Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

15 May 2014

Cablecos and the WiFi first telephony prospect

Cablecos’ recent and vocal interest in developing and expanding WiFi networks outside the home and across the country, along with the creation of the CableWiFi Alliance in 2012, has led many, including us, to speculate that Comcast or other cablecos could launch a quadplay service, along with a WiFi first mobile phone.

On a panel on Cable WiFi at last week’s NCTA conference, none of the cablecos’ executives were willing to say anything about future plans for their out-of-the-home WiFi networks, or about offering any kind of mobile service.
Leo Cloutier, SVP of corporate strategy and business development at Bright House Networks, did say this: ‘We’re all very aware that possibilities exist as we build out more WiFi. What you’re hearing from us is, none of that is a reality now. None of that’s something we’re doing now. We’re aware those possibilities exist,’ Cloutier added. ‘We’re building a useful WiFi network.’

‘WiFi first’ refers to devices and services that use WiFi as the primary network for data, voice and messaging. Cellular is used for these services only when its needed, to fill the gaps. Cablecos in the US have made very clear their interest in bolstering a mutually-beneficial WiFi hotspot network across the country, which could easily be used to introduce WiFi first services to subscribers.

‘WiFi first presents a potentially game changing competitive alternative to traditional mobile services offered today,’ said Carrie MacGillivray, VP of mobile research at IDC, in a recent Webinar on the subject. ‘MSOs have looked to provide wireless services, and short of developing their own networks, they’ve been required to create partnerships with mobile operators or MVNO relationships with a mobile operator. Being able to offer a WiFi first solution layered on top of an existing contract and customer relationship is a more appealing proposition.’

There are many potential uses for the CableWiFi network that we see. Cablecos could use the networks to:
‘ offer a mobile service to subscribers that could be cheaper than cellcos
‘ create what a ‘reverse MVNO’ revenue stream, in which the cablecos sell access to the WiFi networks to cellcos looking to offload
‘ Cellcos could even offer their own WiFi first phones.
‘ Partner with a third party WiFi first startup to take on the cellcos and challenge any potential telco quadplay offerings

Despite what Comcast’s FCC filing said, Tom Nagel, SVP of strategic initiatives at Comcast, told a panel at NCTA last week its WiFi networks won’t compete with cellcos. ‘It isn’t a cellular network. We’re building more of a capacity network than a coverage network,’ he said. ‘The WiFi network has the ability to deliver high tonnage in a specific location. We don’t see it as we’re trying to replace cellular, it may replace the next bit of cellular.’

Critically the ‘next bit of cellular’ is carrying video and the conundrum is building a network cheap enough to handle this heavy tonnage, at a time when the prices of voice services are also falling.

The question of capacity versus coverage is an important point. One look at the CableWiFi Alliance coverage map shows how little of the country is covered with these 250,000 WiFi hotspots. The map doesn’t stand up to any of the cellcos’ LTE coverage maps. Although it we add Homespots to the mix, it might be a different matter.

Competitive cellcos use national coverage maps in advertisements to differentiate themselves from one another, but nationwide coverage may not be as important to budget-conscious consumers.

Most phone calls are made at home, in the office, or in public places ‘ all areas that typically have WiFi. Estimates indicate a WiFi first phone will operate 70% on WiFi, and 30% on a cellular network. That’s what WiFi coverage can offer currently. That ratio will continue to move in favor of WiFi as both cablecos and cellcos expand their WiFi networks. The Wireless Broadband Alliance, for example, estimates WiFi access points will reach 5.8 million in the US by next year. It also estimates that nine out of 10 people in the US spend at least 19 hours per day within WiFi range.

There are two major caveats to cablecos offering a WiFi first phone:
It may not be be truly mobile, ie nomadic ‘ meaning the caller may have to stay in the same WiFi cell. There are many systems that allow for roaming from WiFi cell to WiFi cell, but not all systems do this, and the time it takes to move cells is less certain than in cellular.

Popular areas in big cities are covered, mid-sized and smaller cities and towns aren’t covered, some entire states are without coverage. Unless you count home WiFi being converted into Homespots.

The first point: WiFi doesn’t always work with things in motion, so callers who hope to keep their data charges light may need to make sure when they do make a call, they are in a WiFi cell and aren’t leaving the cell during the call. This issue is further complicated by the fact that seamless hand-off protocols which have been designed to work between cellular and WiFi are not widely available as yet.

Scratch Wireless, for example, will simply drop the call if the user moves out of the WiFi cell. (Scratch says that’s actually a good thing, because the consumer can decide if he or she wants to pay for the cellular call, instead of being charged automatically when the call hands over).

Republic Wireless, a virtual mobile operator that uses Sprint’s cellular network, has a proprietary hand-off technology, but it has to be baked into the device, in Republic’s case those are LG and Moto smartphones. It has refined the technology to help make the transition between WiFi and cellular more seamless by ‘anchoring’ the call in the cloud before handing it over to the cellular network.

On the second point, coverage is sorely lacking. Some states, such as Louisiana, don’t have even one single cable WiFi hotspot. While most of the large urban areas along the coasts are well covered, most of the middle of the country is without cable WiFi, excluding the big cities, such as Chicago, Illinois or Atlanta, Georgia. Even in the big cities, there are large swaths of areas without coverage. That means subscribers will need to make calls only when they are at home, at the office or in a specific WiFi destination.

Someone’s cellular network would then fill in these gaps: calls made while commuting, and in areas outside the WiFi cells.

There are currently two start-ups offering WiFi first phones. Scratch Wireless and Republic Wireless.

Scratch Wireless has been arguing heavily for cablecos to enter the WiFi first mobile space, most recently in a webinar presentation indicatively called ‘WiFi First: Empowering MSOs to Win the Mobile War.’

At NCTA, the cable WiFi panel moderator asked the panelists if any of them would partner with a startup like Scratch Wireless. The response from the cableco execs seemed skeptical.

‘You have to remember the network isn’t national, yet,’ Nagel said. ‘These companies tend to want a much bigger footprint. I think there are opportunities for us to develop relationships where their customers can use our networks ‘ those types of things. We’ll have to see.’

Brad Feldman, SVP of video product management at Cablevision, was a bit more blunt. ‘Those companies only exist because of our WiFi networks.’ Although that’s not really true, as there are many Free community WiFi hotspots not owned or backed by cable.

In the US, the perpetual dark horse Google is rumored to be looking into launching a mobile phone service in its Google Fiberhoods. Outside the US, cablecos and so-called virtual mobile operators are experimenting with WiFi first mobile phone services.

In France, the company Free Mobile launched in 2012 and its entry into the market made large waves. The profitability of the entire cellular sector in France was radically altered by a move from a single cellular entrant, which doesn’t even have a network, but has widespread WiFi. The service picked up 2 million subscribers overnight and now has 7 million.

In the Netherlands, cablecos Ziggo and UPC are experimenting with WiFi first telephony with voice apps. Both companies have launched free apps that enable users to send calls over WiFi. Comcast has a similar app service, called Voice To Go.

There are further hints that some US cablecos are seriously exploring a WiFi first service. Cablevision and TWC have filed patents and discussed in the past developing a hybrid WiFi and cellular mobile phone offering.