Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

3 May 2006

Aloha and SES Americom offer third mobile TV option for the US

Aloha and SES Americom offer third mobile TV option for the US

Aloha Partners has thrown a spanner in the works for a smooth transition into an era of mobile TV service in the US, and in a move that totally undermines Modeo’s DVB-H pretensions, it has announced a set of DVB-H services in the almost nationwide 700 MHz spectrum it holds.

Further than this it has partnered with SES Americom, the satellite business that operates a single super head end and which ships IP packeted information into the skies, to drop neatly into a US wide footprint. This obviates the need for the Aloha network to build multiple head ends all over the US and gives it immediate access to SES Americom’s content partners

The two companies will operate under the name Hiwire, and will compete head on with Qualcomm’s MediaFLO, which is partnered with cellco Verizon Wireless, and Crown Castle subsidiary Modeo, which worryingly has yet to announce any Cellco partnerships.

With Sprint Nextel already promising its own mobile TV in partnership with a cluster of US cable operators, in the 2008 time frame, this means that Aloha is set to completely undermine any attempt by Modeo to claim an exclusive partnership with Cingular. It doesn’t mean that Cingular won’t do such a deal, but the given the better propagation qualities of 700 MHz spectrum, versus Modeo’s 1670 MHz, its cost of building out a US wide network will be substantially below that of Modeo, even if it is a year behind.

Aloha Partners was set up, with the backing of several investors with backgrounds in telecoms infrastructure, to acquire the initial tranche of 700MHz spectrum auctioned in the US. It gained 12MHz of spectrum, double the amount bought by the other auction winner, Qualcomm. Further 700MHz allocations will be made as the current analog television occupants vacate the band, with the auction taking place at the end of 2008, and the spectrum not usable until the second quarter 2009.

This will be hotly contested by backers of WiMAX and other broadband wireless technologies, since the propagation qualities of 700MHz enable it to support high spectral efficiency and base station ranges.

Interestingly, Aloha originally trialed the Flarion Flash-OFDM technology, now owned by Qualcomm, in its 700MHz spectrum, but its current commercial trials are using DV-H.

Of the three companies looking to underpin the mobile carriers’ push into mobile broadcasting, Qualcomm’s MediaFlo subsidiary, which is using the company’s own OFDM-based FLO platform, is the only one to have a tier one customer signed up ‘ Verizon Wireless. The other major CDMA-based cellco, Sprint Nextel, plans to make do with using its own 3G spectrum for television services until it rolls out its planned 2.5GHz broadband wireless system, at which point it will create its own television network, possibly using the emerging TVtd technology from IPWireless, which it has on trial.

Cingular, the largest W-CDMA user, has been expected to sign up with Modeo, because DVB-H is backed by the GSM/W-CDMA community. However, it could now opt for Hiwire’s implementation of the same standard ‘ weighing the risk of opting for a start-up with no major industry supporters, and which is lagging Modeo in buildout schedule; against the attractions of the 700MHz band and the control that working with a small player can bring to the carrier (compare Sprint’s dalliance with the small IPWireless).

If Cingular does stick with Modeo, that would leave Hiwire with only T-Mobile or another CDMA player, and therefore logical Qualcomm prey, Alltel.

Aloha’s 12MHz of spectrum (TV channels 54 and 59) covers 60% of the US, including holdings in the top 10 markets and with coverage of 84%, on average, of the population of the top 40 markets. Hiwire expects to spend $500m to roll out services in the top 150 markets, according to president Scott Wills, about the same budget claimed by Modeo, though less than Qualcomm’s proclaimed $800m spend.

The Aloha system will use fewer transmitters than those of its rivals, and will distribute up to 40 QVGA class video channels to handsets. The efficiency of the 700MHz spectrum should enable it to achieve greater coverage and broadcast capacity for the same financial outlay as Modeo, Aloha claims. The company has so far spent $150m on spectrum.

Aloha says that significant portions of its two channels of spectrum are already available for use, three years in advance of the deadline for analog broadcasters to vacate 700MHz. This is mainly because, with two channels held, it is easier to free up at least one in each market.

The main role of SES Americom, the US subsidiary of Luxembourg based SES Global, will be to deliver content. Its chief current business is delivering content to cable operators, but it has been looking to enter the wireless space. “We have all of these signals in IP format ready for distribution. We have already made the investment and we have the relationship with the programmers,” said Bryan McGuirk, president of media solutions for SES Americom.

“We have deals with a number of wireline companies and now we are moving to wireless.” SES is one of the largest international commercial satellite operators by revenue and by number of satellites, but believes its long term growth requires expanding beyond the supply of wholesale space capacity to traditional broadcasters. Instead, it believes it can take a share of the emerging mobile TV segment, by using its satellites to transmit music and television to wireless systems on the ground.