All the vapor emerging from the connected TV arena suggests that 2012 will be the year it really heats up, as the big beasts line up for battle. We can expect major announcements in the TV landscape from Apple and Microsoft, while Samsung, the leading force from the CE arena, will ramp up its strategy now aligned with Google TV, and set top box makers such as Pace will also be making significant plays. We think that an interesting lesson will have emerged in 12 months time if not sooner, which is that success in connected TV will depend on partnerships and cannot be obtained by boxes or packages on their own, no matter how sexy. In any case large screen TVs can never have that consumer chic Apple has attained with its iPhones, iPads and even Mac PCs, and will always be largely utilitarian products for consuming content. The prediction that Apple’s connected TV will be devoured by consumers like the iPad just because it has Apple iOS, an iMac screen, and access to an app store backed by the Apple name, could well be wide of the mark.
Of course Apple has long realized that a delivery ecosystem must be in place before a key product is launched, as was the case for the iPhone and iPad. Indeed this is presumably why the Apple TV has been a long time coming, waiting for the ecosystem to be completed. But this has always been a highly secretive project designed to shut out competitors and leave Apple in sole control, and there is every sign that the same line is being taken with TV. It MAY work this time, leveraging off its brand values and links to the other devices, but we’re not convinced.
Either Apple’s antagonistic strategy succeeds beyond its wildest dreams in taking over the living room ‘en masse’ from the established pay TV operators, or it will fail. The iPad has been more of a friend than a foe for pay TV operators by encouraging consumption of existing subscription content around the home primarily, Apple TV will be aimed at the living room itself, competing with Samsung and other emerging connected TV providers as well as with entrenched operators.
Steve Jobs was famously said to have cracked the riddle of connected TV before he died, which is rather like the story of the Italian mathematician Fermat who claimed to have solved the theorem named after him, Fermat’s Last Theorem, but never published the proof. In the event the world had to wait almost another four centuries for a solution, and while the connected TV conundrum should be resolved much more quickly, it may be beyond any single company. Apple’s solution looks like being built around integrated search and intuitive remote control via gesture and voice recognition. If so it will be doing little more than applying to TV what Microsoft has already done with its Xbox games console and associated Kinect motion sensing and voice recognition software.
Let’s remember that Apple has rarely been first to market with anything, with its genius lying in design, product engineering, and marketing rather than innovation. Nokia can attest to that, having failed for several years to gain traction among major mobile operators with its smartphones, only for Apple to step in with a device no more advanced than its own, the iPhone. And Microsoft could claim to have invented the tablet in 2003 seven years before iPads took the world by storm, with its product Windows XP TabletPC based on hardware from Compaq, since swallowed up by Hewlett Packard. This had a form factor similar to the iPad, but was of course inferior in performance or display capability, lacking the near instant bootability, as well as the ‘lovability’. Since then Microsoft has singularly failed to make any inroads in the tablet arena partly through lack of conviction and failure of the operating platform to deliver the robustness and fast switch on we know now is required of a tablet.
But it looks like being a different story when it comes to connected TV, where we think Microsoft has played a much stronger hand all along and is well perched to give Apple, Google, Samsung and others a very good run for their money. One key difference is the strategy, in that Microsoft is aligned with rather than against the pay TV industry, actually helping operators withstand the onslaught from emerging players. Microsoft sees connected TV as a positive disruptive force that pay TV operators should embrace by getting off their backsides and deploying TV Anywhere to extend their reach and defend against cord cutting, while actually attracting new subscribers for OTT-only subscription packages.
This partly reflects Microsoft’s background as an early entrant to the TV arena after seeing IPTV as an opportunity to get into the pay TV game, with its Mediaroom software, providing the functions such as video recording, time shifting and search needed for interactive broadcast services. At first this was an unwelcome disruption for entrenched satellite and cable operators, since it supported emerging IPTV players, but the Mediaroom portfolio has come to be deployed by some of these as well, to extend their services to IP platforms.
