A senior Cisco executive has come out openly and said that it is going after Alcatel in the IPTV market, with Cisco veteran Mike Volpi telling Business Week this week that IPTV is one of its key focuses going forwards.
Just a week after Faultline reached the conclusion that financially Cisco had no further need of acquisitions, and that it must use the acquisition of Scientific Atlanta to attempt any domination of the digital home market, it has virtually come out and said just that.
Volpi said that on the subject of IPTV it is not a matter of if it goes mainstream, but rather when, and went on to say buying Scientific-Atlanta was one step toward a complete end to end IPTV solution going up against Alcatel, and initially focusing on Europe.
That could also mean that Cisco has to also go up against Microsoft, which has been seen to partner Alcatel on IPTV, though initially, to us, it looks like Cisco just fits in right alongside the two.
Alcatel doesn’t make routers, nor set tops, nor head ends, and Cisco with Scientific Atlanta is pretty well placed to fill out the equipment roster at Microsoft Alcatel customers. The only thing stopping that is the lead role that Alcatel has taken in building the AT&T and others networks, which is a role Cisco might want. As a result Alcatel may simply choose to ignore Cisco as a supplier.
However Alcatel is making more devices which route traffic. One of the key issues in modern IPTV networks is the fact that DSLAMs are having to evolve from simple bridges to routers, as the multiplicity of destinations on the access side, in the home and on the service delivery side, have risen. Traffic comes from multiple places in the core network and goes to multiple places in the home, and the result is a huge increase in routed traffic.
Broadband upgrades to telco networks have only put bridges between the ADSL modem in the home and a remote access server, on a best effort basis.
As IPTV has emerged over broadband, complexity is driven through the core network, with the provision of Quality of Service, IP tunneling needing to be carried out by complex and powerful MPLS routers and with the DSLAM taking on some of the routing function. All of this has had to be supplied on a one to one basis, that Alcatel calls Wire Speed, which means, quite simply, a network has the capacity to backhaul or deliver to every node on the network at the maximum speed that each wire will carry.
Best effort internet could be supplied on a 20:1 contention ratio. IPTV must be supplied in a 1:1 ratio.
So more and more equipment that Alcatel has been building eats right into the heart of Cisco, and if Alcatel comes to dominate IPTV globally, Cisco is scared it will also dominate the outer edges of IP networks.
Cisco routers have been used exclusively in the famous Italian Fastweb IPTV system, although most other installations have so far shunned Cisco, suggesting that other devices are more reliable and carrier class.
Volpi naturally told Business Week that it is not the US (where Alcatel is clearly winning) where IPTV adoption will be fastest, but in
Japan, Korea and Italy (where Cisco has some sway).
Another Cisco executive, Dan Scheinman, was also heard in the Wall Street Journal this week saying that Cisco plans to make the Scientific-Atlanta set-top box ‘an even more integral part of viewing and listening to media which will do network switching, routing, wireless net access and VoIP.’ So perhaps one way to take the prominence out of the DSLAM role is to move networking jobs even further out to the network edge and into the home device.
Given that the Scientific Atlanta set top family is one of those chosen to work with the Microsoft IPTV software at AT&T, it might be that Cisco will try to oust Alcatel as the sole partner for Microsoft IPTV, rather that set up in opposition to Microsoft’s way of doing things.
Separately Cisco this week made an investment into Moviebeam, the datacasting set top idea that Disney dumped after it ate more than $100 million of its money.
Cisco invested alongside Intel and venture capitalists the Mayfield Fund, Norwest Venture Partners and Vantage Point Venture Partners, putting a total of $48.5 million into MovieBeam.
MovieBeam was conceived as a set top that would host 100 films and have 10 of these changed each week using spare TV broadcasting capacity to deliver the updates, with the films viewed on a rental basis.
It makes a lot of sense to an IPTV strategy if films can be downloaded to such a device over the internet, and Cisco might consider this an important part of a future Scientific Atlanta strategy, to offer download to view films over the internet from such a service on SA set tops.
Disney’s management of MovieBeam was pretty much an unmitigated disaster, with trials suspended last year because customers just didn’t like the idea of having yet another set top in the home or the pricing scheme. Embedding the function in an SA set top or an Intel PC makes far more sense, with delivery over broadband rather than using the spare broadcasting capacity of TV stations.
In the meantime this week Scientific Atlanta said it would acquire UB Video, a compression specialist in technologies for digital video encoding, on undisclosed terms.
The two companies have been working together for the past two years and the deal is said to substantially improve Scientific-Atlanta’s intellectual property portfolio in codecs.