Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

16 October 2014

LGI-Ziggo merger must be seen through the lens of HBO going OTT

For all of the current year Faultline has been telling anyone who asked that Liberty Global would not be allowed to buy the “other” Dutch cable operator Ziggo, because it would cause too much market concentration.

Well it has now been granted permission to go ahead by the European Commission happened in a decision that will send out a signal to every cable player in Europe that it’s okay to merge.

This is the first time on an anti-trust subject that Faultline has made a wrong call for 35 years – well maybe we haven’t made a wrong call, maybe the European Commission has. We called it when the Justice Department blocked the AT&T T-Mobile USA merger, we even remember sitting through a farcical Microsoft trial in the US only to see the European commission curb the activities of Microsoft after its own Justice Department had failed make a move. The European Commission has tended to be the enforcement arm of US anti-trust.

But we have miss-called this one. We still think it is a poor decision, but we think we can see precisely what the European Commission is saying – “Let’s not fight against the rising tide of operator consolidation, instead let’s set rules which prevent the abuse of dominant broadband operators and how they affect net neutrality.”

When we spoke just after our last issue went to bed to the Authority on Consumers and Markets, the Dutch regulator, their spokesman said they had given the European Commission much of the local market data and they agreed with the outcome. They will not be raising an appeal, although other rivals could try it, but we suspect not. KPN is the only company that will find the going hard, and it may take legal action if there is any to be taken.

But in mitigation the Netherlands has just had Vodafone enter the pay TV and broadband market, and we should have seen in that decision the fact that Vodafone may have already known that this was the way the Commission would react, and it felt it will get a good regulatory ride in the Netherlands since there is virtually no competition in broadband – except from struggling Telco KPN and its wholesalers, one of Europe’s many basket case incumbent telcos.

It is also a year since Netflix entered the Dutch market and the Commission here is trying to be clever. It does not want to regulate pay TV per se, but it wants to protect content diversity and so it has added two big remedies within this deal which may change the nature of the OTT video market substantially.

It has got the combination to agree (call it LGI-Ziggo) that it will remove any clauses for the next 8 years in content contracts that prevent a TV channel from both selling to LGI-Ziggo AND going on its own Over the Top, or with OTT partners. And it has said that LGI-Ziggo not only cannot block this content, but must provide adequate interconnection capacity through at least three uncongested routes into its Internet network. This reflects the reality that Netflix is finding in the US, where peering connections are being supported by its cash, rather than the ISP.

There is a third remedy which we think was obvious anyway, but LGI-Ziggo must sell off one of its film channels, specifically the weaker one Film1, so that it cannot have a dominant position in tying subscriptions to monopoly premium movie content. It must carry Film1 for at least 3 years as well. Interestingly the “other” film channel it owns is called HBO Netherlands, and after the top story this week, it is clear that this channel is flimsy in the sense that HBO is already planning to go over the top, which will prevent LGI-Ziggo from having move channel dominance with which it can enforce subscriptions.

The European Commission has approached this deal from the point of view of “How can we allow it,” and on that basis this may be the best outcome Netherlands can end up with. It is rather clever in that Netflix and HBO and other similar rivals will be able to sell within the Netherlands, with impunity, unworried about Network Neutrality considerations – as long as this agreement is adequately policed.

And there’s the rub, how do you police such a deal, and what if the Commission has got this wrong? What if no OTT services emerge, because they know full well that LGI-Ziggo and KPN will NOT obey these two rulings. Then all they have done has licensed a monopoly that will harm Netherlands citizens. Beyond that they have given the go ahead for a rush towards consolidation in countries that are dominated by cable. Previously the only European cable consolidation has either been from a point of view of cellcos or private equity groups buying cable or roll-ups have been allowed only in countries like the UK and Spain where cable is weaker than DTH.

But there is a rather more obvious betrayal of the local content market in that if you were a TV channel that had a contract with one of these suppliers and also with the other, you will soon be called into a brutal negotiation which beings “We appear to be paying you twice…” and ends with the content owner losing half its income.

It IS true that most content deals are based around the total number of people that the TV channel is delivered to, but that’s not always the case, and it is not entirely the case – in that there are often up front minimums agreed upon and flat rates above a certain number.

So while one provider can say, “Well I used to deliver it to 5 million homes, and I still do, so the bill doesn’t change,” other content providers will have special terms which mean merging contracts will result in an automatic fall in revenue. Then there are those really uncomfortable conversations which are based on straight blackmail – “We are now the largest provider in the Netherlands, if you want to renew our deal, I want to pay less – discuss?”

