Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

22 March 2006

Now MHP royalties draw the ire of DVB Project

The process of making standards has never been more fraught than it is today and there remains continual frustration with the process whereby a vendor offers up patented technology, without making it clear what the cost of that technology is going to be.

There is another case in point beginning to brew in the MHP license, which spilled over into open hostilities last week. Now the standards body, in the form of the DVB Project, has hit back publicly at the proposed royalty terms for the MHP license.

Last week we pointed out that there were already rumblings from systems companies in Europe and now the parent standards body has spoken out against the terms and at the DVB World conference in Dublin Peter MacAvock, Executive Director DVB said, ‘I’ve collected a number of highly adverse comments to the licensing program, I’ve heard that the royalties are too onerous and don’t reflect the different broadcast distribution patterns within Europe.’

What he means by that is that Europe is getting a raw deal here, and specifically those TV operators that want the interactivity benefits of the new standard working in conjunction with free to air systems like DVB-T.

This squabble has some parallels in the MPEG LA OMA licensing scuffle, now in its second year, but that fight has some essential differences. In that dispute, companies that were largely excluded from the standards creation process have simply got involved at the patent stage for the first time, having previously told the OMA that it was treading all over their toes prior to the creation of the standard. Here we have companies that have promised to charge non-discriminating reasonable fees, doing the opposite and trying, after the fact, to charge excessive amounts.

The full list of companies has not been published, but they are known to include Comcast and OpenTV, companies that get most of their revenue from the US cable industry, asserting that the two flavors of the standard, MHP and OCAP, are charged differing amounts.

But the outcome may well be the same as the OMA dispute, where it has been largely frozen in Europe and ignored in the US, with only CoreMedia landing about 3 operator contracts for OMA DRMs and Vodafone separately cutting deal on secret terms to license the underlying DRM patents.

Comcast with 21.5 million customers, will benefit hugely from an upper level cap placed on the royalty payment, but this will hit smaller TV operators badly, especially those that operate small TV operations in Europe, and especially those that want to offer interactive systems for hybrid DVB-T systems.

Comcast is used to paying top dollar for its set tops, and so is most of the US cable industry, whereas the DVB-T market is an open retail market and has prices less than half those of US cable, which is part of the point of MHP.

Last week we revealed that MHP royalties were set at $2 per device plus a $0.25 per annum household charge for service providers, while for OCAP the license will cost $1.50 per consumer device and $0.30 per household per annum for service providers.

There have been caps put on the fees with free to air broadcasters paying $100,000 a year, and pay TV operators paying $200,000 a year once they have 7.5 million subscribers. The charges will begin on January 1, 2009.

Some cynics will say that this is the role of companies like Via Licensing, the Dolby patent pool subsidiary, and that royalty setting always involves argument and a bit of barefaced bluffing, not to mention the occasional piece of underhand dealing.

Last week specialist software house Osmosys called for a cut in the per device rate and an elimination of operator fees, describing the fees as a ‘case of IPR hijacking that is endangering the wide adoption of MHP.’

Sun Microsystems, a leading contributor to MHP, is understood to have offered its license for free because all of the applications are based on Java.