Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

20 December 2006

GSMA backs ETSI changes on patents

The cellco trade body, the GSM Association (GSMA), has urged the wireless industry to increase the transparency around intellectual property rights related to new technology standards.

Pulling no punches in its statement last week, the GSMA suggested other standards bodies should follow the lead of Europe’s ETSI, which is making significant changes to its policy and procedures regarding declaration of IPR claims. It wants to insist that any such claims are made in advance of a standard being finalized, to avoid patent holders emerging from the woodwork once a market is established and demanding high fees once vendors are over a barrel. It is also introducing safeguards that will enable IPR holders voluntarily to declare the terms and conditions attached to their IPR ahead of the standardization of a new technology.

ETSI has also declared that it will no longer be mandatory for the organization to select technologies purely on the basis of their technical merits and regardless of other considerations, a more realistic approach that needs to be emulated by the IEEE, which is still living with the fiction that its workgroup decisions are not influenced by commercial and political agendas.

The issue came to a head as standards bodies started looking at the intellectual property licensing costs likely to relate to the forthcoming successor to W-CDMA/HSxPA, LTE or Long Term Evolution. ETSI suggested capping the IP rights for this emerging technology to 3-5% of the cost of all LTE gear. This is an issue that has also been of key interest to the WiMAX Forum, with uncertainty over patent ownership in 802.16 – particularly by Qualcomm – one of the technology’s obstacles in 2005-6. Recently, the Forum commissioned a study of the IPR in its standards and said that there was no dominant stakeholder, with Samsung the largest on about 25% of IPR ownership, and that 80% of the top patent holders were in the Forum and therefore subject to its rules on ‘reasonable and non-discriminatory’ licensing charges. (Qualcomm, of course, is not in the Forum and has not yet fully shown its hands on its WiMAX IPR, although it has signed two licensing deals related to the technology already.)

ETSI’s changes were spurred earlier this year when a group of operators led by Vodafone, T-Mobile, Orange and KPN threatened to hold patent holders to ransom by delaying finalization of standards until the IPR issues were solved. They claimed that, if suppliers did not sign up to the proposed agreement, they would lobby to exclude their patents from the standard.

Alex Sinclair, chief technology officer of the GSMA, said: “As the underlying technologies in mobile telecommunications become more intricate, there is a danger that excessive cumulative license fees for the use of intellectual property will slow, or even prevent, the adoption of new technologies within the worldwide mobile operator community. The changes announced by ETSI will reduce that danger. Other standards bodies should consider taking similar steps to create a less unpredictable commercial environment around new standards.”

To back up its new stance, ETSI has created a permanent IPR Committee that will meet when significant IPR-related issues arise.