Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

15 May 2014

Harmonic and Cisco steer CCAP towards virtualization

The Converged Cable Access Platform (CCAP) driven originally by Comcast and Time Warner Cable (TWC) to enable IP migration for MSOs is becoming virtualized by pushing DOCSIS CMTS (cable modem termination system) and QAM closer to subscribers.

Harmonic is the latest to bow to this trend by releasing its NSG Exo, a cable edge device that supports DOCSIS 3.0 functionality out of the box with edge QAM support coming later in 2014. The launch came just two weeks after Cisco had demonstrated a new range of CCAP components aimed at virtualizing the DOCSIS CMTS part of the platform by distributing remote PHYs closer to the customer, connected to CCAP Cores that may be implemented in hardware or software and deployed in local data centers.

The aim, as with Harmonic’s NSG Pro, is to improve scalability by allowing bandwidth to be increased as required without continuing to consume more space and power in distributed hubs and headends. Meanwhile Arris, the other big cable infrastructure vendor, has revealed that virtualized CCAP is on its roadmap.

CCAP emerged around four years ago from two parallel, but separate, US projects, Converged Multiservice Access Platform (CMAP) led by Comcast, and Converged Edge Services Access Router (CESAR), headed by TWC. The operators soon decided it was futile to pursue two separate projects with the same end goal of developing a much denser architecture that as a result would save both space and power, by combining edge QAM and CMTS functions.

Clearly it was counterproductive having two separate initiatives aiming to set the cable industry on the road toward service convergence around a common IP data platform. The aim was to ease the path to IP migration, but rate of deployment was slower than expected as it turned out that CCAP involved a hefty upfront investment and considerable complexity. Even Comcast admitted after conducing trials with Cisco during 2013 that deploying CCAP involved a lot more than a simple box swap.

“Preparing for CCAP deployments is not a trivial matter,” said Jorge Salinger, Comcast VP of access architecture, just after the trials. Salinger admitted that the internal re-organization involved was considerable for an operation of Comcast’s scale, with training and reshuffling of engineers between the previously largely separate video and broadband departments.

It meant consolidation of monitoring and alarm systems, as well as support processes, given that Comcast had used different trouble ticket systems for data and video. The upshot is that CCAP had become almost an impediment to IP migration when it had been supposed to smooth the path.
Such issues prompted a rethink within CableLabs, as well as leading vendors and the MSOs themselves, with a switch towards distributed architectures, utilizing concepts that have emerged in the IT world, such as software-defined networking and network function virtualization, to enable the virtualizing of CCAP where functions are distributed.

One option is to distribute just the PHY, leaving the CMTS as a physical box in the headend. But this fails to satisfy the growing thirst for all-IP operation within the headend to enjoy the economies of scale available with commodity Ethernet and IP equipment, while also retaining the cost of maintaining centralized CMTS equipment. There is growing momentum therefore behind the idea of a full virtual CCAP solution, pushing the whole DOCSIS CCAP to the node, rather than just the PHY. The vendors have been scrambling to catch up with this trend.

However Harmonic at least believes there is still a place for dense centralized CCAP and that some operators will continue to deploy it, largely to support sparser consumer populations. The new distributed form of CCAP will then be promoted particularly for sites with multiple occupancy, such as businesses, hotels, college campuses, and apartment buildings. In these cases fiber will go to the building delivering pure IP with the RF infrastructure only starting there, delivering DOCSIS, MPEG video and other RF based services across the site.

The initial version of the NSG Exo is a one rack unit for indoor use only, with a hardened outdoor unit expected for launch later this year. A single NSG Exo can support 250 to 500 customers, and interestingly is suitable not just for MSOs but also Telcos terminating fiber to multi-dwelling units that then need to run services across in-building coax-based networks. This will be applicable quite widely in the US, but also in many European countries.