Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

9 November 2005

Grokster settles, joins eDonkey and Bit Torrent going straight

And so farewell to Grokster, once the leading light in P2P file sharing, now permanently out of that business. It has settled in a US court with a $50 million payout to the entertainment industries, which probably won’t even pay all of their legal fees, and a promise to stop issuing the current version of its software that allowed file swappers to swap copyrighted files.

This is the second major P2P closure in as many weeks, the previous high profile exit being eDonkey. The closures come on the back of the Supreme Court decision in June this year, that there was enough evidence under existing laws to find most file sharing networks guilty of encouraging copyright abuse.

It’s not quite clear what Grokster is now planning to do. Back in September it was believed to be in advanced discussion with the RIAA over clearing its name and starting life as a legitimate service, but also planned to fall into the waiting arms of Mashboxx, which was to acquire the business to merge it into its own legal file sharing service.

That deal with Mashboxx has not been mentioned anywhere, but at the Grokster web site a statement reads:

‘The United States Supreme Court unanimously confirmed that using this service to trade copyrighted material is illegal. Copying copyrighted motion picture and music files using unauthorized peer-to-peer services is illegal and is prosecuted by copyright owners.

‘There are legal services for downloading music and movies. This service is not one of them. Grokster hopes to have a safe and legal service available soon.’

There is then a link to something called Grokster 3G (despite the name there doesn’t appear to be any link with cellular 3rd generation networks, although who knows?). This is described as coming soon to a desktop near you, ‘a safe, secure & legal P2P experience,’ so the Mashboxx deal may still be on, or Grokster may be going it alone (but has no content deals, so perhaps not). Also recently the authors of Bit Torrent, a piece of file sharing software which was particularly good at swapping large video files, have formed into a company which will support legal file sharing.

There are the usual glowing and fairly smug quotes from the music industry dropped into most news stories about this closure, saying how good this all is, but the mopping up operation, as in Iraq, may be more messy than the original campaign. Despite two high profile closures, other P2P systems, such as Sharman Networks’ Kazaa and Streamcast Networks’ will battle on. Streamcast was a co-defendant in the legal action with Grokster, and runs the Morpheus system.

Also given the nature of P2P software, once installed it can operate without the support of a core organization, so residual file sharing using those systems that have closed down, will continue for some time, perhaps years.