Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

7 June 2006

US Upfront caves into the concept of ‘Live’ TV viewers only

Just for the record, it is worth pointing out that the US broadcast TV networks lost the fight to base their advertising schedules on all TV programs watched by their viewers, including anyone watching a program on a DVR, where they are likely to skip ads.

The final adherent to billing for all viewers including those who time shift programs was ABC, which finally caved in this week to pressure from a united advertising front. The US Upfront is a once a year negotiation to pre-sell about $9 billion of broadcast TV’s advertising slots as they unveil their new seasons programming, sold at a small discount to usual prices.

ABC had no choice but to alter its hard-line position, when the other networks had already agreed to do business using live viewers ratings only.

Although it is being swept under the table as a mere detail in the Upfront negotiations, with all advertising journals continuing to be upbeat about how the negotiations can now get under way in earnest, this is a huge defeat and a continuing problem for all broadcast TV in the US, and soon in Europe and the Far East, as DVR usage spreads.

If 11% of the US TV market has a DVR, then there is a good chance that virtually all of them will be excluded from most TV viewing figures from now on, for at least half of the time. Nielsen Media, which monitors TV viewer activity, will still track these habits, but even if a DVR viewer delays viewing by just 15 minutes, the chances are that they are planning to race through the advertising, and view the program in 40% less time, one of the great benefits of DVRs.

So while prices may rise in the US Upfront by as much as 4%, this could mean that they are just charging 4% more per head that watches TV, and this figure will now drop overnight by as much as 6% for various parts of the prime time viewing, perhaps more, plus the effects of inflation. That could be a revenue fall of as much as 3% or 4%, which will shake out in the advertising numbers revealed next January in the year end reporting season.

For the broadcast networks there is no way back. They don’t control the DVR, are not part of selling it to the public and cannot share in the revenues gained from any DVR based advertising such as those being designed by TiVo.

TiVo has managed to get voluntary advertising to become effective and has experiments with still ads that feature during the process of fast forwarding.

Cable and satellite networks can at least fall back on this new type of advertising, and both DirecTV and Comcast have licensing relationships with TiVo for this type of technology. So they at least have a fall back position when the $6 billion cable Upfront is negotiated.

But for Broadcast this is a potential 4% or 5% now and a much bigger percentage erosion in the future. Many of the networks came prepared for this Upfront negotiation, offering web based new media advertising alongside their TV broadcast advertising, in the hope of finding some revenue growth. We won’t know how effective this has been until some definitive stories emerge from this Upfront

But going forwards the broadcast TV networks have a real problem. DVR penetration is expected to go to 47%, some 55 million US homes, by 2010, and if the same metric remains in use, then the entire US advertising industry is facing a massive transition out of broadcast TV, and many broadcast channels will go to the wall, while others will have to get used to not being quite so rich.

This move alone will shift billions of dollars towards advertising innovation in broadcast, but mostly to web TV style services.