The bulk of the coverage in the US oriented newspapers and internet media this week praised George Bush’s signature on a bill that will increase fines for what the US calls indecency, by a factor of ten.
But what of its effect on the content industry? And why did such a law become necessary in the fundamentalist Christian state that the US has become.
Swearing is not per se evil, nor is it good. But the attraction to it among the young is surely due to adults around them swearing, and wanting to be more like their parents and other adults they mix with. The same applies to movie stars and TV stars that are increasingly today’s role models.
Parents swear, children generally don’t. Children want to be like their parents and senior peers, so want to swear and be seen to shock. Parents on the other hand want their children to stay young and innocent, and hate it when they swear.
So why, in a country which was the first country in the world to sanctify the freedom of speech, has it been necessary to bring in such harsh measures.
Bush has given the FCC the right to increase the maximum indecency fine on a single TV or radio station to $325,000, ten times more than the $32,500 that was previously in place. There is now a $3 million maximum for any incident which goes out to multiple affiliate stations.
That’s real money, and it is big enough to mean that broadcast TV has to rethink its schedules and its attitude to both nudity, swearing and references to sex throughout its programming.
This, of course will not eliminate swearing, nudity and references to sex from TV, but limit it to cable and satellite TV. The understanding today is that any service where the viewer has to pay to receive the programming, and has specifically requested receipt of it is not affected by this. Neither is the internet of course.
It is a matter of human nature that the programs with explicit sex, realistic vocabulary from real people, tinged with a what youth sees as the ‘coolness’ of people who swear, will naturally attract the young. So they will be more and more attracted to cable, satellite and the new IPTV systems, which leaves Broadcast floundering for a business model. So far it has just followed cable and satellite down this road, and now it will genuinely have to rethink.
So in effect all this means is that American fundamentalism is hastening the end of broadcast content, which has always been a little erratic in who it reaches. Programming is made by TV studios and put into channels by TV networks. Those networks will now have to make content that heavily distinguishes cable or satellite from broadcast content, because these rules, despite all the efforts of the broadcast networks, do not apply to those pay TV systems.
The way they are operating right now is to take content that was designed for either cable or satellite, and cut out certain words, expressions and scenes. They also do this on any content that they commission that doesn’t observe all the rules. This takes a lot of effort and costs a lot of money, so it acts like a tax on broadcast TV and radio.
The way around this, of course, is to play the FULL versions of all this content on internet web sites and downloads. The distinction will be watch this program on TV to follow the story line, and either buy it from iTunes or watch it from our web site (at any time of the day or night because there is no 9 pm watershed on the internet) in order to get the full ‘grungy,’ swearing version with all the scenes, rather like a DVD’s Director’s cut.
This new revenue stream has to pay for the self imposed censorship, and even act as a future revenue stream. But at the same time, the more that is available on the internet, the more people will watch it from there. If you combine this trend with devices such as the new TiVo, that allow you to watch video on your TV set which is downloaded from the web, then you have gone full circle.
The content is now on the web in its more profane version, it is available to everyone at any time, and potentially globally, and the broadcast model is severely weakened.
It is not a huge step for companies to begin making content entirely for the web and putting TV stations on there, like the 200 or so .tv sites that have sprung up in the past year, mostly specialist sites, that already exist.
Will President Bush have affected future generations, somehow denying them access to swearing and to TV of a sexual nature – not at all. But he would have put a powerful censorship tool into the hands of the FCC.
A cynic might say that TV stations that praise the president might find the FCC more reluctant to fine for instances of profanity. And if this is true, as the last election appeared to demonstrate, US media will be suffering from the same government intervention as media does in say China or any other dubious tin pot dictatorship, except its power structure will be more subtle.
There is also another route that broadcasters can take to prevent all of this coming to pass quite so quickly. Using digital terrestrial TV, using either DVB-T which has taken off like a rocket in Europe, or ATSC (Advanced Television Systems Committee) which is defined for the same use in the US, broadcasters can re-invent themselves.
This is much tougher in the US, where whole swathes of the country are out of reach of TV transmitters, due to the prevalence of pay TV cable systems, but it can be done. It is a non-trivial, but achievable aim, to use broadcast spectrum to send both free to air TV and encrypted pay TV services.
In this way broadcasters could create a set of pay TV services, which although they use the FCC allocated spectrum, would have easy parental controls added at the set top level. They might use this to offer two copies of a given program, the one as it was written to be, complete with nudity and swearing broadcast in protected mode, and one without. They might then argue that the new rules should not apply to their encrypted pay TV versions.
But program makers are not going to be attracted to making content that fits the new rules, because it won’t have much appeal for export, and Hollywood is still virtually dominant outside the US, as much as it is within. Content delivered in regimes which are not so fundamentalist as America is likely to come from the content makers that are not restricted by this law, i.e. those making TV for cable and for cinema (ironically the censored type of programming will go down better with Islamic states that the US is so suspicious of, rather than with European and Far Eastern audiences).
And if program makers begin to ignore the US broadcast networks, because their format is overly restrictive, that will ultimately accelerate the demise of US free to air broadcasting.