Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

5 January 2012

Canal Plus pulls out of 3D for now

The news that French pay TV operator Canal Plus is closing its 3D channel after only picking up 20,000 subscribers in its 18 months of operation can be interpreted in ways. For some, such as Oscar winning sound engineer Walter Murch most famous for his work on Apocalypse Now, it is confirmation that 3D TV in its current incarnation never can work and never will. But others suggest that the Canal Plus move merely signals lukewarm interest in Europe, pointing out that major US networks are persisting with 3D, examples being ESPN 3D, Discovery’s n3D, and DirecTV’s 3net.

So the question is which is it to be? The common ground between the extremes is recognition that 3D technology has some way to go before it will be suitable for general programming, that it must allow viewing without goggles, and without causing unpleasant symptoms such as headaches in a significant number of people. The divergence is over whether a 2D image can ever satisfactorily simulate the 3D world we actually live in. Murch believes not, while broadcasters, TV channels, and CE makers believe it can, driven partly by a need to find new sources of revenue beyond HD. Canal Plus in fact takes this view, with Ren’ Saal, its managing director, indicating that for now development and marketing efforts will be focused on HD, but that it will return to 3D when interest picks up, fuelled both by improvements in technology and availability of content.

Even some of the US networks are taking a somewhat similar line, and although ESPN for example has just spent $15.2 billion for the rights over the next eight years to the National Football league, it will not start shooting matches in 3D until 2014. This is because ESPN wants to shoot 3D as well as HD in full 1080p resolution, which even using MPEG4 encoding as it is doing will increase the bandwidth needed by pay TV operators to carry the programming.

Such delays are not welcome for the CE vendors desperate to sell 3D capable TV sets, and as a result they are actually subsidizing the high cost of producing 3D content, hoping to exploit this year’s London Olympics to stimulate sales. Panasonic is one that is sponsoring 3D TV production at the London games, having pledged to pay for 200 hours of live coverage from the Olympics. The hope is that interest in 3D at least for sports programming will be given a kick start after threatening to fizzle out.

But this still leaves unsettled the question of whether 3D in anything like its current form will ever become mainstream, and this could be well be determined in the laboratories of neuroscience rather than TV displays. This is where Murch is coming from, having cited various arguments for his case that 3D will never work. The most telling one is in essence that 3D TV and cinema displays work fundamentally differently from the way the human brain processes visual information, perfected over millions of years of evolution.

When viewing the actual 3D world we focus on a particular object and at the same time converge our two eyes on a given point. This generates two slightly offset images not just of that point but also background of the surrounding area in 3D depth. The brain processes these two separate offset images to create its 3D view of what we are seeing. When viewing 3D video on the other hand we focus on the screen, but then have to converge the eyes on a point at a different distance, depending on how the illusion of 3D was created. The image of the point we are converging the eyes on is blurred because the eyes are actually focusing on the screen, and so the brain has to recreate the 3D representation differently. The brain can cope, having evolved to compensate for imperfect eyesight perhaps, but at the cost of headaches, dizziness and nausea in some people. The Murch view is that these problems can never be resolved using a 2D screen to simulate a 3D image, and that we will have to wait for holographic projection and genuine 3D before we take to it. It is arguable even then whether people will still prefer to view in 2D a lot of the time, but that’s another question.

Meanwhile we believe that while Murch is fundamentally correct that current 3D presentation is flawed, this will not stop the CE and pay TV industry from colluding in its continuing development and deployment for commercial reasons. The technology will improve, aided by neuroscience, and the unpleasant artifacts will diminish without disappearing entirely. Goggle-less viewing will emerge, although this will create a new series of artifacts such as variations in the experience depending on the angle of viewing. But 2D viewing will continue to predominate for movies as well as TV, because it is more relaxing, and allows the brain to indulge the imagination rather than having to work overtime on unfamiliar visual processing.