Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

17 May 2006

What happens to TV advertising as we all learn to multi-task?

US TV advertising is beset with more hurdles than it has ever faced before and without innovation, it is headed for terminal decline. On the back of such a decline in the US, global TV advertising would fall also.

TV advertising is already known to be suffering from falling audiences, through competition with other leisure activities such as web browsing, game playing, watching DVDs and fast forwarding through adverts using a DVR, VHS or VD recorder.

In our view, TV advertising needs a new paradigm, and it needs first and foremost a company that is brave enough to try a new paradigm.

TV advertising is also under pressure from the fact that the modern human is faced day-in, day-out, with the requirement to do more than one thing at once, and this represents another challenge. As people get used to this and develop advanced multi-tasking skills, they are adapting their viewing patterns, and are likely to spend even more time ignoring unwanted advertising.

A piece in this week’s New York Times points to research going on to try to work out the likely change in TV advertising brought about from the fact that many viewers are now also reading, fiddling with their mobile, listening to music or searching the internet at the same time as watching TV. The research shows that viewers are doing something else with some other media about a third of the time they are watching TV.

The piece basically said that advertisers don’t know what to do about it, so we thought we’d recommend some courses of action.

The truth is that the human animal is evolving and the ability to do two things at once by storing one activity in the short term memory, and then later scanning it to see if anything interesting has happened, leads to new modes of TV viewing, and new capabilities. It also leads to a new kind of boredom. A being that can do two or three things at once is bored if only doing one.

Short term memory varies from person to person, and it may improve with practice. Certainly people can hold a single string of events in their head without focusing on them enough to digest them. This usually lasts for between 20 and 30 seconds even without rehearsing or repeating what has been absorbed. After that the memory can be lost. But some people can cope with multiple streams of short term memory at the same time, and psychologists think it works like a loop tape. If you are not ready to deal with that memory yet, to analyze it, process it and accept it into long term memory by the time it is about to fade, then send it around the loop again by ‘re-thinking it’ in a kind of rehearsal. With this kind of rehearsal, short term memory will last as long as rehearsal continues.

So life is teaching people to develop the skills to have multiple concurrent short term memories, under a loose kind of mental management. Talk to someone, while driving; talk on the phone while watching TV; listen to music while doing homework; all these are easy and commonplace.

The next level is doing homework, while watching TV, while talking to someone on the phone, while listening to music and using the internet at the same time to look something up, but also continuing an instant messaging conversation.

The more we do it the better we get at it, and this has huge implications for how advertising must change.

Faultline has written many words saying that TV advertising is on the decline, and if that decline is not yet steep, that’s only because the alternatives aren’t necessarily there yet.

Using the US Upfront as an example, which is going on right now, last year’s Upfront seemed to show ad markets in the US declining once inflation was taken into account, and there was every prospect of this getting far worse in this week’s Upfront dealings.

If there is a feeling that when surveyed most people can say ‘Yes I watched that program’ and can recite its plot lines, but at the same time they were able to totally switch off from the advertising, then the question remains, how do I truly reach the modern advertising target.

Of course the answer is delivered in the question, it’s just that so few people want to hear it.

What needs to happen, and what’s in the process of happening, is that TV advertising needs to be revolutionized

We’ve seen subtle changes that attempt to stall the weakening affect of TV advertising, for instance all advertising breaks are harmonized so that when one program is showing ads, they all are. That makes it hard to use the zapper to avoid ads.

Another device is to raise the TV volume when the advertising is on, so that waning attention span can be dragged back to the TV for a second, overcoming the effect of dropping it back one level in the attention span and focusing more on iPod track selection, or a new search term, while the ads are on.

These are crude mechanisms, not universally used, that are creeping into the ad man’s armory.

We think there are two ways to go in TV advertising to revitalize it, perhaps three and there are clues to each of these in the patent filings of companies like Google and Microsoft.

1) Spread advertising over more formats in a coordinated advertising campaign – using the TV, the web, outdoor advertising, mobile TV advertising (soon with us) and web TV ads. The same ads can be placed into the same TV programs, and some of this is being tried in this year’s Upfront, where both web and TV versions of the same programming are having advertising pitched together. Short term memory is interrupted by the sound of anything familiar, like the sound of your own name or the sound of an advertising idea you’ve heard before. In this way advertising needs to become multi-platform, and mixed message with subtle media variations.

