An unnamed FCC official has confirmed to the Washington Post that the FCC will vote on outlawing legislation that prevents municipalities from installing their own broadband networks in the FCC’s February 26th meeting. With the US President throwing his hat into the ring, in favor of tearing up the rulebook, the FCC is apparently torn over the issue.
A statement from FCC chairman Tom Wheeler has confirmed the vote, saying “while fast broadband is available to some, there are too many parts of the country, particularly rural America, that are being left further and further behind. Many other Americans lack competitive choices for broadband. The FCC has been working diligently to expand broadband deployment and increase consumer choice nationwide, including reviewing complaints from cities that have been prohibited from providing competitive high-speed alternatives.”
But fellow FCC commissioner Michael O’Reilly, a Republican, argues that such a decision “is completely without statutory authority and would be a good candidate for court review, if adopted.”
O’Reilly’s argument, and the wider political argument in the US that centers around the federalization of the states that comprise the nation, is that a state should be allowed to set its own legislation – and that the national government should respect the state’s decisions, which are in theory the ultimate distillation of the democratic will of the people.
The Republican commissioner adds, “In reality, this debate is about preempting a state’s right to prevent taxpayer rip-offs. Municipal broadband has never proven to be the panacea that supporters claim and the Administration now boasts. Instead, we have seen a long track record of projects costing more than expected and delivering less than promised.”
Earlier in the week, Obama used a visit to Cedar Falls, Iowa, to urge the FCC to repeal the 20 state laws that currently inhibit municipalities from setting up their own broadband networks. The president also announced that the Department of Agriculture would set up a system of loans for rural areas to construct networks, and the Department of Commerce would provide assistance too.
Cedar Falls built its own FTTH network after running a broadband network successfully for 20 years, and the White House response to the Republican argument is that if a community like Cedar Falls wants to set up a network, there shouldn’t be a law on the books preventing them from doing so. “More competition means better products and cheaper prices.”
The Republican rhetoric used to counter that argument will likely center around honoring the business contracts that were agreed between states and telcos, and effectively enshrined into law – and in some cases actually written into the law books after ISPs lobbied at the state level.
The power of lobbyists in the US is already a contentious issue, but most of the arguments that have been put forth this week center around whether laws preventing new entrants should be protected by the courts – something that the Center for Public Integrity’s 2014 report argues very strongly against.
Cities or towns which already operate an electrical utility are best placed to install a broadband network, as they already have the truck roll, pole-access and rights of way to install data wires next to the power lines. Chattanooga’s EPB (Faultline, July 17, 2014) is the most notable city to install a gigabit network for its citizens, and is currently petitioning the FCC, along with Wilson, NC, to override the laws that put restrictions on their projects (such as only being allowed to sell to electricity customers) and make similar projects illegal in many states.
But the National Cable and Telecommunications Association (NCTA) has unsurprisingly been vocally opposed to any change in the law, arguing that its members have spent $230 billion over the past two decades upgrading their networks – while simultaneously failing to count that as an operating cost or investment from which the ISPs have profited heavily. There was also no mention of the government grants and subsidies that were allocated for network upgrades – which many would classify as exactly the sort of taxpayer rip-off that FCC chairman O’Reilly is so staunchly against.
The NCTA’s Brian Dietz has also argued that “there have been several examples where government-run networks have failed because they aren’t able to compete effectively with private-run networks.” Dietz pointed to Provo, Utah, which spent more than $39 million building a fiber network which it ended up selling to Google for a single dollar.
The Provo example, as well as four others which include Salisbury, NC’s project that forced Moody’s to downgrade the city’s credit rating, sound like a powerful argument until you start looking at the other 450 municipal broadband projects in the US.
Of these, most were not initially funded by tax dollars, and most have avoided financial difficulties. Around 100 have found themselves in financial trouble, but there are other metrics besides revenue and profit that can be used to measure success.
In markets where Google Fiber or a city has launched a service to rival the local cable or telecom incumbent, the price of the incumbent’s packages have fallen – a saving generated by competition that can be passed onto the consumer and spent elsewhere in the local economy. Similarly, every new entrant generates another opportunity for equipment vendors to pick up new customers, and OTT services will look to attract new customers who have access to the bandwidth required to stream HD content in the wake of a network upgrade.
Then there are the harder to quantify benefits to consider, which better and more competitive internet access can bring. Chattanooga has attracted a wealth of startups to its city limits thanks to its gigabit connections, which could generate new hubs in cities and towns that adopt a similar approach. Faster connections, with their snappier page load-times and uninterrupted streaming performance, are also a hard to quantify benefit that consumers stand to experience in a more competitive market.
Given Wheeler’s ongoing attempt to redefine broadband as 25 Mbps up and 3Mbps down, up from the current 4 up 1 down, equipment vendors could soon see the fruits of a radical shakeup in the US market. If broadband is redefined and more projects are able to go ahead in the wake of a law change, those in the business of selling routers and CPE could see an upswing in sales volumes – and won’t care if they’re selling them to an incumbent or an upstart city council or rural cooperative.