Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

5 April 2006

TiVo claims EchoStar stole DVR idea during sales meetings

The early days of the TiVo EchoStar patent infringement court proceedings were reported this week in various media, including on Fox News. Fox funnily enough is owned by New Corp the same company that owns DirecTV that gave TiVo its first breakthrough in the Digital Video Recorder business, that it invented.

It’s always been strange that TiVo has earned so little out of its DVR patents. It either invented the DVR or it didn’t. It can either enforce the patents or it can’t. And that’s what this case is about. If it can show one jury that it is the rightful owner of the core steps of ‘trickplay’ and indexing files on hard drives and using its smart recording technology to select what a DVR owner would want to record without asking them, then it can charge royalties all over the world.

Initially TiVo made license revenues by selling those rights to consumer electronics manufacturing companies including Toshiba, Sony, Philips, Thomson and DirectTV to build their own devices. It’s stated intention was that it wanted to charge for a monthly service which would upload EPG programming data and allow for advanced software functions such as ‘smart recording,’ where it records programs with a viewer’s favorite actors, or of the same genre or from the same directors, as those that have been selected before.

Ex-CEO Mike Ramsay made the case in court that his organization showed EchoStar’s Dish network the TiVo technology in the process of trying to sell it to them, and then EchoStar went off and came up with their own version of the same technology.

The argument in court is currently focusing on whether or not TiVo can patent the entire business processes such as copying video onto a hard drive or ‘trickplay’ per se, where a pause button spools the rest of the program onto a buffer on the drive. Or can it only patent its particular way of doing it.

Already TiVo has had something of a stalemate in the past in legal actions with both Replay TV and Gemstar. In each case they settled and agreed to share patents, and at least one major competitor in Scientific Atlanta gets its DVR license from the remains of Replay TV, now owned by Japanese consumer electronics firm D&M Holdings.

If TiVo wins the case, which is expected to be completed in the coming few weeks, it is thought to be asking for damages of $100 million, but the prize is much bigger than that. If TiVo wins well, there is an argument that it can require a royalty from DirecTV, which is now replacing its TiVo DVRs with those designed by sister company NDS. It could say the same about each of the cable companies in the US and around the world and it could shift to being an intellectual property play instead of a service business.

And if the DVR shifts onto the cellphone in the coming years, as it is expected to, then TiVo could be in for a big slice of a huge patent royalty pool.