Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

7 August 2014

It’s time to take HBO over the top

Discussions resurfaced this week about divorcing Time Warner’s HBO from pay TV and taking it over-the-top, offering its movies and programs directly to subscribers without the rest of the pay TV bundle to go along with it.
Rumors are that 21st Century Fox’s Rupert Murdoch, who recently offered $75 million to buy Time Warner and then withdrew the offer, wanted to take HBO online to compete directly with Netflix. Many have wondered why Time Warner hasn’t done so itself.

‘It’s amazing to me why Time Warner CEO Jeff Bewkes is not using the tremendous archive of fantastic content that HBO has, to go head-to-head against Netflix,’ Mediatech Capital Partners managing director Porter Bibb told the Bloomberg Surveillance radio program this week. Bibb said he doesn’t think Murdoch ‘would make that mistake.’

HBO needs more subscribers. Pay TV growth has slowed substantially, and Netflix has now surpassed HBO in terms of domestic subscribers ‘ though not in global subscriber numbers.

In the States, estimates peg households without pay TV subscriptions to be between 8 and 10 million. Time Warner would certainly want to target these consumers with an HBO OTT service, but Bewkes has said the cord cutter demographic doesn’t offer enough of an opportunity to justify launching an OTT service. On the other hand, there are around 70 million homes in the US that subscribe to pay TV, but don’t get HBO.

Two points here: First, some of those 80 million (cord cutters plus pay TV subscribers without HBO) probably subscribe to Netflix. Research from Leichtman Research Group estimates 80% of Netflix subs are also pay TV subs.

Second, all Netflix subscribers are potential HBO Go subscribers. It would be interesting to know how many Netflix subscribers are also HBO subscribers. We’re betting there’s a little overlap, but not much. Where Netflix is additive to pay TV, it is in direct competition with HBO, more so now than in earlier years because of Netflix’s blossoming original content library. Netflix is now competing directly with HBO and other premium pay TV channels for series. HBO’s recent hit, ‘True Detective,’ could have been on Netflix, if Netflix had won the bid on it.

Time Warner is still hesitant to offer HBO as part of any package that may cannibalize its pay TV subscriptions. ‘We’re just trying to figure out how to do this in a way that enhances rather than subtracts from our business, that supports the distribution infrastructure that we need, whether it’s the TV one that goes to your house today, or whether it’s the broadband one,’ Bewkes said at an investor conference in May.

The solution thus far has been to offer HBO alongside a few other pay TV channels as a limited cable package targeted at Millennials.

A number of pay TV providers are offering these packages:
Time Warner offers HBO to broadband subscribers in a $49 per month cord cutter-targeted package with Comcast.
AT&T has a similar package that delivers limited basic pay TV channels, HBO and a broadband subscription.
Time Warner Cable also offers a cord-cutter special bundle, called ‘Start TV with HBO.’ It offers 20 basic cable channels, including HD local channels, and HBO. The services costs $30 per month, and includes access to the HBO Go OTT service.
Cox Communications was at one time offering an Internet+ HBO package with around 100 other pay TV channels. That experiment has since been shuttered.

Ironically, these packages seem much more likely to cut into existing pay TV subscriptions than offering HBO as a standalone OTT service. Limited pay TV packages are just that, pay TV packages with fewer channels and for less money. Consumers who are interested in watching pay TV but are paying $100 or more for a lot of channels they don’t watch may be tempted to ‘cord-shave’ down to one of these packages ‘ though that may depend on what those other channels are in the package. Actually, many of these offers only include the lower monthly fee for the first few months, then the monthly charge increases slightly, though the final price will still be lower than $100 or more per month that most US homes pay for TV.

On the other hand, there still hasn’t been much proof that Netflix or any of the other OTT services are jeopardizing pay TV, at least not in any significant way. The majority of Netflix subscribers are also pay TV subscribers, not cord cutters. And while Netflix is growing its original content library, there is still a lot of pay TV content on Netflix, much to the benefit of pay TV, as we have seen with ‘Breaking Bad.’

