Sweden’s decision this week to reallocate the 700 MHz spectrum band from broadcasting to mobile services from 2017 is the latest in a litany of setbacks for digital terrestrial TV (DTT) in Europe, which suggests that the tide has turned against it on that continent. This has been happening for two years, evidenced by an overall drop of 13% in number of subscriptions to pay DTT services in 2013 according to figures from IHS, the first fall for some years. In the same year plans for pay DTT services in Spain and Portugal were dropped, while existing services have ceased in Italy and France. In several smaller European countries the development of a financially successful model for pay DTT is proving problematic.
Meanwhile free DTT has also fared badly in some countries, notably Germany with the decision early in 2013 by broadcaster RTL to pull out of DTT after 2015. We should point out that the situation varies greatly between European countries, with DTT never having gained much ground in Germany, where only 11% of households access it from their primary TVs. But in other countries public commitment to DTT remains strong, including neighboring German speaking Austria. Even in Germany two other broadcasters ARD and ZDF in September 2013 announced plans to transition their DTT platform to the second generation DVB-T2 standard between 2017 and 2020. Pay DTT meanwhile has become established and is doing quite well in various smaller states such as Estonia, Malta, Lithuania, Macedonia and Albania.
Overall, terrestrial TV is the preferred medium for receiving broadcasts in about 50% of households in Europe, with higher penetration rates in the UK, France, Italy and Spain. The reason for pessimism in the DTT camp springs from larger global forces compounded by trends in TV viewing, which have contributed significantly to the Swedish decision, as they did to RTL’s last year.
The key point is that DTT has much higher penetration among secondary rather than primary TVs, largely because relatively few households yet distribute video over home networks or even extension leads. Therefore while many homes have switched to pay TV services over satellite, cable and more recently IPTV, they have continued to rely on DTT for second or third TVs in bedrooms or kitchens for example. To some extent this factor has kept DTT afloat in some regions and also maintained public resistance against analog switch off. But there is now a rapid switch taking place from traditional TVs to connected devices, including PCs and smartphones but especially tablets, for secondary viewing and that trend will continue. Therefore the argument for preserving DTT just to serve secondary viewing in the home will diminish.
There has also been a counter argument that DTT itself is well suited to serve mobile devices both inside and outside the home through the DVB-T2 Lite variant for example, but in the long run that need will be served by mobile broadcast via the DVB-T2 Lite standard, combined with Wi-Fi as hotspots continue to proliferate.
Then there are the wider forces working against DTT. These spring from the fact the world is split into three regulatory zones by the ITU (International Telecommunications Union) for allocation of radio spectrum. Region one includes Europe, Middle East, Africa and Russia, plus all the surrounding states such as Ukraine that used to be in the old Soviet Union, plus Mongolia. Region 2 comprises all the Americas plus the Eastern Pacific, while Region 3 is China, India and the Far East as well as Australasia including all the western Pacific islands.
These regions have taken different approaches to spectrum allocation but there has been mounting pressure to align them and in so doing hand over the 700 MHz band in the range 698 MHz to 806 MHz, to mobile services. This has been called the second digital dividend, although for DTT it is the second forfeit since spectrum is lost rather than gained. The first dividend was awarded by the WRC-07 (World Radio Conference 2007) with the handover of the 790-862 MHz band to mobile services, taking advantage of spectrum liberated as a result of analog to digital switchover. The argument was that although spectrum was lost for DTT broadcasting, total capacity remained the same, while satisfying the insatiable appetite of the much faster growing mobile sector.
Broadcasters accepted this on the tacit understanding that it would be as far as spectrum reallocation went and that they would retain all the bandwidth they had left in the range 470 MHz to 790 MHz. During this hiatus in the spectrum wars, second generation DVB-T2 DTT services started to be introduced in Europe from about 2009, increasing capacity by at least 30% and up to 60% in some cases as a result of various technical advances such as improved Forward Error Correction (FEC) and greater scope for statistical multiplexing. A further doubling in capacity will be achieved by moving from MPEG-2 encoding, which predominated for first generation DVB-T, to H.264/MPEG-4, which is always used over DVB-T2. Eventual deployment of HEVC (High Efficiency Video Coding), which was ratified early 2013, will potentially double this again.
Many European broadcasters hoped and expected these improvements would keep DTT in the game, given its importance in reaching their audiences, and enabling them to meet expectations for increased numbers of channels at ever higher definitions, leading towards ‘full HD’ at 1080p and ultimately UHD. But then a bombshell came at the WRC12 conference in February 2012, the first one after WRC07. The European contingent of the ITU Region 1 was ambushed by a number of African and one or two Middle Eastern countries, which called for a second digital dividend to be awarded or seized, depending on your point of view.
