Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

15 November 2006

Sony PS3 enters life by shooting itself in the foot

There are only so many times that a company like Sony can shoot itself in the foot before it has no legs to stand on, but attracting a while raft of negative publicity on the week of its PS3 Japanese launch, has to beat almost all of Sony’s blunders during the past four unhappy years.

Virtually all this week’s coverage bangs on about the fact that over 200 old games from the original PlayStation and PS2, fail to play. Given that it’s out of a total of around 8,000 games it’s not too bad a problem, but you’d think someone would have checked. It’s a software problem that could have been fixed had someone at Sony noticed it, and many of the failures are down to the audio not playing properly.

After more than five years creating a unique, supercomputer powered console, it manages to bungle the simplest of claims at the final hurdle. Microsoft has swallowed its pride and jumped off Intel chips and onto the IBM originated Power 5 chip for its Xbox 360, and sacrificed the idea of having a device that was backward compatible. That made Sony’s effort of bundling lots of free network based copies of older games, look like a marketing masterstroke. Except that it has now backfired. The company says that it will issue a fix in the next few weeks, but it sounds like it is too late to upgrade the software prior the US launch which is this Friday.

Sony also managed to renege on its promise to have 2 million devices ready for launch, and in the end only shipped 100,000 devices to stores, randomly disappointing some stores and making them tell customers the bad news, and promising to make up the numbers by Christmas. It seems the problem was with the Blu-ray high definition DVD players, and the inclusion of these into the device is a decision that has dogged delivery from the moment it was known, around a year ago. The lack of Blu-ray’s readiness pushed back the launch of the device originally and led to Xbox having a free run at the market which has now stretched to a full year.

Game magazine site Enterbrain says that in the first two days in Japan around 88,000 of those PS3s were sold, which looks like another mistake by Sony, because there are thousands of disappointed orders laying unfilled in stores that have run out, while a few stores will take into this week to complete the sale of their first batch.

By comparison the Nintendo Wii is getting ready for a December debut in Japan with 400,000 machines available on day one, a rising share price and almost universal acclaim from reviewers, many of them lavishing praise on its wire free controller, mostly due to the fact that it has included force feedback vibration on the device, where Sony hasn’t.

The Wii remote controller also features motion-sensing and to throw a pass in an American Football game the player simply mimes the movements of a quarterback’s arm.

If this battle to claim ownership of the living room media hub was based on execution alone, Sony would already be in last place, but it isn’t. Instead many reviewers look at the Sony graphics and gloss over them because the PS3 has had such a long introduction, they have already spent all their superlatives over the quality of the color, and rendering detail years ago.

The man in the street however that has not attended the last three E3 gaming shows is likely to be pretty agog when faced with 1080p resolution in a game.

One reassuring piece of news for Sony is that most customers, some 62%, have elected to buy the more expensive of the two available devices, opting for the wi-fi connectivity and the larger 60 GB hard drive on the $599 priced version, rather than the $499 device with a smaller hard drive.

The question mark about the device pricing will remain until Christmas, but if Sony sells all the PS3s it can make by then, it will be set fair to once again lead the gaming market, and the only detail to establish is whether or not the Xbox 360 can stand comparison with the far more powerful Sony device, and maintain its own sales.

The Nintendo Wii is far cheaper than either the PS3 or the Xbox and if it has the kind of appeal that reviewers predict for it, then all the surveys out there will be forced into a re-write, because it could outsell the Microsoft box and form a price sandwich either side of the Xbox with the Sony device. People that want a cheap gaming device might opt for the Nintendo and those wanting the best, the PS3.

The new Sony Blu-ray player though has already received plaudits from the few that have managed to get their hands on one, with critics claiming it produces sharper images than the first to market the Samsung Blu-ray player which actually costs more than a PS3.