An entertaining paper on electronic, or as they call them, interactive, program guides (IPG), came to our attention this week from The Diffusion Group (TDG).
The thrust of the paper, an executive summary of which can be downloaded from the TDG site, is that if you consume entertainment in different, more complex and fragments ways, then the IPG needs to keep up.
TDG’s answer is that a personalized IPG which they call a Personalized Entertainment Guide or PEG, comes into existence, probably as a server centric tool, which can cope with broadcast, cable and satellite TV, mobile TV, DVRs, and broadband services including IPTV.
‘What will emerge is a ‘personal entertainment guide’ or PEG that capitalizes on many of the techniques pioneered on the web in the areas of search, behavior prediction, and distributed computing and thus be more attuned to the viewer’s preferences and capable of spanning a multitude of consumer devices, both stationary and portable,’ said Colin Dixon, author of the white paper and senior analyst with The Diffusion Group.
TDG even goes so far as to say that such a platform will reach 800 million viewers by 2010 and generate $1.4 billion in licensing revenue and suggests three golden rules for such a PEG, these are 1) Know the viewer 2) Work from wherever the viewer is and 3) Keep it simple (for the viewer).
These rules are meant to deal with mobility, place shifting, time shifting and broadband.
Now we are not decrying this report (we have only seen the executive summary) but there are an awful lot of complications to be overcome before anything like this can come into existence.
Let’s treat this like a crime. The proponent will need the motive, the means and the opportunity.
Apple only wants you to be able to navigate all of the music on iTunes and all of the content in your iPod. Apple wants to keep how it does it to itself and keep it a secret or at least apply for it to become its intellectual property, as it represents some of its differentiation. It has no experience in putting software onto a mobile phone (although it might work with Motorola), and no experience in putting things onto set tops or onto VoD servers or head ends. It has never written an IPG and it tends to be hostile when other companies try to break through its Fairplay DRM system to include the iPod in any industry move. And if content was available everywhere, then what would be the point of an iPod. And yet any PEG would need to take in the music and video stored on local copies of iTunes or the iPod. So that’s a tough one on means and opportunity
Comcast currently has one of the biggest motives, as it wants to offer a way to navigate cable TV, VoD, allow its customers access to it on the road, and on portable players. Comcast is known to be interested in putting its cable programming onto mobile phones through a tie up with Sprint and a bunch of other cable operators. Perhaps Cable Labs would put out a specification for such a software service. Perhaps Motorola, the dominant force in US cable set tops might help out using its mobile expertise. It might, but it holds its set top position by dint of control of its conditional access system and it has take about 5 years for it to license the first set top maker, Pace Microsystems, to operate with Motorola head ends. Comcast would be fine sharing whatever it came up with among other cable operators, but if it suddenly found the same software being used by the US RBOCs on their mobile phones and IPTV environments, it would be furious, so like Apple it would want secrecy and is more likely to be a follower here than a leader.
Microsoft would build such a thing as a set of web services which are self declaring to other server based web services so that an IPTV head end could hand over data to a piece of middleware that would communicate with other similar services which might drive cellular services. The resultant systems might extract favorites lists for both cellular TV, portable Media Centers, IPTV, cable systems and even satellite TV where it was linked to a Media Center. But it could only do this on mobile phones that run Windows Mobile or with operators that are happy to report data back to a clearing house. It would be stymied on handsets make by competitors like Nokia, and on iPods and the Sony PSP, which are the portable players of choice by a long way.
In fact this week one report in BetaNews had it that Microsoft is already working on a system like the Slingbox, designed to give access to home TV for road warriors through their Mobile phones. But this was only if that mobile phone happened to be one of the 1% or less Windows Mobile devices.
Gemstar TV Guides, now they have a real motive to put out something like this and they already made more than TDF is forecasting this market to be worth, out of licensing both data and intellectual property in the form of EPGs. But in order to establish its position it had to go through a period when it was the most litigious company on the face of the planet, so not everyone likes the company.
The data for what each channel is showing on TV is given automatically to each broadcaster. To get in into an EPG they must drop it into middleware. In the end they also publish it publicly or license it to Gemstar which provides the means for CE companies to display it on their devices.
