The San Jose Mercury, the local paper for Silicon Valley in the US, says that Microsoft is building a head on competitor to the Sony PSP, with work starting now and a product likely to come out in 2008.
Faultline bemoaned the fact a year ago that Microsoft’s Xbox 360 device was un-ambitious and did not have the benefit of a portable client in the way that the Sony PS3 and Sony PlayStation Portable are designed from day one to work together.
Microsoft has done pretty well in bringing its Xbox 360 to market ahead of Sony, but given the massive power and visual advances anticipated in the PS3, plus the fact that it can be a server to the PSP, this means that the Xbox 360 could be reduced to a single year of life as a leading edge product. Already the PSP on its own has brought in more revenue than the Xbox 360 and Nintendo DS combined, this year.
This week researcher In-Stat came out with a report that said that Sony will continue with its domination of the video consoles through 2010, with a market share of over 50%. It suggested that the Microsoft Xbox 360 will win 28.6%, and the Nintendo Revolution just 21.2%.
At Faultine we don’t think that it is going to be that simple. The Xbox 360, Revolution and the PS3, are all going to end up as general purpose home entertainment appliances. The pure power of the Cell chip in the PS3 will mean that it can do so much more than the other two. In some functions, like driving multiple High Definition screens, the Cell’s inherent parallelism could make it perform up to 100 times the speed of a PC processor chip.
Also Sony has borrowed technology from IBM and is working with Toshiba to create a device that can be used in clusters as a powerful supercomputer, without changing a line of software. This will lead to many centralized gaming and other entertainment models with the PS3 working as a server. In order to do this it needs a general purpose client and we feel that the PSP and perhaps later variants of the PS3, are that client. So a new handheld product, just like the existing Xbox 360, is going to find itself competing with a moving target ‘ in a way a new form of triple play ‘ targeting video, games and music both at home and on the road. As such Microsoft HAS to have a portable player, but at the same time we fear it is already too late to start.
By the time the Microsoft handheld comes into the market, it will have to upgrade the Xbox 360 to work with it, and by then Sony will already have a 50 million installed base of PSPs.
Also the last thing that a portable player needs to be saddled with is a version of Windows as we have seen with the dismal sales figures of the portable media centers, which are neither liked, nor efficient.
One of the biggest weaknesses in the Microsoft strategy to date has been the fact that it does not have a viable hand held device that can be used to offload content programming from a TV service such as its IPTV. Consequently (see top story) although Microsoft has won the hearts and minds of all of the major Telcos in getting them to go with its vision of IPTV and it has painted a picture of that TV acting as a portal for mobile devices, currently all of those mobile devices have to run on a Microsoft software platform, which means that the iPod and the Sony PSP are out through Digital Rights Management incompatibilities.
So Telcos will love the new Microsoft handheld and offer them, but at the same time there will be around 100 million iPods and PSPs that people will WANT to put their music, films and games on, creating an impasse.
We’re sure this is all understood by J Allard, the Microsoft games head that is leading this project along with Greg Gibson, who was the system designer on the Xbox 360 video game console.
One of the things that is hurting the Xbox 360, and this is set to continue, are the lack of games. By realizing that the Xbox chips didn’t have enough power and switching to a completely different architecture, old Xbox games won’t work with the Xbox 360. Sony has made its PS3 work with both PS1 and PS2 games and is also believed to be bundling a huge number of PS1 games with the console and shifting many of them over to the PSP.
That will mean dragging over a decade of games creation with Sony’s launches, while Microsoft had to start again. One thing that has been suggested by the Mercury is that a handheld gaming device from Microsoft will fix this problem and all the old Xbox games will be made to play on it. Not a bad idea, copied as it is from Sony.
Microsoft will also use this device to take a potshot at the iPod, since it will double as a music player. But to do all that it will have to make the devices for under $200, and given that its portable media centers do less than this and cost $500, it will have a huge job of device subsidy on its hands, that may break the bank at the games division.
Microsoft is known to have considered making an ‘Xboy’ handheld a few years back but couldn’t make the numbers add up. Our guess is that the same thing will happen again.
The launch of the Microsoft Project Origami device will confuse this market even further and we don’t expect this project will ever see the light of day because by the end of 2007 and into 2008 the landscape is going to look very different.