Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

17 May 2006

TiVo, Brightcove Team Up with Internet Videos – Shades of Akimbo

TiVo has teamed up with Internet TV platform start-up Brightcove to allow TiVo users to download and watch Internet-based videos. TiVo wants to have advantages for its DVRs that aren’t available on those the satellite, cable and TV operators are shipping.

The service would appear to validate what Akimbo Systems has been saying that there is video on the Net that people want to see and that people want to watch the Internet videos on their TV more than they do on their PC.

Adding the Brightcove service means TiVo users will be able to download videos over the Internet from companies that are Brightcove customers. Reportedly there’ll be videos from six to 12 sources when the service starts in June but they haven’t yet all been identified.

Akimbo offers a similar service that includes 10,000 video titles and the Movielink online movie service. It’s available through three outlets; Akimbo has its own Thomson-made, RCA-brand Akimbo-only set-top box that connects to the TV; The Akimbo service is available to users of Windows Media Center PCs, but that’s typically connected to the PC’s display, not the family’s main TV; and more recently, AT&T announced a new set-top that, in addition to the Akimbo service, also includes the Dish Network satellite TV service and a broadband connection.

AT&T calls the service Homezone. The box, made by 2Wire, allows subscribers to have access to all the content through a single on-screen interactive program guide. To help users find something of interest, the guide features a video search function, full program descriptions and even video previews of the on-demand content.

Movielink offers more than 1,000 titles, including major studio hits, National Geographic specials, documentaries and more.

Both the Akimbo and TiVo/Brightcove approach have a major advantage. Consumers can watch Internet-based videos on their TVs instead of smaller PC screens.

The TiVo-Brightcove deal isn’t exclusive. That means there is no known barrier to Akimbo also getting a TiVo deal. All the titles on the Akimbo service are already re-encoded for watching on a TV set. It’s neither clear nor certain how many videos will ultimately be available through the TiVo-Brightcove service.

Brightcove customers include the New York Times Company, Oxygen Network, Hearst’s SmartMoney finance magazine and Dow Jones, publisher of The Wall Street Journal.

The move also gives Brightcove an advantage because most of its viewers currently can watch only on their PC. The Wall Street Journal quoted Jeremy Allaire, founder and chief executive of the company, as saying, “Increasingly they want to be able to have the same programming on set-top devices and portable devices.” He also said that TiVo and Brightcove plan to expand the number of content providers who can offer video to TiVo users.

TiVo has been scrambling to add functions that’ll attract buyers in the aftermath of losing its deal with DirecTV, which sold some two-thirds of all TiVos out there. TiVo’s much-ballyhooed deal last year to supply its software and service to Comcast has gone silent recently. Comcast said that its subscribers would have to pay extra to get the TiVo goodies.

EchoStar (with its own DVR) and DirecTV (TiVo DVRs) started the DVR push and used it to take away substantial market share from the cablecos. The cable companies belatedly ramped up their own DVR efforts, using less than state-of-the-art boxes, at least initially, from Motorola and Cisco’s Scientific-Atlanta. The cablecos now appear to have their DVR product and marketing strategy in gear.

Right out of the gates, AT&T and Verizon have made DVRs one of the key products in their efforts to differentiate their services from that of the telcos and cablecos.

TiVo, having lost DirecTV, now must depend on sales through retail stores to grow. The satcos and cablecos have the advantage. They have and can and do use their customer lists. Each can conduct very targeted direct mail and telephone marketing campaigns. Also, they finance the DVRs, offering them for little or nothing up-front and a small monthly fee.

TiVo has three other problems, two of them relating to its installed base.
1. TiVo does not control the majority of its units that are installed. DirecTV does. That limits what TiVo can offer to what fits DirecTV’s long-term strategy. The two have very different strategies.
2. TiVo’s Brightcove service reportedly only works on its standalone Series 2 boxes. That’s estimated to be only about 400,000 or so of the installed units. If that’s right, then none of the millions of owners of DirecTV TiVo boxes will get the Brightcove service. Nor will any of TiVo’s own users of Series 1 boxes.
3. Tivo’s current boxes only decode the increasingly antiquated MPEG2, which produces much larger files than those produced by more recent codecs such as MPEG4, H.264 or Microsoft’s Windows Media 9 and WM10. The installed base of TiVo boxes were not really designed to do this because they rely on hardware video decoding of only MPEG2 files. The newer codecs produce much smaller files and consequently allow for high-quality delivery at low cost.

It is Akimbo that now has a deal with a distribution giant – AT&T, and TiVo that’s out looking for partners. AT&T certainly has the clout – it’ll be the world’s largest telephone company and the largest mobile phone operator in the US once it completes its acquisition of BellSouth.

However, its TV heart seems to belong to its fiber-optic network-based IPTV and the system that Microsoft and Alcatel have developed.
By focusing on its IPTV project, however, AT&T may be missing a bigger opportunity with the Akimbo/EchoStar/broadband box. After all, it’s the middle of May and AT&T still isn’t saying any more than it’s got the IPTV service on test in a couple of hundred homes in its headquarters town of San Antonio. Here’s guessing that most of those homes are AT&T employees.

AT&T can immediately start selling the Akimbo/EchoStar/broadband service to the majority of its 26.7 million residential phone customers. There’s no reason, except political, that it couldn’t get BellSouth to start selling the same service to its 14 million residential customers. That’s over 40 million potential customers, customers that AT&T could sell today.

There’s no waiting on pulling cable, no waiting for getting local video franchise approvals, no waiting to get content deals. It’s a service that AT&T can sell now and install immediately. EchoStar has proven that its pay-TV package, save of its lack of the football package, is as good as any. The Akimbo service with its wealth of Internet-based videos is a service that no other pay-TV service can offer.

Even if 20% of the residential customers can’t be served with broadband and if 20% want to stick with DirecTV for its football package, that leaves over 25 million immediate prospects for the AT&T service.

AT&T and BellSouth know who they are and where they live. The two can mail them plus put ad inserts into the envelope with the monthly bills, there are no “don’t call” lists to contend with.

If and when AT&T gets its IPTV act together and pulls the fiber wires into a neighborhood and gets the local authorities pay-TV franchise approval, well, it can try to get its pay-TV customers to switch from one AT&T service to another. That would be easier than getting those consumers to give up all the TV shows and movies they’ve recorded on their cable TV or DirecTV DVRs.

Who knows Verizon, Qwest and many of the smaller local telcos might also be interested in partnering up with AT&T on such a venture. Now that would give the cablecos and DirecTV fits. Holding its punches doesn’t give AT&T any benefits