The argument was based on convergence with ITU Regions 2 and 3, which as a result of legacy had decided to award the 700 MHz band from 698 MHz to 806 MHz as the first digital dividend rather than the 790-862 MHz band as Region 1 had done. This incidentally helped the US leap ahead with LTE services following auctions in 2008, having lagged behind Europe in 2G and 3G.
From this point on economic and scale factors weighed in, aided by the 3GPP (3rd Generation Partnership Project), which sets and promotes cellular standards including LTE. 3GPP has effectively claimed the 700 MHz band as its own, building on work done by the Asia-Pacific Telecommunity (APT) in configuring that band for LTE. Now Latin America is part of Region 2 for spectrum allocation, but has converged towards Asia for DTT and has adopted this APT plan for 700 MHz along with the APAC region. This has created strong momentum behind migration of 700 MHz to mobile, opening the door to global spectrum harmonization for LTE systems and for greater economies of scale in both devices and network infrastructure.
This emboldened the African countries to make their move at WRC12, also motivated by the fact there was little deployment of DTT there anyway and that mobile broadband infrastructure alongside satellite represented the best avenue for TV distribution. However this was strongly resisted by European broadcasters led by the EBU (European Broadcasting Union), leading to an uneasy compromise whereby mobile services would coexist with DTT on a ‘co-primary’ basis, leaving individual countries to decide how to use that spectrum. WRC has agreed that this new allocation will not take effect until after its next World Radiocommunication Conference in 2015, when the technical and regulatory conditions will be defined.
Since then some countries have voted with their feet and pre-empted the WRC 2015 conference by deciding to give up on the 700 MHz spectrum now. There is growing consensus in Europe that this band is lost to broadcasting, with Digital Europe, the Brussels based group representing the IT and digital industry as a whole, arguing that DVB-T2 yields a sufficient capacity improvement to allow the second digital dividend to be paid to the mobile sector. Digital Europe has pointed out that DVB-T2 makes it possible to deploy large Single Frequency Networks (SFNs) that enable spectrum to be reused more efficiently between adjacent DTT cells. Digital Europe also considers that HEVC changes the game.
This is not of course how the EBU sees it, since DVB-T2 was supposed to be about delivering more high resolution channels rather than coping with less spectrum. But even the EBU appears now to have given up the ghost over the 700 MHz band, since its main complaint over the Swedish move appears to be over its haste in re-allocating the 700 MHz spectrum band away from broadcasting from 2017. The EBU said such a fast switch-over will jeopardize the integrity of TV services in Sweden, given that around 2.8 million households currently rely on digital terrestrial TV.
The EBU argued that the shift would require immediate DVB-T2 deployment with a substantial financial investment by the broadcast industry and will disrupt reception for many Swedes without compatible decoders. The EBU’s technology and innovation director Simon Fell said digital terrestrial TV cannot move out of the 700 MHz band in Sweden within the government’s proposed time frame without substantial disruption to consumers. A smooth transition involves detailed planning and engagement with all sectors of the television industry.
The EBU is also concerned that this is the thin end of the wedge and that Sweden will follow by taking further spectrum away from broadcasting after that next WRC15 conference. Meanwhile back in the UK, which remains a haven for DTT despite the roaring success of BSkyB in pay TV over satellite, Digital UK, which supports Freeview channels and viewers, has come out fighting by making the economic case for DTT. The group argues in a report published January 2014 that the UK’s Freeview DTT platform returns almost £80 billion ($130 million) to the country’s economy, more than previously estimated, and delivers more value per unit of spectrum than mobile broadband. This not-for-profit organization claims the research ‘challenges the view that mobile broadband delivers more value from airwaves than television’ and urges policy makers in the UK and Europe to reconsider plans to free up more spectrum for the mobile sector.
The report, which was commissioned by Digital UK and carried out by media and telecoms consultancy Communications Chambers, claimed that DTT supports 15,000 jobs in broadcasting and independent production in the UK. In terms of value, the report claims that the average value per MHz of spectrum for DTT is 50% higher than for mobile data, and that mobile ‘already has a far greater allocation of spectrum than DTT.’
Interestingly Digital UK pointed out that the increasing availability of free Wi-Fi meant cellular networks only carry 18% of mobile device traffic (no other source agrees it is this low). But Digital UK’s arguments are likely to be swept away by the greater global tide towards mobile, which is likely to pin DTT back to the margins since it will lack the capacity to deliver a full bouquet of UHD services. Its main hope may be as part of hybrid services in conjunction with broadband, within which it would deliver core channels.