Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

20 September 2006

Private equity group looks set to pay $17.6bn for Freescale

Freescale Semiconductor has agreed to a private equity bid led by Blackstone Group for $17.6bn, or $40 a share, a deal that will, if finalized, be the largest ever leveraged buyout in the technology sector.

The agreement appears to end a bidding war that had erupted when another private equity consortium, led by Kohlberg Kravis Roberts and Bain Capital, entered the fray last week, with a higher offer but with a less certain outcome, since the partners had not even embarked on due diligence.

The announced price represents a 36% premium over Freescale’s average share price in the 30 trading days before September 8. Freescale can still solicit other offers for the next 50 days but calls this one “definitive”.

Private equity groups are rampant in the telecoms sector this year, and the latest sign of this trend was the bidding war between the two consortia for Freescale, which has led to a likely deal price that breaks the previous record for this class of transaction in high tech, set by Sungard Data Systems earlier this year at $11.3bn.

The rival bids came from, on one hand, Texas Pacific Group, Blackstone Group and Permira, and on the other, Kohlberg Kravis Roberts and Silver Lake Partners, the latter partnership, plus AlpInvest, recently won control of Philips’ semiconductor business, now called NXP, in a $4.4bn deal and may be looking to consolidate a range of chip companies over the coming year. Carlyle Group and Bain Capital are also said to be considering joining the former consortium, which is widely expected to be the winner of the deal.

What is the sudden attraction of Freescale, which was spun off from Motorola two years ago? It is certainly building up its strengths in areas of critical importance such as power management, and starting to emerge from the shadow of being Motorola’s in-house supplier (as well as riding on the coat tails of that company’s recent resurgence). But while both these trends could translate into increased value in 2007 onwards, this optimism must be offset by the likely decline in Motorola business once the companies’ tie-in deal expires, and by the fact that Freescale is dwarfed by Texas Instruments and others in key growth markets, amid a general consolidation of its sectors.

Of course, one appeal for private equity groups is that Freescale operates in a number of discrete businesses, which could gain higher value if broken up, and which can offset cyclical dips if kept together. The acquirer is likely to take one of two routes to extract maximum value out of Freescale. One is to jump on the semiconductor consolidation trend and acquire other companies with related products to create a volume giant for the low cost to midrange wireless and network computing spaces. This is thought to be the route favored by Blackstone and its partners.

The other is to break the company up, splitting off its transportation activities and its Network and Computing Systems group from the core wireless business. The latter is perhaps the most likely, given that the customer bases for the various activities are fairly distinct, but would remove one key Freescale advantage – reuse of architectures and common R&D across different industries. This is most obvious with the Power microprocessor architecture, codeveloped with IBM and Apple, which can be implemented across a huge range of applications from workstations to mobile devices to cars.

Either of the two routes could drive a shareholder value that Freescale has struggled to achieve on its own, despite healthy if un-dramatic financial progress over the past year and some increasingly strong technology differentiators. And despite those pluses, it has some problems looming on the horizon. The greatest doubt surrounding Freescale is how much of Motorola’s business it will retain. Motorola, especially with the runaway success of its RAZR handsets, has given Freescale a major boost in its early years as an independent, akin to the buoyancy Nokia gives TI. In the second quarter of 2006, Freescale made net sales worth $342m of semiconductors to Motorola, about 16% of its total sales across its three units, and well over half the total net sales of its wireless and mobile unit, which reached $514 million (much, though not all, Motorola business is with this division). The wireless and mobile group contributed most of the $127m increase in overall sales that Freescale enjoyed, year-on-year, in its Q2, and this was attributed mainly to demand from Motorola.

The challenge for Freescale is to ensure that it can keep its former parent hooked even as the guaranteed supply deal they signed at spin-off expires and the habit of buying Freescale potentially declines in the new culture of Motorola. Some of the chip company’s advantages are important to its largest customer in their own right, notably its market leading cellphone power management capabilities, and the retaining of the old alliance will also give Moto an influence over the technology agenda that it might not have with another supplier (an advantage Nokia certainly has from being TI’s dominant customer).

A larger number of tier one customers will be important to retain confidence however, and Freescale has made some progress in this respect, notably with its deal to be the premier technology provider for Toshiba’s new portable media player, Gigabeat, and for Sony’s digital music player, plus a contract with French phonemaker Sagem (unannounced agreements with Nokia and RIM are also apparently in place). In a move to sneak into TI’s kingdom, Freescale has also announced a collaboration with Nokia and Symbian to create a 3G cellphone reference design based on its single-core MXC300-30 chipset.

