Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

15 May 2014

Sky Europe may also stalk Spanish Digital+ DTH player

We said last week that the offer, accepted so readily, made by Telefonica to buy the 56% of Spain’s Prisa pay TV operations, that it doesn’t own, is likely to run into regulatory trouble sooner or later, and so when an alternative bid emerges, it makes sense that this is where ownership may end up.

This week another bid was reported in the offing from 22% shareholder Italian commercial broadcaster, Mediaset, still controlled by the disgraced ex-Italian Prime Minister, Silvio Berlusconi and his family. However it is now run by CEO Giuliano Adreani.

Bloomberg, among others, reported merely that Mediaset was ‘thinking’ about a bid. Mediaset is no stranger to these types of deals, and while Berlusconi may love to end up owning this asset, we think such a deal is unlikely. Berlusconi is legally confined to Italy and is doing community service in an old folks home, while trying to appeal a number of personal court cases against him and also continue to fight for his political life.

The Spanish Prisa operations are a classic DTH platform called Digital+ plus the Canal+ content assets in Spain. For our money the company that might best run a service like that is 21st Century Fox, the owner of the Sky franchises in Italy, Germany and the UK. In the UK it only holds 39% of BSkyB, despite attempting to buy the remainder of the company in 2011, a deal that was scotched at the time by political intervention after News Corp (as 21st was then) was embroiled in a debate about the illegal interception of mobile phone messages, to break news stories for its newspapers.

Today the news side of the business has been separated from the TV operations, which have become 21st Century Fox (it owns 20th Century Fox and Fox TV in the US). However both are controlled by chairman Rupert Murdoch, and there are concerns that he still has aims to buy more ownership of BSkyB. One reason for this is to lay hands on the free cash flow generated by BSkyB, of around £1 billion each year.

In Italy Mediaset and Sky Italia hate one another and are fiercely competitive, and Sky has perhaps fared the recession there in rather better shape than Mediaset, which relies on both payments for its DTT pay TV system as well as advertising sales. Sky is built mostly around subscriptions, but also owns content, and sells advertising.

So where Mediaset buys, Sky would try to buy, and while conservative UK investors who hold shares in BSkyB, would never want to have assets in two weak economies like Italy and Spain, Murdoch would not be phased by it.

We think it is likely that despite the 22% shareholding of Mediaset that Murdoch or one of his operations will sniff around this deal, given that the asking price is just €725 million, BSkyB could afford it in cash without flinching. Bring Murdoch’s know-how to that operation and it would likely improve immensely. But as we say BSkyB is only held 39% by Murdoch’s company and the UK investors would veto any such action. Instead we would expect 21st Century to enter the bidding via its 100% ownership in Sky Italia or through Sky Deutschland, in which Murdoch has a 57% stake with the rest publicly traded in Germany or directly.

The outcome is likely to be a sale one way or another, of the leading Spanish pay TV operator to interests outside the country. Already across Europe there are multiple attempts to consolidate pay TV, with Vodafone buying cable companies in Germany and Spain, while Liberty Global has acquired two cable companies in Germany over the past few years, Virgin in the UK and is attempting to buy Ziggo in the Netherlands, another deal which will get mired down in anti-trust.

There is the dim possibility that other Spanish interests will emerge, who realize that pay TV is pretty recession proof, and a better investment than virtually any other business in Spain ‘ but such a team could partner either Mediaset or Sky, but not Telefonica, so that would not put a change of control out of the picture.

Al Jazzera was another company that local interests thought would bid, but no such bid has yet emerged.

But right now Murdoch is already mid-way through a complex move to merge BSkyB in the UK, with Sky Deutschland and Sky Italia, and adding the purchase of Digital+ might be one step too far. The real rationale for that Murdoch deal is to accumulate more shareholding in BSkyB through the back door ‘ if BSkyB buys companies that he owns, and swaps the shareholding in one for shares in the parent BSkyB and adds that to his 39%, once again he will be forced by takeover law to bid for the whole thing, and perhaps the political motivation is no longer there to prevent this.

His rationale is clear ‘ BSkyB is now dominant, but in 2006/7 it was touch and go how well it would do. Murdoch can repeat this trick in Germany and Italy and the UK shareholders can benefit from this. In the meantime he takes over BSkyB by the back door. Ofcom, the UK regulator, has more or less said that will happen ‘over its dead body’ but it may not have the power to prevent this deal, as Ofcom has more than once been sidelined by the Competition Commission, which has come down in Murdoch’s favor, and which would police such a deal.

Here is the key point ‘ he can do all that or not, while the parent company separately acquires Prisa’s Spanish pay TV operations directly, something he can later merge into Sky Europe, when it is performing better financially. While there is a long way to go in this deal, we would not bet against this kind of scenario or any other surprise entry, such as one form private equity or from other European parties.