Microsoft is now pushing out the idea that it will offer its competitors free, unlimited technical support through the European Commission’s Workgroup Server Protocol Program. Microsoft will also now provide on-site assistance to licensees to further help facilitate the development process, it says. It has also rounded up 5 University professors to say that Microsoft’s documentation is as good as, or better, than any one else’s in the industry. The offer of unlimited technical support provided at no charge is an increase from providing up to 500 hours of free technical support.
It all sounds very reasonable so why is the European Commission and none of Microsoft’s competition convinced? Well that’s pretty straightforward. Microsoft has in the past been found out putting undocumented features into its operating systems that only its applications have access to. Go back and look at the maneuvers it went through when it ousted Stac Electronics from the disk compression business or when it ensured that Lotus 123 no longer worked efficiently. In those cases it documented what it wanted too perfectly well. But it never documented everything that was going on, and that’s what this case, in essence, is all about.
The Monitoring Trustee is able to wander through Microsoft finding these things out and trying to establish a process whereby the same documentation that’s available internally to Microsoft staff, is available to other companies that want to build client server applications.
So when the Commission criticized Microsoft’s 12,000 pages of technical documentation the company had made available to enable licensees to implement certain Windows Server communications protocols, it may well have had good reason. How would you like to find the critical command in 12,000 pages of documentation?
The Trustee has to work out how to make sure that now, and in the future, Microsoft cannot give its own applications the edge, by illicitly hiding features, and making sure there is no subtle formula to enhance performance that you could only know if you written the OS source code.
Microsoft has pledged to make Windows source code available as a reference implementation, but the day after the case is over, that source code can change, and one line can slow down competitive applications.
So we mustn’t feel sorry for Microsoft in all of this, or believe that it is genuinely bending over backwards to help. Microsoft’s response is really about doing anything to help, except what it has been asked to do.
The inherent problem of an applications company having achieved applications supremacy by cheating, is extremely complex to stop, and almost impossible to reverse without breaking up the company, which one day will be inevitable.