But over-dependence on one customer, as TI well knows, can seriously limit a company’s freedom of action and increase its risk, especially when some of the products it supplies are in decline – Freescale may provide 75% of the chips for the RAZR v3i, but it also is the exclusive supplier of silicon for the iDEN network, which will be gradually phased out by its only major carrier, Sprint Nextel (though dual-mode iDEN/CDMA phones to assist the subscriber transition should create a nice revenue stream for 2007-9 at least).

Another worrying factor is the collapse of some key partnerships, in a market where few companies can afford to go it entirely alone any longer. Recently, the Freescale-Agere-Infineon venture Star- Core, set up to challenge Texas Instruments in digital signal processing, was shut down, and now another alliance is under threat – as Philips’ spin-off NXP becomes independent, it may withdraw from Crolles 2, which was set up by the Dutch giant with Freescale and France’s STMicro to collaborate in the research, development and industrialization of CMOS process technologies from 90 nanometer to, ultimately, the cutting edge 32 nanometer. In a market where getting more efficient manufacturing processes online at an early stage is an increasingly critical differentiator, and one where TI consistently scores, this could be a heavy blow.

Despite these possible setbacks – which also include its loss to TI and Intel of the war to control emerging UltraWideBand standards – Freescale does have some key strengths too. It has stolen a march on most rivals with its advanced power management techniques, increasingly important with the rise in high function, multimode handsets and other devices. It has its auto chip business to offset the cycles of the mobile sector, and it is showing promising signs of a firm strategy for the evolving convergence trend.

At July’s Freescale Technology Forum in Orlando, Florida, the company showed off WiMAX and Wi-Fi platforms geared to home networks and mobile television, as part of a broader strategy to focus on providers offering fixed/mobile and triple play services to the residential market.

This trend could take Freescale further beyond handsets and into a wider range of devices for the converged home, such as gateways and VoIP platforms. The company also shows signs of wanting to use this market to move up the food chain to offer fully integrated products and reference designs, not just embedded processors, and so line up more naturally alongside Texas Instruments and Broadcom in the home as well as the smartphone sectors. With a growing focus on multimedia, Freescale already leads the market in supply of DVB-H tuner chips for mobile television, and has made a major bet on MRam (magneto-resistive Ram) memory chips, a high speed, non-volatile technology that could challenge SRam in future, though the chipmaker has no short term plans to adapt it for cellphones.

The other key product for Freescale is its latest application processor, the i.MX27, which focuses on high definition video for cellphones as well as VoIP and other portable multimedia applications. This gives the company a high end, multimedia offering to take up against the strengths of TI OMAP and Qualcomm in this area, and means it now has an application processor for all handset price ranges.

Seeking a technological edge that it often lacked at Motorola, Freescale has doubled its rate of patent filing in the past year as part of a drive by CEO Michel Mayer – ex of IBM’s chip business – to gain a more powerful intellectual property position, which he calls a “good defensive position” and a means of offsetting the intense price pressures on the semiconductor players. He told a recent interview that Qualcomm does not have to be cost competitive on chip manufacturing ‘because of their strong IP position. They are priced for value, like Windows XP’.

Qualcomm, of course, is fabless, and Freescale – even when still under the Motorola wing – has moved steadily to reduce its reliance on its own plants, although it retains them primarily for the auto business, which requires highly specialized units. But Mayer is unwilling to abandon fabs altogether, even for wireless chips, claiming that to survive as one of the only remaining manufacturers would bring competitive edge in terms of technology control and timing.

Overall, Mayer has brought steady, if undramatic, progress to Freescale and is gradually changing the company’s culture and strategy to reflect its independence, boosting its intellectual property and advanced technology weapons and seeking differentiation in multimedia, multi-network and low power applications. Some of this effort could go to waste in a private equity-inspired breakup or even a consolidation, but such a move would enable Freescale to adapt more rapidly to the increasingly harsh and competitive realities of the commercial chip market, and to life without the guarantee of Motorola’s patronage.

Freescale is the tenth largest chipmaker in the world with revenues of $5.9bn last year, which is forecast to grow to $6.3bn in 2006, and in the last quarter, it beat analyst expectations with net income of $260m. The stock has risen dramatically since the rumors first circulated last week and the company is now valued at around $15bn.

Apart from Motorola, key customers are Cisco (for routers), Sony Electronics and most of the tier one auto manufacturers, including Mercedes, BMW, Ford, Hyundai and General Motors.