Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

5 April 2006

Qualcomm files third set of patent disputes with Broadcom

Qualcomm has filed a suit against Broadcom saying that it has misappropriated its trade secrets and infringed its patents.

This is another tit for tat legal action, with the initial move being taken by Broadcom in May last year when it filed a patent infringement lawsuit against Qualcomm, claiming that the latter is using its intellectual property in products that combine video, VoIP, Bluetooth and other functions within one cellphone chipset.

Qualcomm counter sued and then in October filed a second suit against Broadcom alleging it used two of its patents for compressing digital video, without authorization.

Broadcom said it was common for countersuits to be filed in patent cases. “We remain convinced that our patent claims are very strong, and we are confident of prevailing,” it said.

Broadcom’s antitrust lawsuit, filed in the US District Court for the District of New Jersey claimed Qualcomm has abused the wireless technology standards setting process and failed to meet its commitments to license technology for cellular wireless standards on fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory terms.

Qualcomm, as is it practice these days, never discussed the new suit with Broadcom or asked for it to change its behavior, but just went ahead and filed.

Broadcom has filed a separate action with the US International Trade Commission alleging that Qualcomm has acted unfairly by importing chips that infringe on its patents.

The new lawsuit alleges that Broadcom has used the misappropriated trade secrets to compete unfairly with Qualcomm for the sale of WCDMA chipsets.

In our view there is little possible here other than a negotiated or court enforced settlement, sometime in the 2008 time frame, at best. There are too many patents involved and too many separate actions. But the two companies will fence for a while longer in order to work out which of them has the stronger negotiating position. The first court appearance before the two US companies is scheduled for next January and somehow we think there will be more law suits before then.