Over the past few weeks Verizon has been touting the idea that it buys the 50% of Verizon Wireless that Vodafone owns. Vondafone, beset my small minded shareholders, has been encouraged to take the money from such a deal and pay down some debt and give the rest back to shareholders.
Vodafone shareholders are unadventurous UK institutions that have been more than well served by the old buccaneering days during which Vodafone acquired its way into becoming the biggest mobile phone company in the world. The new management at Vodafone is torn between continuing in the tradition of the legendary Chris Gent, who made Vodafone what it is today, and doing as they are told by shareholders.
Perhaps what they should consider is something more in keeping with Gents management style. Verizon shouldn’t mount a bid for the 50% of Verizon Wireless it doesn’t own, but instead announce a genuine merger of equals between the two giants (actually Vodafone is worth quite a bit more than Verizon).
This serves Vodafone by making it a US company. It can then replace many of its traditional UK institutional investors with more understanding US investors. It would also give Vodafone the first landline partner that convergence suggests it may one day need. Verizon would suddenly have a global brand (it should continue to operate as Vodafone outside of the US) and could target a convergence vision in the biggest telecom using countries, where it could mount more acquisitions. Its future strategy would then take in the quadruple play of mobility, fixed voice, internet access and entertainment services such as IPTV and mobile TV services.
Unless Vodafone adopts an aggressive strategy to do something radical, it risks becoming a cash cow in a marketplace that responds to adventurers, not risk averse institutions.