It looks like all the pressures of the Faultline are beginning to bite at NBC Universal, the GE majority owned business created two years ago by buying Universal Studios from Vivendi for its national TV broadcasting network, NBC.
The company will cut around 700 jobs over the next two years, and look for other savings through consolidating locations, support functions and marketing activities.
The company says that it will reinvest any savings into higher-growth digital distribution areas which will grow to exceed $1 billion in revenues by 2009.
This, in our opinion, is code for ‘The rot starts here,’ and we invite you to think about the big US studios the way the big car making conglomerates of the US, Ford and General Motors and others are, and how they have been in what seems like terminal decline for most of our lives.
This is not a business that has temporarily lost its way and is seeking new management, but is under considerable multiple threats to how it currently does business and doesn’t know how to deal with them.
The entire rationale of a broadcasting business buying a content producer is to cut costs. NBC wanted to capture some of the world’s content making capability so that it could guarantee that it had some unique content. But all broadcasters everywhere are under the cosh of falling advertising revenues and feel the need to cut costs.
Content makers feel this in harsh negotiations with broadcasters, and the early discarding of TV series commissions that they thought were in the bag. When an audience drifts away from a major entertainment focus like broadcast TV, a decline which has been demonstrable in audience figures over the past five years in the US, then the advertising revenues have to seek better results elsewhere.
Is it too late to transfer the NBC model to the internet? No, it’s not too late, most of the US broadcasters only took such initiatives this year, but by arriving late, and with no management that fully understand the new internet video models, and who are culturally aligned with an outmoded way of doing business, we anticipate the potential for disaster.
Four US national broadcast networks don’t automatically set up shop as video portals and simply win the amount of business they had in a pre-internet era, there are lots of new businesses chasing that same business.
And besides the two sides of the business will be pulling each other apart. Content creation at Universal will want to go direct to the internet, bypassing NBC, while NBC will say ‘Hey we paid for most of that programming, we should get to exploit it on the internet first.’
NBC Universal actually has the audacity to name this set of moves ‘NBCU 2.0,’ aligning it with Web 2.0, when it actual fact it is a statement that says, ‘We are LAST to exploit the internet, and we’re very web 1.0.’
The announcements were made by Bob Wright, Vice Chairman of GE and Chairman and CEO, NBC Universal and he talked about operating efficiencies and reallocating resources to invest in new growth areas redirecting traditional analog resources to high-growth digital areas and international expansion.
“Success in this business means quickly adjusting to and anticipating change,’ he said, something that the company clearly has yet to achieve.
The company-wide initiative is expected to reduce the company’s annual administrative and operating expenses by $750 million by the end of 2008 resulting in a 5% workforce reduction.
Just where NBC is going to get $1 billion of revenue from in new digital content businesses, we don’t know and the statement only really gave detail of cost cuts. One such set of cuts were that newsgathering would be modernized to improve efficiencies. But if it was to be completely web 2.0 it would outsource newsgathering to the internet citizens, in return for advertising revenue share, but somehow we sense that’s not going to happen.
NBC news channel, MSNBC will move to existing operations in New York and New Jersey and new consolidated news facilities will be added in Burbank, while further reviews (read cuts) are also under way at NBC News bureaus and facilities around the world.
To talk so vaguely about new digital distribution opportunities and yet be unable to name them, or trials for them or measured results for early digital deals, is to clutch at straws.
NBC promised to sign new distribution outlets for its content and the company says that its strategy is to reduce dependence on traditional content distribution methods and advertising models. But those very models are embedded in NBC DNA.
The aim is to bring content to consumers sooner on a variety of platforms, over the internet and mobile TV, and the company says it will be developing alternative advertising metrics.
All of the US studios would love to get away from reliance on Nielsen Media, but for measuring broadcast TV audiences Nielsen is virtually a monopoly. The only way to get alternative metrics to drive its ad sales is to resort to the interactive nature of the internet, where it can be done in software.
NBC says it will also realign its domestic theatrical distribution and home entertainment and television arms.
NBC Universal is 80% owned by General Electric and 20% owned by Vivendi.
Our take is that this is a company run by a conglomerate, so that doesn’t have its own share price to protect, which means it has lost touch with its value as an organization. At least when Vivendi got out of touch with internet routes to market, its share price could bring pressure to its management and drive change. Not so at NBC, which is why it is one of the last to embrace its inevitable digital future. Disney has Steve Jobs to help interpret the new digital markets, who will help NBC?