Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

16 October 2014

Aereo “Not Dead Yet” seeks plan B through OTT MVPD status

Aereo has said in a blog that it wants the FCC to grant it MVPD status which would allow it to approach TV channels for broadcast retransmission deals. We had previously thought that Aereo was dead in the water, simply because our impression was that Aereo would be frozen out of the retrans market by high prices, set by a vengeful broadcasting community, still annoyed that Aereo had the temerity to steal its programming, without payment, in its prior business model.

This blog is perhaps a forlorn hope. But… it is fairly straightforward that the FCC plans to remove “network ownership” from the requirements to be an MVPD. While Barry Diller, who funded Aereo through his IAC vehicle, clearly had hoped that he might get away with simply taking free to air broadcasts for nothing, he is perhaps, after all, not just in this market for the quick kill. He may decide to rally other funders behind Aereo and build the next US OTT delivery vehicle, which has retrains consent.

You may even argue that Diller knew all along that Aereo could not have a free ride and that he was planning this stage a while back. We don’t know Diller except by reputation, but his reputation would have it that he has one of the widest understandings of TV in the US, as well as a preference for innovation and new ideas. Given that, he may well have known that Aereo was a long road that someone had to go down in order to get precisely what the FCC is now proposing, an agreement that MVPDs can use the internet for delivery, not their own networks.

The DTH community had to go down a similar “proving” route that required a long view, before it became accepted as a genuine rival to cable in the US. Diller would know this and perhaps when he made comments like “there is no plan B” for Aereo, he was simply bluffing, trying to win his Supreme Court case. Now perhaps he is ready with Plan B after all.

Broadcasters in the US have shown a history of resisting change, in whatever form it has taken, with legal proceedings their weapon of choice. They tried to sue against the VHS recorder, the DVR, the nPVR and the use of User Generated Content websites like YouTube. In the early days of piracy the industry behaved like the music industry in trying to sue its customers for more or less any internet related initiatives – instead of embracing them.

Broadcasting has, most recently, conducted a campaign to rid itself of the control of the cable TV industry, by negotiating huge retrans consent increases from cable and DTH, with contracts that also allowed the free distribution by those companies in their TV Everywhere systems, but at the same time allowed the broadcast companies the right to sell to OTT organizations.

What would be the point of fighting for that right, and then putting the price of retransmission consent over the internet at too high a price or failing to offer it at all.

At Faultline we feel that there are many disturbing trends right now that must be driving at the heels of the US broadcasting giants.

1) The global consolidation of operators of all types – cable, DTH, cellular and telco – in some cases one group buying into another or simply consolidation into larger blocks
2) The rising costs of broadcasting in comparison with internet delivery of content
3) Original content is coming more frequently from companies outside of the broadcast market, especially OTT
4) Public Broadcasters outside the US all have advanced OTT strategies
5) Sports bodies which control sports rights are increasingly looking to offer their own OTT services

The only trend in its favor is the way the movie industry has gone global, in the process ejecting writing, directing and acting talent which now fill the major US TV channels. This has seen the rise in the understanding of what is a TV mega series, often lasting ten seasons and bringing in close to $1 billion in total revenues over that time.

Sometimes it is easy to believe the rhetoric which is spoken around legal actions, so much so that we might believe that broadcasters would NEVER ever speak to Aereo about retransmission rights, and if forced would ask punitive pricing for such services. But where large amounts of money are concerned, emotion is not usually part of the equation and the rhetoric can soon turn around. We see it in channel disputes where the two sides contradict each other publicly, denouncing the other for being greedy, then make up very publicly once a deal is done, and smile and say nice things about one another.

And that raises the possibility that Aereo would be used as an experiment for the national broadcasters in particular, to offer a retrans agreement with not quite so much up front, and a price per customer in line with the deals that have been struck with major cable operators.

Previously cable has made it clear that it would not renew deals with national US broadcasters if they were seen to be giving content away over the internet. But if broadcasters can open up a second front among OTT operators, then they can retain the advantage in retrans negotiations.

A buyers’ market is one where there are too few buyers and so they set the price. A sellers’ market is the opposite where there are plenty of buyers, so the seller, sets the price. Right now in broadcast TV content, it is a sellers’ market and if, against the rising tide of consolidation, the broadcasters want to keep it that way, then they need to create more buyers, by actively encouraging companies like Aereo to take their channels.

The only problem this presents to the consumer is that while it is a sellers’ market for broadcast TV content, there is unlikely to be much in the way of unbundling channel groups from one another. If broadcasters can set the terms of such a deal then they will insist on OTT providers taking and paying for their entire cluster of TV channels instead of simply just the popular channels – but that is a discussion for another day.

If you take this news that Aereo is looking for a second bite at TV, but this time paying its way in retransmission agreements, and add it to the news last week that the European Commission has used the Liberty Global merger with Ziggo to eliminate restrictive contracts there, which prevent TV Channels going OTT, then it is easy to see that OTT TV Channels are about to begin attracting major investments and the opportunity for US broadcasters to experiment with paid OTT in Europe, alongside pay TV licensing. The HBO statement this week tips its hat to that reality.

The hard news so far is that Aereo has filed a brief with the FCC seeking classification as an MVPD and is also talking in a blog about the clear benefits this would have to consumers, creators and distributors alike. Let’s see if there are any takers.