Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

14 June 2006

3G base stations in the home ‘ Are we missing something?

We confess that the first thought that we had when someone first told us about a base station in the home, was ‘Why would anyone want that?’ but with the current wave of activity here it now becomes glaringly obvious.

The problem came from our picture of what a base station consists of, one of those big transmitters that hang from towers by the side of the freeway, but these new devices, with at least five companies offering them, are tiny little transmitters no bigger and using the same kind of power profile as wi-fi Access Points.

The trend was highlighted last week by Motorola making the acquisition of TTPCom, which in turn has a 47% stake in IP.access, which makes 3G pico base stations for home networks.

After all what is a 3G base station except a transmitter/receiver with a little more software in it for roaming etc…. All its needs is a broadband line for backhaul and overnight it becomes a powerful tool for 3G networks.

The whole thing has come about through base station chips coming down in the price such that a tiny base station can be built, we understand, for as little as $160, comparable with consumer pricing when the first wi-fi Access Points began going into homes.

These could be used in both unlicensed spectrum, where perhaps a WiMAX base station might be preferable, or in spectrum that is owned by a mobile operator.

Could the decision to offer them in homes not be a way to block many attempts at dual mode handsets, while at the same time offering cellular operators a cheap way to rollout out 3G in rural communities, and also offer 3G operators a way into home networking, with all that entails.

If a 3G pico station is used inside a home, then surrounding base stations in the countryside don’t have to be powerful enough to penetrate walls. Home coverage could be offered extremely cheaply, because it would travel to the base station over spectrum that the operator owned, but then drop into the any best effort broadband line, and find its way back into the cellular network over an IP connection.

This would also dramatically cut rural backhaul, potentially making it cheap enough for operators to subsidize these devices. A normal mobile handset could then operate a little like dual but in a single spectrum. When it was connected to a large, commercial, shared base station, usual mobile charges would operate, but when it was connected to the home base station, home connection prices would make it as cheap (and as clear) as a home phone line. All the benefits of the mobile, at the price of a home phone and all the features of a mobile for holding directories etc’ and no wi-fi in sight.

Suddenly this would drive a market for 3G PC line cards, because what was traditionally wi-fi traffic could travel over the operator’s spectrum around the home to the broadband line, and offer premium priced connection wherever there was only a large commercial base station.

The same pico stations could be driven into the enterprise, and sufficient savings from the backhaul reduction and the lower density of base stations might pay for all of it and yet take away the attraction of wi-fi and give the same kind of attraction back to the cellcos.

Back at home consumer electronic devices might be made to talk to each other over the cellular signal, but because it was delivered through a home owned low power base station, this could be with much higher speeds than Wi-Fi and yet at similar equipment prices.

The idea for tiny base stations has really emanated from the WiMAX community, with lower power WiMAX base stations from companies like Radiospire, which launched a chip in January for HDMI file carriage using WiMAX services, optimized to stream high definition television.

Radiospire claims cable TV quality while sending an HDMI signal around a home to a home theater in High Definition formats including 720p, 1080i and 1080p using industry-standard HDCP encryption

Radiospire says it can offer 3Gps throughput and points at wi-fi and UWB short range signals and says they are too slow and present compression and copy protection issues.

It uses a Silicon Germanium SiGe RF transceiver chip, ADC/DAC, and a CMOS baseband device and operates in the 3.1 to 4.8 GHz range to avoid interference with Wi-Fi.

The UK’s picoChip is touting a straightforward WiMAX chipset which simply adheres to low power limits for use in the home, and as yet has no takers that we know of for turning it into a product, as yet.

Another company focused on indoor applications of WiMAX is chip designer Cygnus Communications, which last year demonstrated a software defined platform for 802.16 at the SuperComm show, designed to compete with fast Wi-Fi.

In a 5GHz Lan environment, many of WiMAX’ characteristics will be similar to those of the OFDM-based variants of Wi-Fi, such as 802.11a and future releases. However, over LAN distances it will boast higher data rates than 802.11a, though not necessarily than the upcoming 802.11n, which could reach several hundred Mbps in its second generation, but also can offer the WiMAX QoS services.

Cygnus was acquired by NextWave Wireless in February this year and operates as a wholly owned subsidiary.

Finally his week Ericsson has completed the mix saying that it will bring to market a pico low power base station, which as the premier base station supplier to much of Europe, is perhaps the signal to rethink just how 3G can be used in the home.