Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

5 April 2006

Netflix sues Blockbuster over online DVD business model

It was only a matter of time before the two large US online DVD rental businesses began hostilities in earnest, and Netflix has decided that because it invented the business of online DVD rental, where you choose online and then have DVDs posted to you, it can sue Blockbuster for patent infringement.

Netflix talks about its two US patents for what is in effect a business model, where it offers a monthly fee in return for DVD rental and the idea of retaining a list of forward preferences of which DVDs a particular customer wants to view. A further patent has just been granted, which has triggered the law suit, and refers to the idea of keeping DVDs as long as the customer likes, rather than having to return them by a due date.

The patents would certainly not hold up in any other country except the US, and even there it may turn out that they won’t hold up to legal scrutiny, which will only be found out after a lengthy legal battle.

The lawsuit states that Blockbuster knew about the patents but has willfully ignored them.

The difficulty is the idea of patenting a business model that is largely obvious and common sense. For instance if the patents were upheld then how could any other company could enter the online DVD business? Blockbuster might then claim that it owns the DVD rental business and say that Netflix is just a special version of that. Our guess is that it is never a good idea guessing what a US judge, or worst still, a US jury will decide, but in the long run we would have thought this was little more than a nuisance suit designed for PR gains rather than real financial gains.

There have been 1,000s of copies of the Netflix service but the only one that Netflix is suing is the one that threatens to take customers from it.

Blockbuster Online has been going around 18 months and has attracted 1 million subscribers, compared to over 4 million for Netflix.