Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

8 March 2006

US senator pushes new law to stop two tier internet

US Senator Ron Wyden has introduced an act that he thinks is going to save the internet, called the ‘Internet Nondiscrimination Act of 2006.’

The idea is that network operators will be prevented from charging some companies a fee for faster delivery of content to their own customers. The implication being that companies like the RBOCs and especially the merged Bellsouth and AT&T, might soon offer a fast lane and a slow lane into the home, artificially giving more bandwidth to paying applications such as Google and Amazon ‘ if they agree to pay – and less to other internet services.

Ed Whitacre, CEO of AT&T and an outspoken critic of those companies taking a ‘free ride’ to his customers, is known to be thinking along these lines. Of course the argument also applies that customers have been charged a fair rate for broadband and has every right to get what he or she wants over the internet, at best effort speeds.

But it’s like charging fast cars more to use the roads. They don’t have to be any wider or stronger and it doesn’t cost more to build the roads for the fast cars to use them, but it can be argued that the faster cars are getting more for their money because they are covering more ground.

We are always worried about US legislation being introduced that will effect the future of the internet. Certainly there have already been some roadblocks as operators try putting data limits on services in most parts of the world. A certain discount price for a certain number of Gigabytes. These services have tended to act as introductory services, and have not been offered to the point where they are excluding all you can eat services. Offering internet services with a service level agreement, guaranteeing faster delivery will mean subordinating other internet traffic and holding it back.

The US legislators will have to be very careful here. The traffic often belongs not to someone like Google, but to an ISP or internet hub carrier who already pays attachment rates. So AT&T would have to pick out some traffic from a paying customer, and give it privileged access over other traffic from the same paying customer. It won’t make a lot of sense and it will be horrendous to police.

AT&T mostly only controls the last mile, and this is where any tollbooths would need to be put up. AT&T might go to a lot of trouble to identify privileged traffic as it comes onto its network, but because it doesn’t take the traffic the full length o the journey, it is not in a position to guarantee Quality of Service ahead of other traffic. It cannot control what happens to that traffic before it arrives inside its network.

Any ‘faster rate’ traffic would have to be identified and that would take quite an effort in packet sampling and that effort in turn would lead to price increases and desertions from the RBOCs to other forms of broadband lines, be they cable, powerline or wireless.

As long as America has genuine competition in its broadband services, this legislation is not necessary, but in many parts of the US, certainly rural areas, there is either only one broadband supplier, or in some cases, none.

Even if the technical difficulties were overcome, and a two tier service introduced, companies like AT&T would have to actively slow down other traffic, and that’s a very different thing to given some customer QoS.

If web pages from smaller companies were slowed down, then not only would that mean that US web innovation could slow to a crawl, but it would mean effectively an internet tax collected by the RBOCs, who are already bloated, over staff and over protected.

So far the attitude of the FCC has been that slowing someone else’s traffic, such as VoIP traffic from Vonage, is not allowable, but the RBOCs will no doubt be thinking of a courtroom showdown on that topic sometime soon and Wyden wants there to be a new piece of legislation in place for that day.

Imagine trying to offer video file download services over a P2P network, in competition with AT&T’s $4 billion plus investment into its U-verse TV service. Somehow we think that AT&T would price out of the market any request for QoS guarantees.