Nobody builds their own CDN just to deliver software updates and operating system downloads, even if it does make the process faster and more reliable. We can conclude therefore that as Apple’s own CDN ramps up it will be delivering large amounts of data over it and that can only mean video. Even if the primary motive for building a CDN is quality of experience rather than cost saving, it would make no sense either economically or competitively to invest in massive CDN capacity costing more than $100 million, capable of carrying multiple terabits per second just to improve the admittedly patchy performance of its software updates, which have prompted numerous complaints from customers.
Establishing its own CDN does fit with Apple’s longstanding strategy of owning its whole ecosystem as its cloud services become an increasingly important part of its offering. When the principal role of the Internet for Apple was for delivering updates and iTunes downloads, it could profitably rely on third party CDN companies like Akamai and Level 3, as it has been. But video consumes far more bandwidth and when streamed is very demanding in terms of latency and jitter, which can only really be guaranteed with full control over the end to end infrastructure.
This does not necessarily mean owning the end to end path, which is impossible in the case of the last mile since that is in the gift of the local broadband service provider. But if you own the CDN you are much better placed to ensure delivery up to the interconnect with the local ISP and avoid that point becoming a bottleneck. Access bandwidth itself may or may not then be an issue, but at least all content providers will be in the same boat, providing net neutrality is upheld. In any case by owning the CDN it is possible to establish good service agreements with the ISP and ensure that the interconnects have plenty of capacity. Then as access network capacity continues to increase as fiber goes deeper and DSL vectoring improves, that will become a diminishing issue for delivery of OTT video, even at full HD, for more and more households across the developed nations at least.
As we reported a month ago, Alcatel-Lucent has shot an economic hole clean through fiber to the home technologies with its demonstration of 10 Gbps broadband speeds over the last 30 meters of twisted pair copper wiring. This is a major step forward because the last 30 meters is if anything more expensive to provision than all the rest of the last mile. It entails scheduling with customers, digging up gardens and drilling holes in walls, and is the most disruptive and expensive step in the creation of high speed broadband to the home in a Telco environment.
This is all why Netflix has been building its CDN for some years and has now established interconnection arrangements with ISPs like Comcast, AT&T and Verizon in the US. It is true that Netflix’ relationship with some of these ISPs has been factitious, but this partly reflects its business model, focusing heavily on price. For Netflix it is important that it pays as little as possible for interconnection to ISP access networks and preferably nothing at all, but for Apple that is not the case. Apple does not compete hard on price and is more relaxed about the interconnection agreements.
Of course with NDAs (Non-Disclosure Agreements) in place we are not privy to such arrangements and in any case Apple, true to form, has not even confirmed or denied the existence of its CDN. But tests done by various analysts, including Frost & Sullivan’s longtime CDN watcher Dan Rayburn, have used tools such as traceroute, which have confirmed that Apple is now delivering some of its content over its putative CDN. Traceroute is a widely used diagnostic tool that displays the path and transit delay of packets across an end to end IP connection. Its strength compared with some other tools like Ping is that it provides the round-trip times of packets received from each successive host on the route, rather than just end-to-end and so makes it possible to drill down into the path. Apart from such direct evidence it is also known that Apple does have its own interconnect agreements in place now with at least some ISPs, although here too details have proved elusive.
Of course there are huge differences between Apple’s profile and that of pure play OTT video providers like Netflix. While Netflix delivers almost exclusively video within a confined geography, albeit expanding, Apple has to reach out across the world. This is another reason Apple is not so bothered about paying ISPs for final delivery. It is also a reason why Apple will not be migrating all traffic to its own CDN for the foreseeable future and will continue to rely on third party providers like Akamai and Level 3 for a long time to come.
Much has been made of the likely impact Apple’s CDN will have on the revenue of CDN providers. Akamai has been deemed particularly vulnerable, since 10% of its traffic is consumed by Apple sending updates and downloads to its customers worldwide. But as the Netflix experience showed, migrating the traffic over will be quite a slow process and Apple will be retaining large amounts on third party CDN networks.
So while Akamai will lose some revenue, the impact will not be massive and that does seem to have been reflected in the relatively modest 4% fall in its share price when news that Apple’s CDN was now carrying significant amounts of traffic came out at the very end of July.
The relatively small impact on Akamai can be confirmed further by drilling down into the likely numbers. We do not of course know exactly how much Apple is spending with Akamai currently, but given this widely accepted 10% figure it cannot be more than $200 million and more likely $150 million, given that Akamai is heading for $2 billion revenue this year. Remember that Apple will have struck a harder bargain for such a large amount of data and so 10% of volume will not account for as much as 10% of revenue.
Apple is likely to diverted no more than 30% of this traffic at most from Akamai over the next two years, if past experience from Netflix and others is anything to judge by. This means Akamai might stand to lose $50 million over the next two years from Apple during which time its overall revenue looks set to continue growing healthily, projected to scale $3 billion by 2016. The loss will therefore be only 1% to 2% of total revenue and as we have said the Apple business is probably not generating much profit per unit of data, so the effect on the bottom line will be minimal. The same applies even more to Level 3.
It could be said that Akamai and Level 3 will lose out though on future video traffic that Apple will deliver, but then again they also stand to pick up some of that, especially outside the US. Paradoxically it may be that they end up quits without losing much business at all.
It remains to be seen when Apple will finally enter the video streaming business, but clearly it will initially be confined to the US. The CDN is a key enabler here, not for cost reasons, but to guarantee the end to end QoS and the whole thing doesn’t make much sense without the video dimension. But the actual timing of any launch will be determined by content rights and not technology or CDNs.
Apple’s $360 million acquisition in November 2013 of Israeli 3D sensor firm PrimeSense, which developed the technology behind Microsoft’s first Xbox Kinect gaming console, clearly heralded the development of a revamped Apple TV box designed to bring together video, apps and gaming, but acquiring sufficiently compelling content rights has proved difficult. It looks like Apple may have bitten off more than it can chew and that plans have in any case been delayed by the protracted Comcast Time Warner Cable negotiations, currently bogged down waiting for federal approval.
Meanwhile Apple has been gradually adding to the catalog of content on its existing $99 Apple TV streaming box in the US, including most recently new channels for Fox Now and CNBC, along with ABC News, PBS Kids, AOL On, and Willow. But these hardly amount to the premium material that would set the world alight for a live streaming service.