Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

24 May 2006

US Upfront presages turning tide for global TV ad revenues

After TiVo last week saying that it has cut its own upfront deal, the shadow of its invention, the digital video recorder, is now hanging like a sword over the US Upfront advertising negotiations, threatening to leave US TV advertising in a deep depression.

Broadcast networks have been preparing their ground for ad spending at the same levels as last year, which they thought they would achieve by selling internet advertising, bundled with their TV ads. But the broadcast networks never saw the specter of US DVR penetration coming.

Now a war has broken out, according to US advertising journals and TV Week, which suggests that the Upfront has totally stalled over one single issue, and that’s the definition of just what constitutes a US broadcast TV viewer.

Already one major advertiser, Johnson & Johnson, said last week that it will defer upfront spending until August, in line with its annual budget.

The key to the US Upfront negotiations is that new TV packages are up for sale, as a new season of TV series are announced, and these sell at a discount to advertising bought throughout the year, in return for volume. But the long drawn out upfront for Broadcast last year has meant that purchases of adverts throughout the year, known as the ‘scatter’ market, have been unable to command a premium against last year’s Upfront, taking away many of the benefits of committing to volume in the first place.

Usually by now a number of networks are either full, or filling up and a number of major brands have made serious commitments, but all news of deals is currently absent.

What’s holding it up is the definition of what a viewer is. Nielsen Media, which has always held a near monopoly in measuring US TV markets, offers three different figures for advertisers and networks to work with, the number of people that view a program live, those that store in on a DVR to view later than day, and those that store it on a DVR for viewing sometime.

Both of the last categories are suspect, in that viewers don’t always view the program, and nearly always fast forward through the advertising. The increasing penetration of DVRs across the US means that there is a bigger and bigger difference between the three sets of figures and this year it has come to a head. Advertisers want to use only live viewers, Broadcast networks want to count all of them and they are struggling to reach some kind of standard compromise.

Once they do, the Upfront can get under way, but if big names like Johnson and Johnson are not in it, it can’t help but be down.

Also the complexity of trying to involve the internet versions of the same programming, from the owners of the Broadcast TV networks such as CBS and NBC, are slowing down negotiations which usually see buyers panicked into promising up to $9 billion in just one short week.

The same hurdles will no doubt re-emerge at the cable Upfront due in a few weeks, and the likely outcome will be that a fraction of last year’s $15 billion of advertising spent Upfront across the two types of TV will have been pledged.

It is one thing having US broadcast TV take less money, it is another completely different outcome if they turn tail and start desperate discounting to salvage their schedules.

Last year the Upfront was a huge market swing in favor of ABC, which had long had the worst of what appeared to be an outdated schedule until its ‘Lost’ and ‘Desperate Housewives,’ franchises turned the tide. It accepted smaller than anticipated percentage increases, and advertisers deserted NBC in droves, to the tune of $800 million. So this year if any network is going to ‘break for cover’ and accept the lower ratings, it is likely to be NBC looking to recover last year’s ‘lost’ ground.

Fox is the one network that claims that it is doing business, but won’t give out details, but with internet properties such as IGN Entertainment and MySpace, it has the internet power to cut some very clever new media deals.

Misguided financial analysts had called the market as likely to be up by around 2% (which is actually a fall in real numbers). That same enthusiasm from media analysts have it that Cable networks could see a rise of 7% to 9%. But Cable networks have their own issues, and the DVR is one negative aspect, while their internet versions of their own programs have less scale to counteract that. However a stronger approach to VoD advertising should see some upwards pressure. Cable still sells at a substantial discount per thousand viewers reached when compared to cable, primarily because many brands want a simple US wide footprint, that cable networks can’t always deliver.

Many international advertising efforts find themselves pegged to US cost per thousand viewers, and a US fall is likely to lead to a global advertising shift, with all the money saved from TV advertising likely to find a home on the internet.