Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

22 January 2015

The other 3 billion need food before they get the internet

Just as the US is tied up right now in deciding on how and if it wants Net Neutrality, with the main reason for needing such rules being the limited number of players US consumers can buy internet access from.

So it would be nice to suddenly have a new technology which is viable for delivering the internet to everyone, and we had multiple reminders this week that satellite may shortly become an option.

They come in the form of deals cut around new ventures targeting satellites. But can the harum-scarum nature of Low Earth Orbit, mass satellite ventures, involving constellations of hundreds, if not thousands, of satellites, ever really make a difference?

This week the news is mostly about serving the 3 billion people who so far, do not have the internet, and it’s not so much about supplying the individuals and homes which are on the edge of modern societies, such as the rural parts of the US, France or Spain – although it could be about them too since any complete constellation design would also reach these people.

The first new event on satellite internet in the early part of the week was the deal that WorldVu Satellites announced with both Qualcomm and the Virgin Group in the UK, who are to be initial investors, in a venture called OneWeb, with Qualcomm Chairman Paul Jacobs and Virgin founder Richard Branson to join the company’s board. Subsidiary Virgin Galactic will supply the launch vehicles to put the satellites into space.

This company plans to build a Low Earth Orbit version of what CEO and founder Greg Wyler has already built for his previous company O3B. That business used Medium Earth Orbit satellites about 5,000 miles away from the Earth to create a kind of “backhaul in the sky” for any kind of network, but particularly for operators wishing to offer mobile broadband to parts of the world which currently have no broadband and no real connection to the internet.  O3B stands for the Other 3 Billion, and its investors include SES and Google.

In other news this week it was thought that Google was separately backing yet another similar venture, putting a reported 4,000 satellites into space. Each LEO satellite has to spin around the planet at high speed and cannot be geostationary (they have to be 22,000 miles away to do that) this many satellites, all between 100 and 1200 miles from the Earth, this creates the effect with thousands of them, of a whirling defensive scythe around the planet and makes it tough for new satellites and other rockets, to avoid collisions with them.

This is especially true in a potential future, when they turn into non-functioning space debris, and unless they are both put into space and subsequently brought down (or sent off into space), they might just encircle the planet with navigation problems. So there are only so many companies which can try this and if they were too close, the prospect of antagonistic regimes shooting them out of the sky might also emerge. The satellites in question will only weigh 125 kilograms, but even at this size if they were to break up, they would create clouds of metal particles that would simply block the way to the stars.

The common denominator in the real Google deal, just unearthed by newspapers, is the elusive Elon Musk, technology entrepreneur extraordinary. Musk made his first fortune in software, his next on Paypal and subsequently is driving ventures in electric cars, space exploration, solar power systems and his Hyperloop transportation system, which allows high speed land travel at air speeds, through a vacuum tube, which he says can be run entirely on Solar energy.

It is the Space Exploration Technologies or SpaceX part of his exploits that appears to have attracted Google, a company designed to get people into space economically, and so far it has fired the first privately funded liquid-fuelled vehicle into Earth orbit. Musk also has dreams of putting people on Mars in case we on Earth blow ourselves up.

The latest version of events is that Google is engineering a $1 billion investment into SpaceX, putting up half the money itself. Meanwhile Wyler is still associated with O3B, which has four satellites in play and which could accommodate up to 100, all offering multi-gigabit per second access.

Even if you add the total capacity of the new OneWeb with 640 satellites each with 14 Gbps capacity we are only talking about a total annual payload of such a system, working flat out 24×7 of something like 35 Exabytes. Given the internet will reach 1 Zettabyte in 2016, that amounts to about 3.5% of global internet capacity. If this is shared with 3 billion people, that amounts to about 1 GB per year, for each person. It’s a start, but it won’t get the whole 3 billion very far.

But is it a wise investment at $1.5 billion? Well that may not be the entire costs of putting those satellites in space, and there will be running costs and ground stations to build and sell, but even at $1 per MB this would bring in some $350 million a year. Given that current satellite data plans are many times higher than this (we sampled some at $4 per megabyte this week) then selling this data through a global network of resellers, is almost certain to turn a profit over the 7 years minimum-duration of the satellites. Though we are not sure how much of that money the last 3 billion could raise, so perhaps the apparent targeting of those 3 billion isn’t so altruistic after all, and perhaps much of the traffic will go to rich operators.