVRs, offering a single voice mailbox for home, work and mobile phones, dual mode handsets, sending emails via the phone, are all being worked towards by every IP based network

It’s the mobile entertainment that’s not so easy to deliver, television, music, video clips, games and pre-recorded DVR-held video.

In essence Sprint Nextel will be telling its 46 million customer to go with cable, and get this clever stuff on their phones ‘ don’t go with satellite or the RBOCs. And all the US cable operators will be telling their 40 million plus captive TV customers that they can have TV on the go, as long as they don’t go with Verizon or Cingular or T-Mobile. And all of it will come on the same, discounted, bundled, bill.

In more detail, we have to think about the deal announced between Sprint Nextel and the US cable operators, as something very different. There are two ways to think about it, firstly as the beginning of a shared mobile triple play, and also as a re-use by cable operators of both their customer relationships and their existing content relationships.

Much of this comes down to a comment by Brian Roberts, CEO of Comcast, made at the time of the announcement, to the effect that all of the mobile communications revenue goes to Sprint Nextel and all the entertainment revenue goes to one of the cable companies.

In an MVNO, the new brand pays a charge for the cellular minutes, which includes a contribution to infrastructure costs, and in return gets all of the cellular revenues of its own branded customers. That’s doesn’t appear to be quite what’s happening here.

Instead Sprint Nextel pays all of those costs and keeps all of that mobile revenue. After that things get a little hazy and they may not be entirely cleared up, even after the service is launched.

Someone, probably Sprint, pays for beefing up the infrastructure so that video can be delivered to the handset. At present this is really the rollout of EV-DO onto the Sprint network, but may also be the creation of an overlay network of WiMAX in 2.5GHz, which may also be used as a delivery network to a mobile phone.

At present Sprint-Nextel, along with every other Cellco, is being pushed to go about the process of investing in another network, one to separately offer video broadcast for its customers, otherwise it would not be able to compete with Verizon and Cingular when they adopt Mobile TV.

Those two companies are understood to be using Qualcomm’s MediaFLO and Crown Castle’s DVB-H network, which will begin being built next year.

Right now video on mobile handsets using the existing cellular delivery platform offers just a few thousand clips of video, a content mix of news, weather and sports with minor amounts of entertainment, all running at 15 frames a second without any download and store required, playing on a software downloadable media player.

This is no kind of network with which to deliver serious TV, like the cable system, not when the competition will deliver twice as many frames per second, with twice the number of pixels per frame, using broadcast networks.

On the face of it Sprint is faced with the problems of upgrading to EV-DO Revision A, the data only Qualcomm designed upgrade to CDMA; at the same time as building a new WIMAX network in 2.5 GHz; at the same time as merging two cellular infrastructures; at the same time as building out a cellular TV overlay network. If it can merge two or more of these activities into one network, it would be more sure of success.

So perhaps by using the early capacity that EV-DO Rev A gives its network, Sprint Nextel may make a decent stab at using its network to deliver ‘better’ video than currently sits on the Sprint PCs network, and then later why doesn’t it combine a broadcasting technology like DVB-H with WiMAX across its huge chunk of 2.5 GHz spectrum, giving it both a rural and alternative interactive channel for pure IP, as well as a broadcast mobile TV network ‘ from the same transmitter/base station sites.

It’s not too far fetched and at least two people we have spoken to have suggested that 2.5 GHz is perfectly good bandwidth for DVB-H, and there are already transmitter products in production that could support this. This is just as good a use for it as delivering WiMAX. And given that Sprint has an extensive relationship with Samsung, which says that its WiMAX alternative WiBRO, can be used in a broadcast mode, it looks like one way or another Sprint will merge the idea of an interactive wireless broadband network with a broadcast mobile video network. This will mean having two radios in each of its TV compatible mobile handsets, but that’s the case with all existing broadcast mobile TV.

So in the end Sprint will only have to upgrade its network to EV-DO Rev A and perhaps build one replacement network, which has multiple roles and which can be rolled out in stages.

We would think that the video revenues will actually be shared and not all go to the local cable companies. We figure Sprint must have some of that money as a way to offset its network investment, but we could see the bulk of it going to the local cable operator. After all, Sprint is likely to gain a huge number of mobile customers as a result of this deal, so perhaps that offsets its investment.

There are some questions remaining that need answering? Do the cable operators have the blessing of their existing cable networks, those companies who supply all of their TV channels? In many cases the cable operators network carriage charge will be on a flat rate basis, rather than a ‘per home’ delivery, so many of these will already be paid for by the cable operators.

There is one very clear price to pay by the customer. All deals between cable networks and cable operators are subsidized by the advertising pull that large numbers of customer give these TV channels. That means that this brand of mobile TV will have to have advertising on it, and probably just as frequent advertising slots as occur on TV.

But there is another stage in the media process. Cable networks create some of their own content, but not all of it, and the remaining content comes from pure content companies, the TV studios. These will increasingly find themselves at the wrong end of the food chain and will fight against the broadcast model by offering their content directly to mobile customer using Video on Demand systems, which have to be fed through the cellular channel, which in turn will compete with the new cable Sprint duopoly.

A final point on pricing. If existing mobile TV services can command as much as $12 a month for 16 channels of TV, then it is likely that a full cable TV suit might command more like $20 a month or more for individuals that already have a cable TV subscription at home, and for those who don’t, the price might be as high as $50.