Nielsen Media Research, this week said it would provide integrated, all-electronic ratings for television regardless of the platform on which it is viewed. It calls this services Anytime Anywhere Media Measurement initiative, and it’s going to be tricky and involve a whole heap of new technology, and it won’t be with use before 2011.
Not only is the future of Nielsen Media and its parent company, $5 billion Dutch conglomerate VNU, resting on this being successful, but at risk is the entire TV ratings system of the US, under threat from revised viewing approaches caused by DVR’s iPod and other portable TV viewing and the user of DVD players, video on demand services and web video. Nielsen even wants to record what people watch on TV when they are in bars and hotels, and plans to introduce some fancy technology to achieve this.
Nielsen holds the keys to where all future advertising will be placed in the 210 US TV markets, as well many overseas TV markets in other countries. It does this by reporting what percentage of each viewing audience decides to watch each TV program. Without accurate TV data the $60 billion US TV ad industry would be in chaos.
In the famous release that it made at the beginning of 2004 Nielsen caused great furor by announcing that in the last quarter of 2003 alone, US TV lost 10% of viewing hours in males aged between 18 and 34.
Now two year’s on, Nielsen has rebuilt its monitoring model and will soon be ready to report on every new type of TV viewing activity. Nielsen has been very careful not to repeat the statements of early 2004. After that its accuracy was questioned, its shift to semi-automated TV monitoring using people meters, was questioned, and advertisers and TV stations alike looked like they would finally have to face the music and accept radical fall-off in their viewing figures.
But in October 2003 Nielsen had already began laying the groundwork for this new service, it cut a deal with Seachange International to get its hands on its VoD audience server data, and in February 2004 it cut a deal to get hold of TiVo DVR live audience data. More recently it has done deals with the in-game advertising network Massive, before its recent sale to Microsoft.
In short it has tried to find new ways to measure new audiences because it could see the writing on the wall both for itself and for its customers. Fail to find and measure the activities that TV viewers were migrating to and Nielsen would encourage competitors to invade the monitoring business and potentially leave advertisers stranded.
But the latest challenges, iPod and web viewing and viewing in bars, is going to stretch its ingenuity.
Nielsen started out life physically posting diaries to people and getting their agreement to write down everything they watched on TV and sending them back. Later it developed a people meter that each family member had to log on to when they came into the room, and it automatically collected the program data that was being viewed by later upload.
Now Nielsen has its hands full and it has to develop and deploy technology to measure Internet, outside the home, and mobile TV, as well as iPods and other personal, mobile devices.
First off it has to shift its people meter concept out to all of its markets, and so far it is years from achieving that, with each rollout having to be calibrated against existing diary based systems.
Nielsen will expand its Local People Meter (LPM) service beyond the 10 largest TV markets to the next 15 largest markets beginning in Houston, Seattle and Tampa in October 2007 and continuing until nearly half of the US population is measured by LPMs.
Then it needs to add video streaming measurement at the PC to gain statistical samples of programming that are watched on the web. Just how it plans to deal with systems like Akimbo, which offers file downloads to a set top, rather than a PC, isn’t clear. It will probably do a deal to buy this data at some point.
Nielsen Media and its sister company Nielsen NetRatings will then integrate data from its SiteCensus service, which uses proprietary ‘ping back’ technology to provide highly accurate and granular measurement of what is delivered online, linked to the demographic data from its metered panels of Internet users.
Nielsen will monitor PC entertainment consumption at home, both offline and online using software based PC meters on the personal computers and laptops of existing People Meter panelists, with the aim of fully deploying them during the 2007-2008 broadcast season.
It aims to produced fused data that can be used to allow agencies to plan and co-ordinate advertising campaigns across the TV and the Internet.
Outside the home at work, in bars, restaurants, hotels and airports, Nielsen will develop a whole new generation of meters which will work by collecting audio signatures and later upload them for analysis by computer at Nielsen, which will have to license a huge audio signature database. We’re not quite sure how you measure an audio signal on a piece of mobile TV that is played with the sound off, but otherwise it’s a neat idea.
Meter owners will also have to have the devices turned on, and with them at all times, which is why one such device will be incorporated into a cellular handset, while the other resembles an MP3 player. There is no mention of how the handset will record what viewers actually watch on their mobile, although the same technology might work here.
Nielsen will also work to create ‘Solo Meters’ that can be used with any portable media system. For platforms that use a Bluetooth wireless connection, Nielsen is developing a very small wireless meter that would passively listen to communication between mated devices. For systems that are wired, Nielsen is building a diminutive ‘in-line’ meter that would be physically inserted between the device on its earphones. At the moment this sounds like pie in the sky and it is clear that Nielsen doesn’t have a concrete plan for portable devices, just a few ideas and this is more a statement of intent than a detailed plan of action.
Development of these systems will start now with functional prototypes due within six to 12 months, and testing in the latter part of 2007.
Another area of Nielsen’s strategy is to create ways of measuring how engaged a consumer is in a video experience. This is primarily because viewers are now known to multi-task with mobile phones and internet access while watching TV. Nielsen will first conduct interviews and then work out how to follow up with additional phases of research or the launch of a specific engagement product.
In some smaller TV markets Nielsen said it will use battery-powered meters which would be placed near televisions to capture all programming on the set, which are then mailed back to Nielsen for analysis, instead of operating online.
For smaller markets currently served only by the paper Diary, Nielsen will pursue a full electronic measurement plan and investigate a number of possible electronic solutions, including set-top box data and Internet Diaries. Nielsen has set a target to have every type of TV market in the US monitored by 2011. Let’s hope that there aren’t another ten formats for TV available by then, driving the need for further revolution at Nielsen.
Nielsen said it will also work on wearable personal tags that let meters know when viewers are in direct line of sight of their TV sets and these of course could be worn and interact with any TV that has a people meter.
In the end this fragmenting TV marketplace does leave space for a competitor to Nielsen, and one that can be instrumental in the disruption that is going on around TV markets. Perhaps a single idea like a cellular handset application, using BlueTooth and its future high bandwidth carrier Ultra Wide Band, could be used to measure almost all these things with a simple Java application reporting through the cellular network.
Most of the people working in US TV have doubted Nielsen from time to time, and the company is secretive and conspiratorially close to broadcast TV companies. It could be that a Nielsen that can sell data to ALL of these markets will no longer feel beholden to US broadcasters and could be bolder in its statements about how media usage is changing. But today it is virtually an unlicensed monopoly and an extension to both advertising agencies and broadcasters.
What would happen if a new competitor, using a new methodology was to come up with a different picture from Nielsen’s of what the world’s audiences are doing. Now that would create a truly chaotic advertising environment.