As BT’s Movio mobile TV service gets closer to launch, it becomes clearer and clearer that it has a very short lifetime, and is dealing in bit rates that will make it the joke of all mobile TV services around Europe.
While most DVB-H services around Europe, either have, or are shooting for between 5 MHz and 8MHz of dedicated spectrum, the BT Movio service is going to be restricted to using just 30% of the capacity on the Digital One national commercial DAB multiplex, which itself has just 1.5 MHz of spectrum. At the same time Movio plans to offer at least 5 TV channels instead of the 3 it has had on trial, and the net result is that the bit rate could be limited to around 64Kbps for each TV channel.
A survey of the trial service made a good impression with 1,000 trialists, with a large percentage saying they would pay for such a service, but now it will be reduced further in bit rate, and the screen image will be even less clear.
There are lots of trade offs in video, the codec can be made to be more or less efficient, and more and less lossy (throws more of the definition data away), or less frames can be produced per second or the overall screen density can be dropped. But the current unicast TV services offered on 3G telephones are already as good as the initial launch services that Movio is planning. By comparison a DVB-H TV channel will run in a quarter sized VGA screen using 320 by 240 pixels, at 24 or 30 frames a second. That takes around 400 Kbps, which is more than 6 times as dense as the Movio service will be at launch.
In April the Department for Culture, Media & Sport in the UK launched a public consultation for the idea of allowing the DAB multiplex used for non-audio services to rise from 20% to 30%. BT Movio will use the fully internet protocol carrier version of Digital Audio Broadcast called Enhanced Packet Mode, which means it can be sent from existing DAB transmitters with no alternation and the current DAB multiplex operates in 200 MHz Band III spectrum, which has great propagation characteristics, which means very few transmitters are needed to cover the UK.
By using this it gives BT Movio a cheap and very early UK launch, but the service will have little more than a year’s head start in the UK, before new spectrum in 1.4 GHz is released in a March 2007 auction, that could see the market flooded with much higher data rate competition.
Overnight the Movio service will either have to be upgraded, moved to new spectrum or consolidate back into fewer channels to increase its data rate. The regulator will be unable to offer more capacity through the existing DAB multiplex because it already houses other radio services.
This week one of the key technology partners in British Telecom’s Movio, The Technology Partnership, which supplied core technology for the trial said it would now license its technology to handset makers.
TTP produced receiver module designs and the EPG and other application software which will manage interactivity, and these initially sat on handsets using the Windows Mobile operating system from Microsoft partner HTC in Taiwan.
Now TTP will license the underlying software to new handset partners, which we would guess to include Samsung, and possibly LG Electronics, which have proved the most agnostic of handset makers on the subject of mobile TV technologies to date. Other no-brand white label manufacturers in China are also sure to be approached.