2) Use the very ‘two things at once’ capability that people are developing to offer advertising which instead of interrupting the TV program, runs concurrently with it. What’s wrong with the TV showing advertising that either ‘surrounds’ the video screen, or is implanted inside another image using picture in picture. That way the capability of the viewer to do two things at once works with the advertiser, not against it. The viewer has spare short term memory capacity so starts running a loop of some TV program dialog and looks away from the screen for a few seconds to view the ads. Later he or she can catch up (faster than real time) the dialog and action that was surging around their short term memory. Google is talking this week about a ‘revolution’ for the TV advertisement and there are two schools of thought over what it might be. Some say it might be like a radio experiment that Google has been running, relating to auctioning unsold remnants of radio advertising, and they speculate that this revolution could be a video version of that. But Google CEO Eric Schmidt says that it has more to do with search. So why not drop a search bar into the TV screen and why not pre-fill the search criteria in context with the content that is on the TV screen.

3) Another version of the same idea is to use a well known Microsoft patent, and make each of the areas of a TV screen hypertext links that work like Product placement, and take viewers from the screen to a long form advert for any product on the screen that is clicked on. This was designed for IPTV, and can work with cable but it requires a return path. Satellite TV systems could be adapted for something like this, perhaps recording the preferences and then accepting satellite sent data onto a DVR for later viewing.

4) Finally we can make advertising that works more intelligently and more engagingly using the mechanisms of all of the above.

There would be a lot of new problems to solve however. We have to work out how to place and how to measure multi-platform campaigns, but this is clearly the route down which Microsoft is headed with its adCenter product line, and it already has a handle on serving advertising to the web and inside video games with its recent purchase of in-game ad network Massive inc.

Mobile TV is next, and research on trials of DVB-H showed that viewers also watched alternative programs at home. Effectively this means that viewers are able to watch something on the main TV and something else on their mobile TV platform. This is much better than having to watch two programs picture in picture, as any viewing sharing the TV may be distracted with a second screen, while the other is happy. Offering a separate screen that is personal on the phone is a much better idea, but advertising will also need to be delivered in phase with other media on the mobile handset. What would be the chance of delivering the same ad to the same person on two platforms at once? What about three platforms?

What advertisers will NOT want is to send the same ad to the same person, on three media ‘ TV channel, radio, mobile TV channel- and pay for it three times over at full price. Sure, sometimes advertisers may be perfectly happy to do this, just to ensure that the message gets through on one of them. But then there would be the trouble that statistics might tell them they had reached three people, when they had only reached one. So new measurement systems and far more accurate demographics are going to be needed in this future, multiplatform advertising world, but also multiple ways of delivering the message, adding delivery that is peripheral to the viewing experience and not only using ads which interrupt it.

The New York Times piece said that the Los Angeles Emerging Media Lab spent valuable time trying to work out which is the primary activity which people were ‘really’ paying attention to. They try to work out their level of ‘engagement’ in a particular activity.

Ask your 16 year old son whether he is listening to music or doing his homework and he will tell you that he is doing both and that he does better homework when he listens to music.

This focus on ‘which one are they really engaged in’ is really panic activity, trying to justify that the TV is the ‘main’ thing that the viewer is doing, but it seems increasingly unlikely that TV IS the main thing, or that it can be proved.

The truth is that in a democratic world, people want control over both WHEN and IF they watch a particular advert. They don’t want what they are doing to be interrupted in order to have it foisted on them, and their weapon in the future will simply to pay attention to one of the other things they are doing to avoid ads. The right strategy for advertisers is to bow to the viewers choice and work with them and not against them.

In future advertising agencies are going to have to earn their keep, because their job is no longer about choosing media for their clients, but about choosing a collection of related, coordinated media.

Because in the future, as this capability to do two and three things at once improves, then viewers won’t even need DVRs to avoid ads, they’ll just re-focus on one of the other things they are doing for the duration of the advert or switch to a channel that no longer uses interruptive advertising.