Has the era of the network DVR box come and gone? Will network DVRs enable the pay-TV operators to cut costs and provide a more reliable service? Businesses learned a long time ago that it’s cheaper, more efficient and more reliable to centralize data storage rather than put the storage on users’ PCs.
So, why not adopt the same strategy when it comes to storing the entertainment that users now store on DVR set-top boxes? Why have a pricey, heat- and noise-producing DVR connected to every TV? A DVR is just another piece of hardware that is becoming obsolete the moment it’s shipped, is probably going to break at some point and adds complications and more wires to a user’s stack of electronics gear in the living room.
That’s the thinking of cable TV operator Cablevision, which this week said it plans to introduce a centralized video recording service this year that will replace the home’s DVRs. It could also make it easier to implement whole-home DVRs, because every TV in the home would have access.
DVRs are pricey, although most satellite and cable TV services give them away or give huge rebates on them. The satellite services, the first to push DVRs, want a DVR in every home so they have a defense against video-on-demand. VOD is something the satcos cannot fully implement because of a lack of bandwidth. Some cable and satellite TV operators require a separate DVR set-top for each TV that’s receiving the service.
In any event, someone’s paying for all the millions of DVRs that are going into consumer homes. TiVo, Thomson, Scientific-Atlanta, Motorola and the like aren’t giving them away. Centrally or network-stored entertainment would reduce hardware and software costs, minimize equipment problems in the home and open up the possibility for true whole-home DVRs. The only problem is that consumers don’t currently like the idea of them.
Cablevision said it wants to cut the cost of installing and repairing DVRs. It said it would pass the savings on to customers. Say it costs $200 for the pay-TV operators to buy a DVR. Add another $100 or so for shipping, installation and support. Assuming that 80 million or so homes eventually get a DVR, then that’s a $24 billion capital expense for the pay-TV industry in the US alone.
However, the satellite TV operators don’t have the bandwidth to offer the same-networked DVR service. That will put them at a competitive disadvantage to the cablecos and telcos. The Cablevision service will allow customers to store programs on servers located at Cablevision’s facilities.
The networked DVR will also make it easier for pay-TV services to upgrade. DirecTV wants to upgrade all its customers’ DVRs so they’ll be MPEG-4 compatible. That means their customers lose all the many hours of content they’ve stored on their current DVR. If DirecTV offered networked-DVRs, which it can’t, then it could do the upgrade without changing any hardware in the user’s home – and there’d be no loss of the subscriber’s stored content (well the set top might need a new chip or new software, but that’s all).
Cablevision’s new service will be called RS-DVR, for “remote-storage digital video recorder.” The Long Island-based company will test the service for 60 days. The good news for Cablevision and its customers is that only a software download to the customer’s existing digital set-top box is needed to upgrade to the service. The company has about 1.2 million subscribers to its digital service.
The fly in the ointment, as happens so often with advances in digital media technology, is the copyright issue. Cable TV channels, especially those that own content, such as Viacom (MTV) and Time Warner (CNN) don’t like the idea of content being stored outside the consumer’s premises.
Cablevision COO Tom Rutledge told Reuters the company had informed the networks of its plans. “In every way, it’s exactly the same product as subscribers would get with a physical hard disk digital video recorder.” He said nothing will be recorded on Cablevision’s network unless the subscriber orders it with the remote control.
The network DVR is not the same as allowing viewers to play back any show that has been aired, something that the networks and content owners have previously strongly objected to. It’s also not the same as Time Warner’s “Start Over,” which lets viewers back up any program that is still in progress.
If the network DVR passes technical and customer tests, as seems likely, and if the networks’ lawyers don’t get carried away, then DVR makers could find their party winding down before it even gets started. That is, except for those that are selling DVR boxes to the satellite TV services.