Apple appears to finally be taking on the tricky task of bringing bulk movie delivery to the video iPod, something we always thought should have been the first thing it did. Perhaps Steve Jobs, Apple CEO had to prove that the video iPod would shift lots of TV series, before the movie studios would listen to him.
Anyway now according to Daily Variety and the New York Times Jobs has their attention and potentially has a deal with either all, or at least some of Disney, 20th Century Fox, Warner Brothers and Universal Studios. No surprise that Sony is missing from the collection, given the bloody nose that the iPod has given its electronics arm, but as far as the NY Times is concerned, no talks are ongoing with Paramount either, which is a bit of a mystery.
What’s got everyone in a twist about these negotiations it seems, is that Jobs is once again acting as the force that is stopping the studios from being greedy. He wants to charge $9.99 for films that are already in their DVD window or beyond, in a flat pricing scheme that borrows more than a little something from his pricing on music tracks and TV series, at $0.99 and $1.99.
Faultline has been saying for the past two years, that movies should take into account that online margins are smaller than real world retailers, and that studios don’t have to spend money on DVD manufacturing costs. That means that online film downloads should be closer to $10 to $12 per film, not the $20 and above that they have been trying to charge up until now.
We agree 100% with Jobs and Apple, and although the move comes 8 months after the launch of the video iPod, any studio that doesn’t go along with the Apple position, will be concerned, and quite rightly that it will miss out on huge online revenues. Jobs will ensure that any contract that ties in the studios, ties them in good and proper, in the same way that he tied in the record labels, likely to be for a minimum duration of five years.
If Apple gets its way, then overnight, the file download market will erupt. All the other services will have ‘most valued customer’ deals and will drop their prices, and anyway it would make no sense to let Apple shift its wares at one price, and everyone else have to sell above that price. That would just automatically give Apple the kind of dominance in films that it had in music.
Paramount would be soon to follow if the others do cut a deal, and Sony will be forced first to offer the same service, using its Connect service and its own films to download, at the same price, for the PlayStation Portable, and then it will almost certainly be forced to open them up to the video iPod as well, in order not to be deprived of the volume the iPod promises.
The NY Times has it that Jobs has been in a huddle now for weeks with studios heads and that he should have a deal in place ready to drive sales by autumn.
It is unlikely that Disney, in which Jobs is the largest shareholder, will tell him no, and that will almost certainly trigger one or more of the others. Apparently previous talks were held with the studios, presumably when the Video iPod was being prepared for launch, and that perhaps explains the weak content platform Jobs had last October, when he chose to launch anyway with just five TV series and a handful of Pixar films plus 2,000 music videos. Already Apple’s success has meant that iTunes already has a lot more than that.
The studios shouldn’t complain about the potential loss of revenue if they charge just $9.99. For a start it is likely that they will make just as much for themselves as they do on DVD sales, and they should think about the long tail of back issue classics which are bringing them virtually no revenue right now, which could suddenly leap back into life and create a whole new revenue area for them. Sony alone has some 8,000 film properties if you include its 2004 acquisition of MGM.
The other big concern will be the studios keeping their relationships alive with DVD shippers such as Amazon and Wal-Mart. But if Wal-Mart suddenly decided that it wanted to drop DVDs, first it would miss out on a huge amount of business, because of the slow adoption of online film downloads. Also it should suddenly do a roaring trade in blank DVDs for storing the downloaded films.
The discussions have re-ignited the idea that Apple will release a DVR in times for the Christmas period, which would also play the iTunes downloaded content, straight to a TV screen, rather like the Akimbo service.
iTunes video is currently about halfway between the QVGA which is right for viewing on a small screen, and VGA, which is fine for viewing on a PC or a TV and Apple might have to move to a two tiered offering, with multiple pixel definitions at different prices if it wants to show movies on TVs.
But more likely is that Apple feels that its recent design of PCs are attractive enough to place in the living room to act as TVs. Last year Apple introduced Front Row capabilities for watching video on a Mac which has a remote control.