Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

9 November 2005

Scientific Atlanta thought to be ‘up for sale’ ‘ But Why?

Just why Scientific Atlanta is ‘considering its strategic alternatives’ which includes the possibility of it being acquired, is a mystery that we don’t think will be solved until after a deal is done.

Scientific Atlanta (SFA) is one of the world’s largest makers of set tops, conditional access (CA) systems and encoders for the cable TV industry, and sits in the slipstream of market leader Motorola, as the two leading hardware acts supporting the cable industry.

With solid margins, growing revenues and owning one of the industry standard US CA systems, the company also appears poised for growth on the back of major contracts with the US RBOCs and has a rumored $195 million equipment deal for the first part of SBC Communication’s IPTV rollout, beginning early next year.

That said there were various reports this week which initially stemmed from that fact that SFA had failed to announce a buy back of its own shares in recent filings. Companies can only buy back shares if they are solvent and have to apply a solvency test, which demonstrates that it has ‘distributable reserves’ with which to pay for them. On the surface SFA appears to have $1.6 billion of funds it can call on, but mysteriously it added in a financial filing that it was in possession of ‘material non-public information related to certain issues’ which prevented it from repurchasing shares.

The implication is that SFA has what is referred to in financial circles as a ‘black hole,’ an unspecified significant downside.

US companies cannot sell or buy their own stock when they hold secret, material information which investors would deem significant such as buying another company, being sold or details of a fraud.

It’s not at all obvious where this black hole has come from. But the most likely is the residue of concern about the stock frauds that were perpetrated at Adelphia, when it was implied that Scientific Atlanta and Motorola both had executives that allowed Adelphia to misreport costs associated with their equipment and so inflate the Adelphia numbers.

In August last year Motorola and Scientific Atlanta were both hit with lawsuits from investors in Adelphia Communications, the cable operator that had been operating in bankruptcy for the previous two years.

The suits claim that both companies aided the accounting fraud that pushed the operator into bankruptcy by getting involved in deals that made Adelphia’s revenues and costs seem higher than they were.

The two suppliers were named in a class-action suit in federal court in the Southern District of New York.

The complaint is built around circular transactions and cross charging mechanisms from way back in 2000 and 2001. Details of the transactions came out at the trial of John and Timothy Rigas, who were convicted of accounting fraud.

The claim is that both companies inflated the price of their set-tops by agreement with the Rigas family. At the time Motorola said it wanted to investigate the complaint, but Scientific Atlanta issued a rebuttal saying it had never been involved. While that complaint might come back to bite SFA, it is not in the interests of the SEC to have one stock crumble as part of an investigation into the bankruptcy of another. Of course the SEC may actually be powerless here and the courts may have to decide this one. But the ‘material event’ could only be a negotiated settlement and the amount of that is unlikely to absorb all of SFA’s cash supply. Also it would also act as a drag on Motorola’s stock price if it went through a similar settlement, which has yet to show anywhere in its share price.

But then again Motorola has far more money in the bank, totaling over $12 billion, compared to SFA.

And given that the overstatement of revenues at Adelphia only totaled $95 million, the increase in its stock value couldn’t be more than two or three times that amount, so perhaps the two could share a $400 million fine, in which case both would just come out and announce it.

Of course if the senior management were implicated, then the potential for loss of leadership as those people exited, might rock the SFA share price considerably.

But one item in SFA filings said that it had put aside just $20 million for a ‘tentative settlement,’ which would make no dent at all, and not even make it worth a mention.

Other areas of potential black holes are that one or more of SFA’s major customers has decided not to buy from it any more, and that would mean Cablevision and Time Warner Cable had found alternative sources of supply.

Back in June, UK set top maker Pace introduced something called Engine Ware which got both Pace and Comcast very excited, as this was designed to free the US cable operators from reliance on the Motorola and SFA proprietary CA systems.