Finally, Time Warner is offering HBO as an OTT service in a handful of Nordic countries. It began doing so in 2012, and now has around 380,000 subscribers. According to Bloomberg, Time Warner ‘found that HBO as an OTT service increased cable TV subscriptions, rather than cannibalizing the main product.’

Consumers and analysts alike seem to think a standalone HBO Go service would benefit Time Warner, despite Bewkes’ repeated retorts that the economics of content licensing and, more importantly, original content funding can’t be supported by a $10 per month fee, as Netflix does.

Any discussion about HBO being used as an OTT service rather than a pay TV channel must start with pricing. Netflix charges around $10 per month for a large library of old TV shows and movies, and a handful of very pricey and popular original series. An OTT version of HBO would offer a much larger library of popular and award winning original series, and a smaller selection of films, for some price above $10.

Netflix subscribers are actually paying more than $10 per month to watch Netflix because they need a fast enough Internet connection at home to enjoy the content. For one of the Cox subscribers in our office, for example, that’s around $50 (for 5 Mbps) plus $10 per month for Netflix: a grand total of $60 to watch ‘House of Cards’ and ‘Orange is the New Black.’

Netflix has around 13 original series available to subscribers, along with a number of original documentaries, films and stand-up comedy specials. HBO is airing around 24 original series this year alone, alongside the films it offers. There are over 135 HBO originals in total.

If the HBO owners want to compete head-to-head with Netflix for cord cutter subs, a $49 Internet plus HBO Go package is actually a very attractive deal. And those cord cutters could easily add a Netflix subscription on top of that package and get all three ‘ Internet, Netflix and HBO ‘ for a price that really is quite reasonable.

There are three obvious potential distribution models for an OTT HBO service:
Stand-alone OTT service for older/library content, without any new content. This is the most obvious model for HBO to use, and it is shocking that Time Warner hasn’t done this yet. Why not launch an OTT service that only offers older shows from HBO such as ‘The Wire,’ ‘Sex and the City,’ ‘Six Feet Under,’ etc? It would be a great way to further monetize older series and content that is gathering dust in declining DVD sales. If the service also offered some older seasons of new shows, it may even boost HBO pay TV subscriptions. Because the content is older, with no new episodes coming in, the service could be priced around $10. It isn’t jeopardizing any new content, and it would serve mainly as a new revenue stream. HBO could even continue to license a portion of its library content to Amazon (as it currently does) and have two or more revenue streams on older content.

It could launch Internet plus HBO: A package that bundles HBO with an Internet subscription. This type of package will draw in some of those cord cutters and cord nevers, but leaves out the millions of pay TV subs that don’t get HBO, but do get Netflix. The question then becomes how to incorporate viewers that already have Internet and pay TV subscriptions into this package. The HBO OTT service should be additive for existing pay TV subscribers, just as Netflix is.

Or it could launch a regular OTT service, with all content available to anyone, without an Internet bundle. New episodes of each show could become available a week after it airs on TV, or more radically, new seasons of its TV shows could only become available after the season has aired on TV. HBO could also introduce advertising into the OTT product. This service could easily cost more than $10 per month, perhaps as much as $20. HBO could also offer a discounted price for existing pay TV subscribers, so that the service becomes additive for them, opening up the 70 million non-HBO subscribers ‘ though pay TV providers may experience some cord shaving.

Time Warner seems to have three options:
Launch an OTT service that is targeted to cord cutters only, while pay TV subscribers continue to enjoy their Netflix subscriptions
Launch an OTT service that can be enjoyed by any and all of the 80 million non-HBO subscribers, and compete directly with Netflix
Stay tied to the pay TV ecosystem, and watch Netflix continue to grow its subscriber base both internationally and at home, and watch Netflix become more aggressive in securing the award-winning, high profile original series that HBO used to enjoy all to itself.