Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

15 May 2014

AT&T’s hand forced over DirecTV, in shadow of Comcast TWC merge

The Wall Street Journal and other US newspapers are saying that AT&T is about to buy DirecTV, in a $50 billion deal. We think that this deal is feasible and that it would serve AT&T well, and at the same time shut out some great potential deals for Dish Network in the US, and none of this would represent a regulatory problem.

It would also fill John Malone’s treasure chest, and allow him to go back to Time Warner Cable and try to unseat its Comcast merger, that we believe will be blocked anyway by the Justice Department.

John Malone has many interests, most of them held through Liberty Media such as 48% of DirecTV and control of the Atlanta Braves Baseball team, the spin out of Starz and Encore movie channels, and other assets including control of the Sirius XM Satellite Radio, Charter and indirectly (i.e. not through shares in Liberty Media) Liberty Global.

That means he has his hands on the largest cable operator outside of the US, the largest DTH player in the world, and one of the leading US cable operators, which he has declared he wants to parley that ownership into a major rival for Comcast.

In 2001 Comcast bought AT&T Broadband, the cable remnants of TCI, a company built up by John Malone, over a 30 years period. It was that move which made Comcast the largest cable company in the US/world with over 21 million customers, a figure it added to with further acquisitions, until it reached some 24 million homes.

In other words Comcast is 50% made up of assets that Malone wishes he still had, and which he wants back, and a big chunk of that $50 billion, would help him plan how best to go about it.

The reason we think this deal can be done without regulatory scrutiny is that AT&T has very few satellite TV customers and those it retains come from relationships with Dish Networks and DirecTV, as a reseller. It has only 5 million pay TV homes in its own right via its IPTV U-Verse operation. So this is not much of a concentration of pay TV ‘ perhaps 20.3 million DTH subs, plus 5 million IPTV would make 25.3 million, a figure that Comcast has been close to in the past. However this would not bring voice, mobile or broadband control in such a merger, as DirecTV has none of those. To turn down this merger would be to automatically prevent the Comcast deal with Time Warner Cable.

We must assume that these talks are in fact a reaction to that merger, and that if Comcast was NOT merging with Time Warner these talks would also not be happening. So if the Comcast merger is off, perhaps this deal too will be off. But it doesn’t have to be.

AT&T doesn’t like the idea of competing with a merged Dish and DirecTV, which would have over 30 million pay TV homes captive and the spectrum that Dish has for build out in LTE Advanced. If that spectrum ever got built out then a quad play could emerge to challenge AT&T’s and Verizon’s cellular supremacy. Dish and DirecTV would not normally consider a merger, but again, if Comcast gets it hands on Time Warner Cable, it would feel compelled to try to work out the details of a merger. AT&T figures it can nip that deal in the bud by buying DirecTV for itself.

Hence we see the deal as logical and do-able and it would keep AT&T safe. However it would also put enough cash into Malone’s hands that if the Comcast merger is blocked, but this deal goes through, then he could roll-up more and more cable assets and create a US cable monster the size of Comcast. Which is what, deep down, Malone wants.

If AT&T did buy DirecTV, it would be interesting to see if the deal would include the Latin America operations which are still growing rapidly, right across the continent. These might be tough for AT&T management to run and would likely be sold off, or left in Malone’s hands and already represent 12 million homes each paying around $49 a month for subscriptions.