This happened to John Malone, the Chairman of Liberty Global when Comcast bought AT&T Broadband in the US and he had to bite his lip then. So it’s not as if his acolyte and Liberty Global CEO Mike Fries has no precedent to draw on, and the content bill of the two combined companies will fall dramatically (but quietly) over the coming 24 months. And we consider that a betrayal of the European content industry by the Commission’s blindness.

The Commission never addressed this issue directly saying only that “These commitments remove the Commission’s concerns,” referring to the Film1 enforced sale.

The other betrayal of this rather naïve deal is to the rest of Europe. Liberty Global now has a formula under which it can buy in excess of 60% pay TV market share or 50% broadband market share and be entitled to be surprised if the deal does not go through. It will be able to brandish its new terms of agreement, and expect the deal to be ushered through. On that basis it has the right to buy very cable company in Europe until it is larger than any telco, including the giant Deutsche Telekom.

But where we are most worried is how this translates to the US. Again Malone is one of the central figures in that debate, one which is not going so well. Malone, with his relationship with Charter, is supposed to be against the Comcast TWC deal, but he still benefits from it, so he is in a no lose position.

Meanwhile Comcast customer care has come in for an obscene amount of adverse publicity. This week Comcast officials are being accused of billing a consumer incorrectly for a year and when he complained about it, talked to his employer and lost him his job. It doesn’t matter whether or not this is true, because it comes in the context of major customer care bungles by Comcast, which have been taped and placed on YouTube and show the company’s ethics in a very poor light.

But even against this type of backdrop, which was likely orchestrated by parties with axes to grind, purely to embarrass and threaten the merger approval, the idea of using the case to kill off Network Neutrality issues will remain tempting. The US has a far worse position on net neutrality in that many vocal representatives don’t actually agree with the underlying principle.

If Comcast is forced in a merger agreement to open its connectivity to OTT video delivery, and improve connections at its own cost to do so, then 40% of the US broadband capacity will swing the market in the direction of becoming Network Neutrality enthusiasts by consent decree. The FCC would love that and could stop gnashing its teeth at every fresh insult to the principle. Similarly, taking away any contract clauses that prevent TV channels from going over the internet, would virtually overnight open up the doors on an entire industry. Let’s face it all TV channels are afraid of losing their sweet deals with Comcast, and if they can go OTT as well, they can definitely make more money.

This would kill off at a stroke all opposition to Netflix contracts and drive the VC community to fund a whole swathe of new OTT businesses. This wold give the appearance of a defeat for Comcast and its ilk, but of course what they lost in TV revenues they wold more than make up for in broadband.

If you add that to the recent rule-making from the FCC, opening up Program Access Rules to Online Video Providers, so they can purchase retransmission rights from broadcasters, then you have a formula for mass desertion of the pay TV market in favor of OTT – cord cutting, which could create real content competition. And no-one gets hurt. Cable companies are in the driving seat for providing that extra bandwidth capacity to make it all possible.

This is hugely significant. Why not buy a channel straight from its owner? And if you do that with 8 or 9 channels, then that is unbundling the channels – a la carte. And if you do that, the pay TV ARPU in the US would go to the floor and everyone would feel that they had won. Except the consumer would find that the lack of competition in US broadband markets would suffocate this and the price of broadband wold rise.

Such an agreement would also kill the TV Everywhere strategies of the US pay TV companies stone dead. Why buy into Xfinity if you can buy 10 channels OTT for a fraction of the price. The aggregator then would be the App provider (be that on the TV or the portable device) that can provider them all in a single package, not the cable company that provides them on the same device.

We wonder if this is put on the table for Comcast, if Comcast would actually accept it? Potentially it turns it into a bit carrier, which it always said it did not want to be (it’s really profitable if you do it well). But then again it also owns NBC Universal, so we don’t see it worrying overmuch on the new content front.

Going back to the Netherlands, the broadband market there does have some competition, even if it is only because of those who wholesale from KPN, such as Vodafone, as well as active fiber builders, such as Reggefiber (KPN owns just over half of it). So it’s a bit more competitive than the US. So as long as US operators proliferate an “ignore the consumer” customer care attitude, then creating competition for broadband becomes the prime market requirement for the US consumer. Simply allowing the “Who cares” attitude to traverse from Comcast to Time Warner Cable, is a good enough reason to stop the US deal. We await that outcome with bated breath.

But we would like to ask the Commission, what happens if you have got this wrong? What happens if content buying in the Netherlands falls dramatically or almost no channels are added OTT as planned by the Commission’s intervention. Will it be too late to save TV in the Netherlands? Probably, although it could always do what the French are so fond of and try to reverse the deal, years later.