Gemstar no longer gets so much of its money for knowing what’s on TV, but for the technology licensed to display it, because every program except in a broadcast system declares itself to the operator. But Gemstar has no leverage over Cellcos or over handset makers, no understanding of broadband middleware. It has the motive by neither opportunity or means.
News Corp looks after its own EPG, it has a new interest in broadband and internet properties, and it has a partnership with Vodafone for taking some of its sports channels to mobile phones. It has some technology in its conditional access subsidiary NDS which has its own MediaHighway middleware, which has been adapted for satellite, IPTV and OCAP cable and dropped into broadcom chips. NDS also works with Mobile DRM. News Corp will certainly do something like a PEG, merging at least broadband and satellite, with perhaps some innovative search technology. If it partners with Vodafone and a technology partner or two such as a handset maker, it might also foray in to the mobile market, but any system it offers will be shunned by the major US cable operators.
For each of the potential giants that already exist in media, in mobile, in broadcasting and in broadband, there are obstacles to producing technology for a PEG where that technology is shared with others, and where it is politically acceptable across the entire segment. We agree that they will be attempted, but we cannot agree that a firm forecast can be made quite yet.
One thing that we think TDG has missed is that there is a candidate that is not server centric which fits in with all of their three rules, know the viewer, work anywhere and keep it simple.
The mobile phone is rapidly becoming the ultimate presence engine. People always carry it and it will soon have wireless connectivity to other services, either wi-fi, or more likely ultra wide band, in particular wireless USB connections.
Once the mobile phone is talking to a TV set, it could be used both as a TV remote and also a way of measuring who else from a particular family is present in the home when the TV is on. It can already keep track of whatever you watch on your mobile TV and there are devices (such as the Slingbox) which take a look at what’s on TV and send either the content or the EPG data over a broadband line to wherever the phone owner is and without needing to work with the TV operator to do so. The same is true for a mobile phone being used to set a recording running on a remote DVR and play it back at a later date.
And of course a mobile will shortly be able to work with the web, and view any broadband based EPG data.
Keeping it simple is really about navigating 300 TV channels, perhaps 40 or so mobile channels, god knows how many web sites that deliver video, as well as your own DVR content.
The truth is the no-one wants to watch TV channels. They want to watch individual programs and the humble EPG really only needs to be retained for that most boring of times when we are looking for something to watch when we don’t yet know what is it that we want to watch. Increasingly that situation goes away. Just the arrival of DVRs means that our first port of call is to look at the programs we’ve stored and never look again at the EPG (except to store some more). In the online world we can store searches in a video search engine and repeat and link them, which will take us to individual content.
The other thing we look at are channels preferences lists and content preferences.
If we try to build out something more sophisticated from the preference list on a TV system we might get somewhere, but it depends upon how this is weighted and scored.
Many US households have anywhere up to 4 TVs, with 2 or 3 on at any one time, in many instances with no-one watching them. How do we aggregate the lists if they simply sit on unlinked set tops? And also if a preference channel is scored by the length of time each channel is viewed then what would result is a preference list containing programming that no-one in household even likes just because TVs are left on. In IPTV preferences lists can be created due to channel change commands and sounds and mute commands. If no-one is there in front of the TV, there are no commands issued.
Even using a mobile phone (unless it is also used for channel change) to indicate preference, there are limitations. People only ever turn their phone off or put it away, when they are in their home (not everyone, but some do) and that’s just when you need them on for the generation of honest viewing preferences.
So what we are likely to be looking for is a search engine rather than an adaptation of a preferences list or a recommendation engine. We need instead a search engine that can search video, but not all video, one that can be limited to the specified channels that we each have access to and which can store these channels as a profile. Perhaps this idea would need to be married to a suggestions engine fed by a personal preferences list that can be edited, and which lives somewhere very private, like on a mobile phone behind a PIN number.
The idea of video preferences, including adult male online viewing preferences that they’d rather keep quiet about, being looked after on a remote server that the entire family has access to, that cannot be edited, might leave some consumers with a chilling feeling of big brother.
That probably leaves us with a service hosted on both Google and mobile Google, sat on a Nokia or Motorola mobile, with preferences editing.
But that’s still all too vague to forecast quite yet.