The formation by Nokia and Siemens in 2006 of Nokia Siemens Networks (NSN), their 50-50 joint venture for telecoms infrastructure, was supposed to herald a golden age of fixed/mobile convergence and open up a fertile seam of profitability. In the event it has yet to turn in a profit, and has now launched a major restructuring exercise in a desperate attempt to reach a state where it can finally caste its baby adrift via an IPO (Initial Public Offering) sometime around 2013.
This restructuring will involve a 23% 17,000 reduction in the workforce, and withdrawal from fixed line infrastructure to focus on mobile broadband alongside professional services, which is where the company believes its best prospects for growth and profitability will be over the next decade. Industry analysts have said for some time that the company’s only hope of IPO lay in such a restructuring, but nonetheless it delivers a bolt through the fixed line and also IPTV field since NSN is currently the world’s second largest overall telecoms infrastructure vendor after Ericsson, with around 12 billion Euros ($16 billion) revenue in 2010.
In fact NSN may have been preparing for this move for some time, having spent $975 million in April 2011 acquiring the wireless network infrastructure assets of Motorola Solutions, including GSM, CDMA, WCDMA, WiMAX and LTE products. The aim was to strengthen NSN’s position in the lucrative and fast growing US mobile broadband market, although the move has yet to result in a major contract win.
NSN’s margins in fixed line infrastructure had been subject to increasing squeeze, partly from Ericsson with its even greater economies of scale, but most of all from Chinese network infrastructure manufacturers, in particular Huawei and ZTE, which have recently smelt blood and intensified their battle for global market share. At first Siemens and Nokia hoped they could survive by disinvestment, selling some of their stake in NSN to private equity groups such as Kohlberg Kravis Roberts in the US, but after these backed out in mid-2011, restructuring became inevitable as the prospect of making profits from the fixed line business evaporated.
This persuaded the two parent companies to take action, even though it will cost them money up front in $675 million initial restructuring costs. But the companies anticipate recouping this via annual savings of $1.35 billion kicking in by 2013 through a combination of reduced staff salaries and by having closed some operational centers. NSN’s current 73,000 employees are mostly distributed between eight centers including Espoo in Finland, Munich in Germany, Wroc’aw in Poland, Delhi, Hyderabad and Bangalore in India, Guangdong in China, and Lisbon in Portugal.
It is worth bearing in mind that the initial formation of NSN in 2006 was itself a restructuring exercise, in that case involving cuts on the mobile as well as the fixed side, leading to a total of around 9000 job losses staged over the following three years. The latest cuts are coming therefore shortly after the dust had settled over the previous round.
Meanwhile the present restructuring begs some questions for NSN’s IPTV strategy, given the increased prominence given to this sector by NSN, with some significant customers such as Belgacom in Belgium and KPN in the Netherlands, as well as various local services in the US. These successes was founded in large part, certainly at Belgacom, on NSN’s strengths in home networking, which was set out as a major focus at the outset in 2006. Belgacom was quick to implement the NSN Home Entertainment Solution, and credited that as one reason for achieving increased ARPU.
At the same time NSN was becoming a force in the burgeoning market for smart networks of various kinds, for example in the home with use of handsets for controlling lighting and heating as well as the TV. Some of these activities will dovetail with the new focus on mobile broadband, but others are very much fixed line, such as a smart grid initiative to help electricity distribution agencies ensure that power generated by renewable sources such as solar panels and wind turbines can be fed into the system efficiently at times of excess, as well as minimizing power dissipation and consumption.
NSN will have to reassure its various customers in all of these sectors depending on fixed line infrastructure that they will not be cast adrift as a result of this restructuring, assuming this is the intention.