When you ponder the 285 million souls that make up Eastern Europe, and just how much TV they have, it’s easy to be reminded of an old ‘shoe salesman’ joke.
A shoe salesman went to a desert country and phoned complaining to his boss, ‘I can’t make any sales, these people don’t wear shoes.’ The boss sent a replacement and when the replacement first phoned his boss he said, ‘Thanks boss, a whole country to sell in and none of them have any shoes yet.’
In Eastern Europe it’s about a difference of attitude when selling digital media, IPTV, triple plays and the like. The TV there is not great, so there are potentially 285 million people to sell to, but many of them don’t yet know what’s possible with TV.
But judging from the visitors and speakers at the IPTV World Forum Easter Europe, held in Budapest, Hungary last week, most of the equipment vendors and suppliers have a pretty good understanding of the size of the opportunity. However some speakers gave us a feel for the size of the problems of living in countries that have only recently come out of the grip of the USSR, and are still dogged by outmoded regulators, under strength infrastructure and local poverty.
Not to say that poverty is here to stay, at least not in some of the countries of Eastern Europe. GDP per person is highest in the Czech Republic Hungary, and Slovakia but the key factor, the growth in GDP, is above 4% in countries like Romania, Bulgaria, the Ukraine and Russia.
Where these countries are not yet rich enough to support IPTV systems they can support public internet video, and very shortly they will be rich enough for the whole works.
Which is why UPC, the biggest cable operator in Europe was at the show, defending its position as a pay TV operator across Europe, including Romania, one of Eastern Europe’s poorest countries.
Already in the rival Cable TV market there are new initiatives in Estonia, Poland, Romania, the Czech Republic and Hungary to name but a few and there are new VoIP services in Poland, and Romania. So the war between IPTV and cable continues in Eastern Europe.
The conference heard about new IPTV systems in Hungary, in Russia, in the Czech Republic, Slovakia and in Romania, and some of these are very advanced services. We can see on the one hand the influence of Western Europe with Deutsche Telekom, France Telecom, Telefonica and TeliaSonera buying incumbent telcos outright and bringing investment and modern ADSL2+ and VDSL2 broadband networks straight to the region.
So in Hungary T-Online has bought the Magyar Telecom incumbent and is launching full IPTV services based on the Microsoft Alcatel system ready for launched any day now. But progress will be slow, even if T-Online doesn’t think so. So far it only has 237,000 ADSL lines in a country that has a population of 10.1 million.
Even so T-Online Hungary will begin any day and already is within reach of 60% of the country’s broadband customers and has plans to build its fiber further out, and to upgrade broadband services to 50 Mbps and offer high definition services. A quadruple play including T-Online is virtually a certainty.
Cesky Telecom, acquired last year by Telefonica, talked about the way in which the hugely successful Imagenio system developed in Spain, had been easily transported into being operational in the Czech Republic. There was no concern about Lucent taking the service on, and just a handful of Telefonica engineers went onsite and the service launches this year, with virtually no hitches. The hitch of course may be in selling the service. Broadband here has to be priced at around €10 to €12 a month ($12 to $14) and is a country where less than 50% of homes have any kind of fixed phone line (there is 100% mobile penetration though) and there are only 338,000 Cesky broadband lines. Again this is a country of around 10.2 million people, so there’s a long road ahead here, although the only way is up.
But the incumbents had far more problems with regulators making arbitrary rules and global content companies being disdainful of offering local operators content when they only have the prospect of selling it in small volumes for years to come. We heard that one operation in Romania had a complete IPTV network for an entire year, but with no content on it.
That all said and done, most estimates have it that Eastern Europe will reach 44 million pay TV homes in the next 4 years, making it a considerable portion of global pay TV systems.
The conference also heard a lot about public internet video, and there is every possibility that free streamed services, supported by advertising and video downloads will take off here faster than genuine IPTV and triple play.
Both Hungarian and Polish Television talked about a huge upswing in traffic on their web sites from putting video content up and both had begun to see that this is a way forward for broadcasters, who are threatened by the gradual erosion of their advertising revenues by the internet. On a smaller scale this is similar to the efforts of US broadcasters such as CBS and ABC, who are very aggressively using TV over the internet to top up their advertising revenue, as advertising sales fall across their broadcasting networks.
The Polish TV trials in particular mean that all Polish TV can be streamed, some for free, some for a small subscription, to Polish speakers all over the world. The only problem they have encountered is that the local France Telecom owned incumbent has blocked the traffic over its network, and insists on substantial peering charges to carry the traffic, which threaten the service.
On the subject of blocking, UPC regional chairman Nimrod Kovacs made himself the ‘bad guy’ of the conference, when he said that he too would block competitor’s traffic over his network where it is legal to do so, and if that traffic competed with his services. So perhaps the US is the wrong place to start forming net neutrality laws, and the European Commission would be a better place to address the issue first, and police it first in its new member states (although much of Eastern Europe is outside the EC’s remit).
From outside the region the conference was treated to samples of how PCCW’s Hong Kong service works, courtesy of Entone’s involvement there, and the show also had a visit from UTStarcom, in town to launch its new IPTV services in Eastern Europe.
Entone’s Sarah Hackforth described the operation at PCCW and how it grabbed 50% of the TV market in Hong Kong in two years. PCCW took advantage of the fact that cable operators had upset content providers and it landed a decade long exclusive with suppliers like HBO and ESPN.
One of the innovations that Hackforth talked about really struck home because it is so rarely seen. All the channels are unbundled. Customers don’t have to buy channels in bundles, but can buy them one at a time, and try them one at a time. The US cable operators are currently fighting (and have just beaten) the US regulator over this very point and should see what a competitive weapon it can be against the reluctant competition.
UTStarcom rolled outs its chief scientist Dr Qiang Li, making it clear how important it felt its embryonic European operation is. Li told revealing stories about the operation’s early days in China, warts and all, not using the conference, as some did, for blatant advertising, but instead showing how much thought is needed in IPTV systems, and by association how much experience UTStarcom has acquired.
One story sticks in the mind about how in the most Northerly Chinese province, when the incumbent launched an all you can eat subscription VoD service, UTS had to virtually redesign its system to accommodate the demand. It appears that it is so cold and boring there in the winter, that at least 300 occupants of a single village decided to fast forward through as many of the 3,000 films on file as possible, in order to decide if they wanted to watch that film after all, getting through 60 films a night and putting huge strains on the VoD servers. ‘At first we thought it was some kind of Denial of Service Attack,’ said Li and went on to explain how he had adjusted the architecture to get around the problem.
One final note came out of the conference that was surprising, with the entire audience and all the local operators convinced that VoD won’t work in Eastern Europe when anyone can walk to a street trader and buy any film they want, pirated, for just $1. ‘Hands up all those that think DRM will eventually prevent this,’ asked the chairman, and sadly not a single hand was raised, to the embarrassment and chagrin of all the conditional access suppliers present.