Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

6 March 2014

Cellular desperation in France drives not one, but two SFR offers

While there is merger mania among both fixed and cellular operators around the world for very positive reasons (in the US, Germany, the Netherlands and elsewhere), in France, the disruption caused by two years of cellular market share grabbing by Iliad’s Free, is leading to a major rethink of how to merely survive.

It was the emergence of the fourth operator in Free that has caused price upheaval, with the widespread offload of 70% plus of cellular traffic to WiFi, allowing prices as low as €2 a month for cellular packages. This happened just as Vivendi bought the 45% of SFR that it did not own from Vodafone, and immediately the French conglomerate had a conundrum on its hands, of whether to keep or get rid of SFR.

Officially SFR is about to be offloaded to existing Vivendi shareholders via a simple share allocation, segregating the Vivendi share price from the disruption in French mobile markets. But now bidding is heating up, with the rumored intervention offer from Numericable’s private equity owner Altice finally materializing (we have mentioned it before), and a counter offer emerging from third placed cellular player Bouygues Telecom, a move that would take France back to having just three cellular operators, after the shift up to four, two years ago.

Free has claimed 7 million customers in those intervening years, mostly from Bouygues and SFR, with France Telecom’s Orange acting as its roaming partner, as it conducted an extremely original build out strategy. Free built just 2,700 base stations, where other companies had needed ten times that number to cover France, instead relying on its own Homespot WiFi and Orange’s roaming contract, to keep customers on some kind of network. Orange’s roaming deal has brought it plenty of money it was a condition of the fourth license although it must be renewed in a few years.

When we said recently that the natural home for Numericable was right alongside SFR, what we meant was the Numericable was bound to want SFR after it went public. What we did NOT say was that nobody else would want it.

Vivendi said yesterday that it has now received two binding offers for controlling stakes in its SFR subsidiary but it has not revealed any of the terms and conditions, only their sources, Numericable’s parent Altice and Bouygues Telcom. French press reports suggest that the Altice offer values SFR higher, but offers to buy less, paying with debt, cash and shares in the venture, while the Bouygues deal values it somewhat lower, but offers more cash up front.

The statement from Vivendi says simply that the offers include financing commitments and the Vivendi’s Supervisory Board will now examine the offers and see what’s best for shareholders and employees.

Some reports say that the Bouygues offer includes $14.4 billion of cash, while the Altice deal is said to offer less cash. Both deals leave Vivendi with a substantial shareholding, the Bouygues offer is said to leave something close to 46%, the Altice deal more like 32%. We suspect that the offers are broadly similar in the amount of value that Vivendi ends up with, but it depends on whether it wants to continue to hold a minority stock in SFR, and of what size. Also the conditions imposed on what it can do with that stock and when, will change its view.

For Numericable this is a route towards the quad play, after a long and difficult modernization program. For Bouygues this is the creation of a more powerful, traditional rival to Orange, alongside the disruptor Free. Bouygues is a large conglomerate taking in construction, broadcasting and telecommunications interests, with revenues of the equivalent of $45 billion. Bouygues has promised that its merger plan requires no redundancies, by way of courting government approval.

Bouygues is said to claim that because it already has a mobile network, there would be both integration costs and savings from combining the two networks and that the combined cellular network would be larger than Orange, at least within France. Numericable already has an MVNO with Orange.