Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

5 April 2006

Net Neutrality bill is neutered

Amendments to the Communications Opportunity, Promotion and Enhancement Act in the US have virtually neutered it and stopped it being a way to ensure that everyone gets the same benefit out of the internet. In other words the Net Neutrality lobby has more or less lost its battle for a flat fee internet.

Instead, changes to the bill will mean that the FCC takes a controlling hand in deciding what can and what cannot be charged for additionally, over the internet.

Broadband providers wanted to retain the ability of charging some specified services for Quality of Service layers and guaranteed high speed connections to broadband services, raising fears that companies like AT&T would charge companies like Google a fee for getting searches to internet users fast enough.

AT&T has made it clear that it wants to offer higher speed to some services, specifically those that carry video, not actually to slow or block existing services. However there is little to stop companies like AT&T under provisioning for general backhaul for broadband lines and leaving the great mass of ‘best effort’ internet squeezed into smaller and smaller pipes.

The telecommunications legislation wording, released this week, will now go through several hearing stages and further amendments.

A November draft of that bill made it illegal for broadband providers to block, or unreasonably impair Internet access, but the final version drops this in favor of letting the FCC decide.

This represents a failure for the lobbies of Google, Microsoft, Yahoo, eBay, Amazon, Skype and some advocacy groups, with Net Neutrality provisions weakened and penalties for breaching the rules also considerably weakened.