Since Mediaroom emerged from the previous Microsoft IPTV Edition in the mid noughties, its connected TV strategy has developed a second pole with the Xbox games console, which has become a serious contender in connected TV in its own right. This may not quite have been Microsoft’s original intention, but now Xbox has been in effect united with Mediaroom in its TV strategy, acting as a catalyst to ignite relevant development and acquisitions. For example Microsoft has just acquired California-based video discovery specialist VideoSurf, initially for integration of its software into the XBox 360 and XBox Live platform. Other key components on the back of Xbox are the Bing search engine, and Kinect for the remote interaction and control via gesture and voice. Skype as well could turn out to be a significant acquisition in the longer run by enabling the TV to participate in Telepresence.
The upshot is that Microsoft now has a much more convincing TV ecosystem than its emerging competitors including Apple, and this is being reflected in partnerships with key operators, such as cable company Comcast, and Verizon for its FiOS IPTV service. The latter has just announced it is making some of its live FiOS TV channels available over the Xbox 360, allowing users to interact with their TVs using the voice and gesture commands supported by Kinect. The deal requires customers to subscribe to Verizon’s FiOS TV and high-speed Internet services as well as to the Xbox Live Gold. Verizon is also making an app for the Xbox console available for download this month (December).
Kinect was cited by Verizon as a key component whose main attraction is use of image based 3D reconstruction combined with acoustic source localization. The latter allows hands free party chat over the Xbox live service, while the whole package enables hands free control over the console. Transferring this to TV may not be as trivial as it sounds, which unlike the games environment is a lean back experience. Indeed the thrust with Xbox has been to get people off their couches and engaged more with the game. For TV though it is important that gesture control is kept in its place so that channels are not changed for example when people raise a hand in anger at what they have just seen or heard on the box.
Samsung is grappling with this issue too, although focused purely on the connected TV side. Lacking some of Microsoft’s Xbox features such as the gesture control and perhaps search capabilities, Samsung has been scratching around for suitable partners to solve the connected TV conundrum. The company has been dallying with Google for some time but was unwilling to commit to the first version of Google TV. However having had some influence over the generally well received Google 2.0 announced last month, Samsung has regained its former enthusiasm for the product, and plans to introduce a box dedicated to Google TV in 2012. The change of heart has not come in time for this product to be ready for the Consumer Electronics Show in January 2011, so it will be launched later in the year.
The key steps for Samsung in Google TV 2.0 were faster web page loading, replacement of the ugly text menus and complex user interface with smart icons, and above all being driven by Android 3.1. This clears the path for support of Android apps, compared with the motley assortment of apps currently available for Google TV. Much better You Tube access, facilitated by Google with its own app, was also significant. The Samsung endorsement is equally significantly for Google itself, coming just a couple of weeks after the announcement by Logitech that its involvement with Google TV as launch partner had been a $100 million disaster.
Of course the other big dimension is content, which will be the crux of the matter for all three big players we have been discussing. This could be the real reason Samsung has now got into bed with Google after flirting for a year. Google has been beefing up YouTube through content deals with media companies such as News Corp and RTL Group, which is Europe’s largest TV and production company. But more importantly will be the results of negotiations between Google and major US networks such as ABC, NBC and Fox, as well as their OTT joint venture Hulu, which last year blocked their programming from being viewable on Google TV. Google has been wooing these networks since, although it remains to be seen whether it can deliver a business model that would make it worth their while to participate in its connected TV strategy. The attitude of the studios is also crucial, with YouTube providing movies from Warner Bros, Sony and Universal through its rental service.
This brings us back to Apple, which also provides movie rental via the iTunes store. The question though is the extent to which Apple can deliver the full range of content needed to challenge for control of the living room. Without the charm and persuasive powers of Jobs it may not be so successful in lining up all the relevant deals. On the other hand we should not underestimate the power of the brand and of the Apple loyalists, which together saved the company from extinction around a decade ago at a time when its products alone were barely worth fighting for.
The future of the connected TV itself is assured, for over time all broadcast services will be interactive and delivered over IP. The question is the extent to which it disrupts the existing ecosystem, and which of the emerging contenders gains most. Prospects for Microsoft are much brighter than they were two years ago, and it has the success of Xbox more than Mediaroom to thank for that.