The 2014 World Cup is not the first major global sporting event to go down to the wire for facilities and infrastructure creation. But it is the first to do so in an age of high reliance on telecoms infrastructure for distribution of live TV pictures and this is concerning broadcasters amid continuing news of major delays to a number of the main stadia for the event in Brazil.
This is in a country renowned for the most prolific growth in pay TV consumption, reaching 18 million subscribers at the end of 2013, compared with 16.2 million a year earlier and 12.8 million in December 2011. This is admittedly from a low base, with penetration of 32% still quite low and only half that of neighboring Argentina. But it has come with high ARPU almost 10 times greater than in the two most populous BRIC countries of China and India. This factor has spawned a healthy pirate TV sector heavily undercutting legitimate operators, that has also been stimulated by overall growth in TV consumption, and this has also been brought to the surface by the impending world cup.
An event like a World Cup generates a spike in piracy and was to some extent responsible for the formation of Alianza (The Alianza contra Pirater’a de Televisi’n Paga) at the start of 2013, formed by pay TV operators DirecTV, Telefonica, Sky Brasil, Newco, Produtora de Comunica”o Ltda, VTR, Claro HDTV, Claro Per’, Claro Ecuador, Claro Colombia, Claro Chile and Claro Brasil, as well as the networks Discovery, ESPN, Fox, Globosat, HBO, Telecine, Televisa, Turner and Win Sports.
Alianza has chalked up some successes, but has yet to make a significant dent in piracy across Latin America as a whole, at least according to Rob Van Nunen, Senior Director of Special Projects at content security specialist Irdeto. He suggested recently that the extent of piracy threatened to make pay TV there an unsustainable business.
While he welcomed the formation of Alianza, Van Nunen suggested that the growth in online video consumption was amplifying the piracy threat through the avenue of content redistribution, which he said had become the single biggest source of piracy in Latin America. This also includes User Generated Content, which surfaced for the first time as an issue for the World Cup at the last 2010 tournament in South Africa. At that event there were 18,227 cases of digital piracy of which 90% or 16,426 were live UGC streams, according to the World Intellectual Property Organization. The number is likely to be a lot higher this time with many of the UGC streams consumed in Brazil.
Until recently cable TV piracy has been the biggest source of pay TV content theft in Brazil, as in most of Latin America. This has been referred to as GatoNet, literally translating as ‘CatNet’, which is the vernacular for illegal wiring. This is rather a misnomer since GatoNet is mostly not that small time but actually includes some reasonably sized operations making over $1 million a year. In total almost one million homes access cable TV illegally in the country, amounting to $100 million loss of revenue for operators, according to the Brazilian Association of Paid TV (ABTA).
Cable theft is not the major headache relating to the world cup for broadcasters, with content redistribution looming larger. For Brazil as a whole there is even more concern not over TV piracy but the potential impact that cyber-attacks could have on the overall communications infrastructure, on which TV contribution and distribution increasingly rely.
There were a number of cyber-attacks at the 2013 Confederation Cup in Brazil, which served as a rehearsal for the World Cup this year. This coincided with widespread riots involving people protesting against the expense of the World Cup and a number of notorious hackers have exploited the malcontent to ramp up activities in the country this year. Reuters recently ran an article claiming that an international hacker network known as Anonymous had confirmed it would launch attacks against official websites and those of companies sponsoring the Cup, including online distribution. To date the country’s hacking community has been considerably more sophisticated and better organized than its cyber defense community, although that is changing.
For international broadcasters and the outside world, there is more concern over whether there will be interruptions to live TV coverage as a result of incompetence and unfinished infrastructure, rather than hacking. While there are concerns over capacity of the country’s core infrastructure, which is still relatively immature and sparse compared with the leading industrialized nations, the main issues surround the networking and transmission facilities in and around the stadia, which cannot be installed until the building fabric is complete.
Several stadia have been behind schedule, with particular concern over the Arena da Baixada in the southern city of Curitiba and the Arena das Dunas in Rio Grande do Norte, even though the latter supposedly opened on 26 January. There were also delays at the Corinthians Arena in Sao Paulo following the collapse of a crane while hoisting massive metal support girders into position, killing three workers and also destroying part of the stand.
This all led to Jerome Valcke, the general secretary at World Cup organizer Fifa, to lay the boot in once again, having said last year that project managers in Brazil needed “a kick up the backside,” when construction timetables slipped again, requiring an extension beyond the original December 2013 deadline. As a result broadcasters are sharing some of Fifa’s stress.