Engine Ware is a layer of software running over standard hardware that can run both conditional access systems and both of the EPGs, as well as OCAP (OpenCable Applications Platform). This landed Pace a deal of between $375 million and $550 million in set tops and the bulk of it will come out of the Motorola-SFA hegemony.

Pieces of software like Engine Ware undermine the market control of the proprietary conditional access systems, and if Comcast finds it attractive, the same type of undermining of SFA control might also occur, whether this is from Pace, or another supplier, at its biggest customers Cablevision and Time Warner Cable.

But even so, just doing a bit less business at some unspecified point in the future, is rarely a basis for selling your company.

The consensus in reports from various US papers including the Atlanta Business Chronicle, is that Credit Suisse First Boston and Evercore Partners were brought on earlier this summer to explore strategic options, and that a deal to sell all or part of the business may be struck by the end of this year.

Immediately all the usual suspects have been lined up as buying the company including Sony, Samsung, Cisco, and Alcatel and Panasonic.

Alcatel doesn’t want to be in the set top business, Sony has enough problems on its plate but has tried two or three times to get into the US cable business. Also Sony is considered an enemy by Microsoft, which is driving the Telco TV technology at SBC and other RBOCs in the US. SFA might lose the SBC deal if it was owned by Sony.

Samsung tends to only sell through OEM in the US, and likes to remain agnostic of any software or security feature, such as conditional access, which leaves Panasonic and Cisco.

There’s quite a lot of buzz about the idea of Cisco buying SFA and it now has a history of buying one ‘consumer electronics’ business in Denmark’s KiSS, which it bought for $61 million earlier this year to merge with its Linksys division.

Perhaps, goes the logic, Cisco has seen a lot of promise in the KiSS Linksys deal and wants to scale it up. Even so, scaling it up by over 30 time the size is quite a material purchase.

Another rumor is that SFA is buying tiny competitor Terayon Communication, but this is roughly a $100 million revenue business, a 5% hike in SFA revenues at its current run rate. Again, hardly significant and a deal that would not merit appointing both Credit Suisse First Boston and Evercore Partners. And anyway, previous statements from SFA about it not having any plans for a major acquisition seem to negate this.

Yet another, more outlandish type of rumor, has been that Apple may buy the company, and Apple does have the share price weight to buy someone right now. But given that acquiring companies always lose some share value, and that Steve Jobs has all his new shares in Apple vesting in the Spring, we can’t see him doing something this out of character, at this critical time.

However a more creative deal with Apple, that does not involve acquisition, but some form of partnership (such as letting SFA have the Fairplay DRM and taking programming off the set top to a video iPod) would certainly be logical. That might involve SFA getting rid of a few bits and pieces prior to such a deal. Something like that, which is not so much a Black Hole as an opportunity, could still give a reason to not buy back shares. Buying them cheap when they were about to rise, on insider knowledge, may make investors feel cheated.

Apple was an initial investor in SFA’s PowerTV company a while back. PowerTV is an operating system specifically designed for digital interactive set-tops, with HTML driven middleware, web-surfing, e-mail and other applications and already nine million homes have the core software sitting on their set tops, so the two companies have some common ground.

There is a culture clash against Motorola, and SFA staff would leave in droves if this deal was considered, but it would be foolish not to ask them.

The big problem for SFA management right now is that the company was valued at $5.3 billion when this idea was first discussed and it has now gone higher. This is only on revenues of $1.9 billion, and that ratio of 3 times revenues may be too high for anyone but Cisco and Motorola to consider.

Just to think laterally for a second, what about a merger with ambitious French group Thomson, which is far larger and has a strong Europe against a weak US, and vice-versa in SFA? But the problem here is that the two companies have similar valuations, despite Thomson being far larger. SFA shareholders would end up feeling like they ‘stole’ half of the combined company.

Finally the idea that SFA might buy little struggling TiVo is somewhat attractive, but this would not preclude it from buying its own shares and given that SFA uses patents from a competing company, rather than those of TiVo’s, this might be counter cultural.

All will be revealed by Christmas and we’ll come back to this if any more emerges sooner.