You can’t say we don’t hit topical subjects in Faultline. After spending a few thousand words last week proclaiming that the next decade for TVs will belong to LCD devices, Nano-Proprietary is trying to prove us wrong, cutting a deal with Taiwanese Da Ling corporation to built a plant for making flat TV screens around its Carbon Nanotube technology.
Nano-Proprietary is already in a patent infringement legal battle with Canon which was supposed to be working with Toshiba to bring its SED (surface-conduction electron-emitter display) TVs to market, using what is a similar technology. Last week the Toshiba Canon joint venture said that it would come 15 months late to market, a decision which Faultline decided means that it would never be able to make SEDs cheaply enough.
Faultline suspects that by then the technology will be dead, with combined losses across the two companies of more than $2 billion.
Now a new 50:50 joint venture called Carbon Nanotube Televisions (CNT TV) will be owned 50% by Da Ling and 50% by Applied Nanotech.
CNTs can be aimed entirely at the large end of the market going up against Plasma panels in the 60 inch to 100 inch flat screen TV market.
‘We expect CNT TVs to become the standard in large size flat panel displays,’ said Dr. Zvi Yaniv, Chief Executive Officer of Applied Nanotech, Inc. ‘CNT TVs are expected to retail for as low as $1,300 once they are in full scale production,’ he went on.
Well if CNT can come out with devices inside 18 months, out of reach of LCD technology in terms of size (LCDs will go up to 50 inches this year), and at this price, then is might just have a chance at survival. But again these claims sound unlikely. The tens of billions of dollars spent in the past and committed for the future, to drive down the price of both LCD displays and Plasma panels are likely to see this type of new technology off before it can bring a product to market.
Da Ling is a large diversified company based in Taichung in the Situn District of Taiwan with operations in several industries, including electronics. Da Ling previously organized a consortium of companies that invested $100 million in a pilot line for a large flat screen displays using polymer light emitting diodes, but it doesn’t say what happened to that product. Our guess is that it wouldn’t be getting involved with carbon nanotubes if it had worked out well, especially since the same project team that worked on that is transferring to the Nanotube project.
The whole thing will have just $10 million of equipment shoved into the joint venture, plus an unspecified amount of funding, and Da Ling will pay Applied Nanotech $1 million up front for its know how,
The joint venture agreement will not include a license to any of the technology used in the pilot line; however it will include pre-negotiated terms for a license agreement to be consummated if the pilot line is successful and the parties decide to move to manufacturing and commercialization.
Carbon can be used to create tiny, segregated vacuum tubes, to build screens that have millions of separate CRTs on them, creating devices a few centimeters thick with the clarity of CRT TVs, and Nano-Proprietary has over 200 patents or patent applications pending in this field.